R v King and Barns No. Sccrm-01-196, Sccrm-01-198

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

R  v  KING and BARNS
[2002] SASC 140

Court of Criminal Appeal         Doyle CJ, Lander and Besanko JJ

  1. DOYLE CJ, LANDER and BESANKO JJ  This is an appeal against conviction by Marcus Stephen King (“King”) and an appeal against conviction and sentence by Susan Ann Barns (“Barns”).

  2. On 20 December 2001 the Court made the following orders:-

    “1.    The appeal by Mr King against his conviction is dismissed.

    2.The appeal by Ms Barns against her conviction is allowed. The conviction is set aside and we order that there be a retrial on information.”

  3. In those circumstances it was not necessary for the Court to deal with the appeal by Ms Barns against sentence.

  4. We said we would deliver our reasons later.  We now do so.

  5. King was found guilty of the offence of armed robbery[1] after a trial before Judge and jury in the District Court of Adelaide.  The particulars of the offence as set out in the Information were as follows:

    “Marcus Stephen King and Mark Phillip Drumgoon on the 15th of August 1999 at Glengowrie, being armed with an offensive weapon, namely a knife, robbed Marian Vogels of money in the amount of $20,650.00.”

    [1] Section 158 (1) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (“CLCA”)

  6. Barns was charged on the same Information as King. She was tried with him and she was found guilty of the offence of fabricating evidence[2].  The particulars of the offence as set out in the Information as amended were as follows:

    “Susan Ann Barns between the 23rd of August 1999 and the 21st of December 1999 at Morphettville and other places, fabricated evidence with the intention of influencing the outcome of legal proceedings.”

    [2] Section 243 of the CLCA

  7. Towards the end of the trial the trial Judge gave the prosecution leave to amend the particulars of the offence against Barns so that the date of the offence read “between the 23rd of August 1999 and the 21st of December 1999”, instead of “on the 24th of August 1999”.

  8. A third defendant was charged on the same Information. Lee-Ann Julie Bockman (“Bockman”) was also charged with the offence of fabricating evidence contrary to s 243 of the CLCA. She was convicted and has been sentenced. She has not appealed to this Court.

    The Prosecution Case

  9. The prosecution case was that at about 12.20 am on Sunday 15 August 1999, Mark Phillip Drumgoon (“Drumgoon”) carried out an armed robbery at the Morphett Arms Hotel at 138 Morphett Road, Glengowrie in the State of South Australia.  The prosecution case was that King was involved in the planning and execution of the armed robbery.  It was part of a joint enterprise between Drumgoon and King.

  10. It is necessary to say something briefly about the facts alleged by the prosecution.  At the time the robbery took place the hotel was in the process of being locked up.  The duty manager, one Marian Vogels, went to collect the takings from the gaming room, the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v King and Barns No. Sccrm-01-196, Sccrm-01-198 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] SASC 140
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of R v King and Barns, the appellants sought to appeal against their convictions. The respondents, represented by the Director of Public Prosecutions, opposed the appeals. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The central issue before the court was whether the trial judge had erred in admitting certain evidence that was deemed irrelevant during the Rule 9 applications, but was considered significant when presented at the trial. The appellants argued that the evidence in question should not have been admitted as it was irrelevant and not presented during the trial. The respondents, on the other hand, contended that the evidence was relevant and should have been admitted, as it provided crucial context to the other evidence presented.

The court examined the nature and relevance of the evidence provided by Morel and Johnson during the Rule 9 applications and at the trial. The court found that while some of the evidence presented during the Rule 9 applications was irrelevant, the significance of that evidence became apparent when considering the more concise evidence given at the trial. The court held that the trial judge was correct in admitting the evidence, as it provided important context to the other evidence presented and assisted in understanding the case as a whole. The court further held that the evidence was relevant and should have been admitted, as it played a crucial role in establishing the facts of the case.

In conclusion, the court dismissed the appellants' appeals and upheld their convictions. The court found that the trial judge had not erred in admitting the evidence in question, as it was relevant and played an important role in establishing the facts of the case. The court further held that the appellants' arguments regarding the relevance of the evidence were without merit. As a result, the convictions of both appellants were upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Some of the evidence given by Morel and Johnson at the hearing of the Rule 9 applications was irrelevant and was not given at the trial. The real significance of their evidence can be seen from the evidence which they gave at the trial. In other words, the significance of their evidence can be seen from the more concise evidence they gave at the trial. It is to that which we now turn.The Evidence at Trial of Morel and Johnson We start with the evidence of Morel. Morel said that she acted for King in October 1999. She said that she spoke to Barns about the matter on 3 October 1999. She formed the view that it would not be appropriate for her to advise Barns. She referred Barns to Johnson. Morel said that she sent her letter dated 13 October 1999 to the DPP with the statement of position. The “other party” referred to in her letter was Barns. The statement of position had been read by King and he had confirmed that it was correct. Morel wrote to Johnson by letter dated 28 October 1999 asking Johnson to obtain Barns’ instructions to release Barns’ statement to the DPP. Morel wrote to Johnson again by letter dated 3 November 1999 asking Johnson to encourage her client to release her statement. Some time prior to 3 November 1999 Morel had learnt from Johnson that Johnson had advised Barns not to release her statement. Morel wrote to the DPP by letter dated 19 December 1999. The two statements of Barns and Bockman respectively were sent with the letter. Morel had been told by King that she would receive the two statements. The two statements were left in a pigeon hole in her office on 20 December 1999. The letter dated 19 December 1999 and two statements were sent to the DPP on the instructions of King. Morel did not specifically check with Barns or Bockman as to the accuracy of their respective statements, but she knew from the conversation she had had with Barns on 3 October 1999 that what was in the statement was Barns’ version of events. In cross-examination Morel said that acting on instructions from King she disclosed Barns’ name to the DPP saying she was the person who had King’s mobile telephone on the night in question. She said that she sent King’s statement of position to Johnson as well as to the DPP. Morel made it quite clear in her evidence that she had sent the letter dated 19 December 1999 and the two statements to the DPP on instructions from King. We now turn to the evidence of Johnson. Johnson gave evidence that she was contacted by Morel on 14 October 1999 and asked if she was prepared to advise Barns. Johnson spoke to Barns on 16 October 1999. Barns gave her a handwritten statement dated 24 August 1999 and entitled “To whom it may concern”. Barns asked Johnson to prepare a written statement of her version of events and in particular her account of who had possession of King’s mobile telephone on the night in question. She gave Johnson a version of events consistent with what is set out in her subsequent written statement. Johnson advised Barns not to provide a statement to the DPP. Johnson prepared a written statement that she sent to Barns. She spoke with Barns a few days later, and Barns indicated that she would not be providing a statement to the DPP. Johnson so advised Morel.

Decision

Reasons for decision

BESANKO JJ

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BESANKO JJ