R v Kolic No. DCCRM-95-1353 Judgment No. D3522

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

Court

DISTRICT COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

Reasons For Ruling of His Honour Judge Robertson

Hearing

23/11/96 to 29/11/96.

Catchwords

Ruling as to the admission in evidence of conversations between the accused and Police Constable - failure to caution - failure to inform specific offences being investigated - evidence excluded in exercise of discretion Ruling as to the admission in evidence of conversation between the accused and Doctor and responses thereafter - whether recorded conversation contained in declaration in indirect speech unfair to the accused - whether answers of the accused were unguarded - application refused.

Materials Considered

• R v Szach (1980) SASR 23 504 at 581-583;
• R v Papadelos 151 LSJS 443, applied.
• R v Dolan (1992) 58 SASR 501 at 505;
• R v Duncan &; Others Judgment D2761;
• R v Hooper (1995) 64 SASR 480;
• McLachlan v Opie (1956) SASR 53, considered.

Representation

R:
Counsel: Mr David Whittle - Solicitors: DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS

Accused Karlo Kolic:
Counsel: Mr David Edwardson - Solicitors: CAMATTA LEMPENS

DCCRM-95-1353

Judgment No. D3522

26 November 1996

(Criminal)

R v KOLIC

Criminal

Judge Robertson

The accused, Karlo Kolic is charged with causing bodily harm by dangerous driving under Section 19a(3) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act, 1935. Particulars of the offence are that the accused on 7 March 1995 at Woodville drove a motor vehicle in a manner which was dangerous to the public and thereby caused grievous bodily harm to Robert Mader.

A voir dire hearing was conducted on 23 November 1996.The accused seeks to have excluded from evidence all conversations between the accused and Christopher William Andrew Pawson, a police officer, contained in Senior Constable Pawson's declaration dated 9 April 1995.The grounds upon which the accused seeks to have the conversation recorded in the declaration excluded are:-

1. That the police officer failed to caution the accused at the commencement of the interview.

2. The police officer failed to inform the accused of the specific offences then being investigated.

On Saturday 8 April 1995, Senior Constable Pawson attended at the accused's home and conducted an interview with the accused.In the first question and answer the accused admitted that he was the driver of a vehicle which was involved in a collision with a motor cycle at the junction of Woodville Road and Norman Street, Woodville on Tuesday 7 March 1995.Thereafter Constable Pawson, for a short time, asked some further questions which involved further details of the accident and some personal details.After informing him that the motor cyclist had sustained serious injuries the following transpired between the accused and Constable Pawson:-

"I said, 'As a result of this conversation, you may be charged with aserious offence.Do you understand this?'

He said, 'Yes'.

I said,'What do you understand this to be?'

He said, 'I understand that the whole books are being thrown against me.I do not remember nothing.I do not remember the bike hitting me.How far do I have to remember?'

I said, 'Let us…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Kolic No. DCCRM-95-1353 Judgment No. D3522 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1996] SADC 3522
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The District Court of South Australia heard a case against Karlo Kolic, who was charged with causing bodily harm by dangerous driving. The incident in question involved a collision between Kolic's vehicle and a motorcycle, resulting in grievous bodily harm to the motorcyclist, Robert Mader. The crux of the legal issues revolved around the admissibility of two sets of recorded conversations: one between Kolic and a police officer, Senior Constable Pawson, and another between Kolic and a doctor, Sonia Curnow. The defence sought to exclude these conversations from evidence on grounds of procedural impropriety and potential unfairness to the accused.

The court examined whether Senior Constable Pawson properly cautioned Kolic and informed him of the specific offences under investigation before their conversation. It was found that Pawson failed to provide a legitimate caution, particularly regarding the nature of the charge of causing bodily harm by dangerous driving. Given this procedural lapse, the court ruled that the conversation between Kolic and Pawson, apart from the initial question and answer, should be excluded from evidence. This decision was influenced by the need to uphold fairness in the investigative process and to discourage improper police methods.

Regarding the conversation between Kolic and Dr. Curnow, the court considered whether the indirect speech format of Dr. Curnow's declaration was unfair to Kolic and whether the timing of the conversation, soon after the accident, rendered his responses unguarded. The court concluded that the indirect speech format did not unfairly prejudice Kolic, as it accurately reflected Dr. Curnow's recollection of the conversation. Furthermore, the court determined that the unguarded nature of Kolic's responses did not necessitate their exclusion from evidence, as fairness must be assessed based on the overall circumstances.

The court denied the defence's application to exclude the evidence from Dr. Curnow, finding that the conversation was admissible. The court's ruling emphasized the importance of balancing the need for fair procedures with the public interest in securing convictions based on reliable evidence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.