R v Kerin Criminal Trial by Judge Alone

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Criminal)

R v KERIN

Criminal Trial by Judge Alone

[2014] SASC 19

Reasons for the Verdicts of The Honourable Justice Blue

21 February 2014

CRIMINAL LAW - PARTICULAR OFFENCES - PROPERTY OFFENCES - THEFT - GENERALLY

CRIMINAL LAW - PROCEDURE - PLEAS - PLEAS IN BAR - PLEA OF AUTREFOIS ACQUIT OR AUTREFOIS CONVICT

CRIMINAL LAW - PROCEDURE - ADJOURNMENT, STAY OF PROCEEDINGS OR ORDER RESTRAINING PROCEEDINGS - STAY OF PROCEEDINGS - ABUSE OF PROCESS

EVIDENCE - DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE - STATUTORY PROVISIONS RELATING TO BUSINESS RECORDS

EQUITY - TRUSTS AND TRUSTEES - POWERS, DUTIES, RIGHTS AND LIABILITIES OF TRUSTEES - INVESTMENT OF TRUST FUNDS - MODE OF INVESTMENT - GENERALLY

Criminal trial by Judge alone. 

The accused is charged with three counts of theft.  Count 1 relates to dealings by the accused under a power of attorney with $200,000 belonging to Miss Fahey transferred by the accused from an investment with AXA to Osvest Pty Ltd, a company of which the accused was Chief Operating Officer, for the purpose of derivatives trading by Osvest.  Counts 2 and 3 are alternatives: they relate to dealings by the accused with share trading assets worth $85,000 which the accused caused to be liquidated and transferred to Osvest’s bank account for derivatives trading and Osvest’s general purposes.  Count 2 alleges that the assets were beneficially owned by the Fahey estate and count 3 alleges in the alternative that they were beneficially owned by the Batten estate.

The accused pleaded not guilty to counts 1 and 2 and autrefois acquit to count 3.  In the alternative, the accused sought a permanent stay of count 3 as an abuse of process.  Upon a ruling that the plea of autrefois acquit was not available, the accused pleaded not guilty to count 3.

Held (convicting the accused of counts 1 and 2):

As to count 1:

1. The accused dealt with the funds of $200,000 without Miss Fahey’s consent because he was acting for the purposes and in the interests of Osvest and himself and not of Miss Fahey. Alternatively, the accused dealt with the funds without Miss Fahey’s consent because he was not acting or seeking to act with reasonable diligence to protect the interests of the donee within the meaning of section 7 of the Powers of Attorney and Agency Act 1984 (SA). The accused did not honestly believe that he was acting with Miss Fahey’s consent (at [285]-[309]).

2.      The accused intended to make a serious encroachment on Miss Fahey’s proprietary rights because he intended to treat her property as his own to dispose of regardless of her rights and to deal with the property in a way that created a substantial risk of which he was aware that she would not get it back or its value would be substantially impaired (at [311]-[312]).

3.      The accused acted dishonestly according to the standards of ordinary people, knew that he was so acting and did not honestly believe that he had…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Kerin Criminal Trial by Judge Alone and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] SASC 19
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved the defendant, Peter Kerin, who was charged with several counts of theft and fraud. The defendant, a former solicitor and financial advisor, was accused of misappropriating funds from a client, Mary Fahey, who had appointed him and his father as attorneys under a power of attorney. The dispute centred on the defendant's actions concerning investments made by Ms. Fahey, particularly a $200,000 investment in AXA and its subsequent transfer to a company called Osvest for derivatives trading. The court had to determine whether the defendant acted dishonestly and without the client's consent when he used her funds for personal and business ventures.

The primary legal issues revolved around the defendant's intent and knowledge when dealing with the client's funds, whether he acted dishonestly according to ordinary standards, and if he honestly believed he had a legal right to use the funds as he did. Another significant issue was the interpretation of the authority granted by the client's representative, Mrs. Wade, and whether it covered the defendant's actions in February 2008. The court also needed to assess if the defendant's actions constituted an abuse of process or if they were within the bounds of the power of attorney.

The court found that the defendant did not act with the honest belief that he had a legal right to use the client's funds as he did. It was established that the defendant used the funds for personal gain and for the benefit of his company, Osvest, without the client's consent. The authority provided by Mrs. Wade did not extend to the transactions carried out by the defendant in February 2008. The court concluded that the defendant acted dishonestly and knew it, misappropriating the client's funds for personal and business purposes without her consent. The evidence demonstrated that the defendant's actions seriously encroached on the client's proprietary rights.

The court's decision was that the defendant was guilty on all counts of theft and fraud. The defendant's actions were found to be deliberate and dishonest, with no honest belief in the legality of his actions. The final orders included the defendant's conviction and sentencing, reflecting the court's determination of the defendant's guilt and the severity of the offenses committed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The accused’s case is that he did not intend to make a serious encroachment on the Batten estate’s proprietary rights. He did not act dishonestly according to the standards of ordinary people, did not know that he was so acting and honestly believed that he had a legal right to act in that way. Background In June 1984, the accused was admitted as a solicitor and barrister of the Supreme Court. Between 1984 and 1987, he was employed as a solicitor at Reilly Ahern & Kerin. His father, Kevin Kerin, was a partner in that firm. In 1987, the accused commenced practise as a solicitor on his own account under the name Peter Kerin & Associates. In 1999, he commenced practise on his own account under the name Millennium Law. He continued to practise as a solicitor until December 2006. Throughout his practise as a solicitor, the accused practised primarily in the field of non-litigious commercial law. His practise included wills and estates. In January 2007, the accused commenced practising as a strategic, business and property development advisor. He practised under the name Strategic & Business Advisory Services. The proprietor of the business was Armalite Finance Pty Ltd (“Armalite”), of which the accused was the sole director and shareholder (holding the shares on trust for Reliability Plus Ltd). The accused used the net income generated by the business to meet his living expenses.Mary Fahey Mary Eileen Fahey was born on 7 May 1907. She was a founding member of The Legion of Mary which was established in 1934. Joan Cahill and Joan Virtucio were fellow members. As at 1985, Miss Fahey lived in a house which she owned at Robsart Street, Parkside (“the Parkside property”). She conducted a bank account with the Commonwealth Bank of Australia (“Miss Fahey’s bank account”). She was a client of Reilly Ahern & Kerin and in particular of Kevin Kerin. On 18 December 1985, Miss Fahey executed an enduring power of attorney appointing Kevin Kerin and the accused as joint and several attorneys (“the Power of Attorney”). They each accepted the appointment and acknowledged that they were subject to the requirements of the Powers of Attorney and Agency Act 1984 (SA). In January 2003, Miss Fahey instructed the accused to prepare a will. On 21 January 2003, Miss Fahey executed the will witnessed by the accused. The will appointed Joan Cahill and Joan Virtucio as executrixes. The will devised the Parkside property (or its proceeds if sold) to Ms Cahill and Ms Virtucio as joint trustees on trust for The Legion of Mary. The balance of the estate was bequeathed to Ms Cahill and Ms Virtucio as joint trustees on trust as to defined assets or percentages for six friends of Miss Fahey or their descendants. By July 2003, Miss Fahey had moved out of her Parkside home into the Lourdes Valley Nursing Home. On 7 October 2005, Miss Fahey was diagnosed with dementia and was accordingly from then on unable to manage her affairs. In October 2005, the accused received a letter from Lourdes Valley Nursing Home saying that Miss Fahey was no longer competent to manage her affairs and enclosing a letter by a doctor certifying that this was so.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

BLUE J
I am satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the accused did not honestly believe that he had a legal or equitable right to deal with the funds of $85,000 in February 2008 for derivatives trading and for the general purposes of Osvest. Conclusion If I had concluded that the Exchange occurred in October 2007, I would have been satisfied beyond reasonable doubt of each of the elements of count 3. Summary of findings I summarise my findings in relation to each count. In respect of count 1, I find beyond reasonable doubt that:1.the accused between 21 September and 2 October 2007 caused $200,000 to be withdrawn from Miss Fahey’s AXA investment and paid into Osvest’s bank account for the purpose of derivatives trading by Osvest and thereby dealt with Miss Fahey’s property; 2.the accused together with Mr Williams opened a derivatives trading account on behalf of Osvest with BrokerOne between 28 September and 23 October 2007;3.in October 2007, the accused together with Mr Williams caused Osvest to appoint Mr Abrahams to conduct derivatives trading on behalf of Osvest;4.as at September/October 2007, the accused did not intend to impose and there was not imposed on Mr Abrahams a trading mandate in respect of the derivatives trading containing the elements asserted by the accused;5.as at September/October 2007 the accused knew that derivatives trading involved high risks;6.the accused caused $250,000 which included $200,000 derived from Miss Fahey’s AXA investment to be transferred from Osvest’s bank account to Osvest’s derivatives trading account on 23 October 2007 for the purpose of derivatives trading by Osvest;7. as at September/October 2007, it was the ambition of Osvest and the accused to establish Osvest as a derivatives trader for the purposes of attracting investment funds;8.the purpose of the accused in withdrawing $200,000 from Miss Fahey’s AXA investment and paying it into Osvest’s bank was to establish Osvest as a derivatives trader;9.if Osvest could establish itself as a derivatives trader and attract investment funds, the accused stood to gain financially by receipt of a commercial remuneration for his role as Chief Operations Officer of Osvest and as a result of Armalite being allocated equity in Osvest;10.the intended use of Miss Fahey’s funds of $200,000 for derivatives trading was not a diversion or distraction from Osvest’s business plan but was part of that plan; 11. in dealing with Miss Fahey’s funds of $200,000, it was not the purpose of the accused to provide a buffer to meet possible future health expenses;12.the accused did not have any firm expectation as at September/October 2007 that Osvest would receive investment trading funds placed by Sigma;13.in dealing with Miss Fahey’s funds of $200,000, the accused was acting for the purposes and in the interests of Osvest and himself and not those of Miss Fahey and for this reason the dealings were without the consent of Miss Fahey;14.in dealing with Miss Fahey’s funds of $200,000, the accused was not acting with reasonable diligence to protect the interests of the donor within the meaning of section 7 of the Powers of Attorney and Agency Act 1984 (SA) and for this reason the dealings were without the consent of Miss Fahey;15.the accused did not honestly believe that he was acting in accordance with the authority conferred by the Power of Attorney and knew that he was acting in the interests and for the purposes of Osvest and himself and not in those of Miss Fahey;16.the accused did not have and did not believe that he had consent to deal with Miss Fahey’s property by reason of his communications with his father;17.the accused intended to treat Miss Fahey’s funds as his own to dispose of regardless of Miss Fahey’s rights so as to constitute a serious encroachment on the proprietary rights of Miss Fahey;18.the accused intended to deal with Miss Fahey’s funds in a way that created a substantial risk, of which he was aware, that she would not get them back or that their value would be substantially impaired so as to constitute a serious encroachment on the proprietary rights of Miss Fahey;19.the accused acted dishonestly according to the standards of ordinary people and knew that he was so acting;20.the accused did not honestly believe that he had a legal or equitable right to deal with Miss Fahey’s funds in the way in which he did.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BLUE J

The letter relevantly stated:RE: AXA - “Generations Investment Portfolio” account #: 0130054 L9 01Further to my telephone calls to you on Friday the 21st of September, 2007 and earlier this week, enclosed herewith is a copy of the letter dated Friday the 21st of September, 2007 from Strategic And Business Advisory Services to Mr. Mark Yeomans at Trilogy Financial Services in relation to a partial redemption of funds currently invested with the AXA – Generations Investment Portfolio account as per your general authorisation to me in this regard.I confirm that the partial redemption will, through the vehicle of Osvest Pty. Ltd. (of which I’m the Chief Operations Officer), be invested through a derivatives trader based in South Melbourne, Victoria until, initially, about the middle of January, 2008 at which time Mr. Paul Williams, the Chairman & Managing Director of Osvest Pty. Ltd. and Mr. Robin Golding, the Chief Investment Officer of Osvest Pty. Ltd., will review the investment so that if, for example, it performs poorly, the funds will be re‑invested with the AXA – Generations Investment Portfolio account as above.… On the face of the letter, Mrs Wade either acquiesced in or authorised the accused investing $100,000 of funds which had been invested with AXA in derivatives trading to be undertaken by a derivatives trader based in South Melbourne, being Mr Abrahams, until about the middle of January 2008. At about the middle of January 2008, the investment was to be reviewed. I am satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the authority given by Mrs Wade to the accused in September 2007 did not authorise the transfer and utilisation of the sum of $85,000 in February 2008. Assuming that Mrs Wade had the capacity to act alone in respect of assets of the Batten estate, the authority which she gave was confined to trading in derivatives over the period from October 2007 to January 2008. She gave no authority to trade in derivatives after January 2008. The authority was given on the basis that the funds would be utilised as the initial derivatives trading in circumstances in which there was no prior trading record. By contrast, the circumstances in February 2008 were very different. Almost the whole of $300,000 which had been invested by Osvest in derivatives trading through Mr Abrahams had been lost. Mr Abrahams had defaulted in repayment of the loan of $100,000 borrowed from Mr Bennett in May 2007 and had admitted to having lost millions of dollars in the 1990s through derivatives trading. The ostensible purpose of the derivatives trading in February 2008 was not to make a return on the new funds invested as such, but rather to recoup the losses suffered by others in October/November 2007. The accused did not suggest that he discussed the proposed derivatives trading with Mrs Wade in February 2008 or obtained any authority from her to engage in such trading at that time. In addition, out of the total sum of $85,000, a total of $45,000 was paid into Osvest’s bank account for the general purposes of Osvest as opposed to being used in derivatives trading. Any authority given by Mrs Wade in September 2007 which might have survived until February 2008 was incapable of authorising the transfer of funds for the general purposes of Osvest as opposed to being utilised in derivatives trading.