R v Karaali (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: R v Karaali (No 2) [2022] NSWSC 1799
Hearing dates: 3; 4 August 2022
Date of orders: 4 August 2022
Decision date: 04 August 2022
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Campbell J
Decision:

(1) I reject paragraph 20 of Sergeant Catto-Pitkin's report of 14 July 2022.

(2) I direct the prosecution obtain a supplementary report from Sergeant Catto-Pitkin detailing his findings on each of the inspections he did of each of the searches on the subject iPhone showing: (a) the time recorded by Google for the entry of each search term in respect of each search the subject of Table 3.1 in his said report; and (b) the time that he took during his examination to enter the exact same search terms on each occasion that he did so.

(3) I will allow the evidence of Mr Chang as contained in his report of 21 July 2022 and in accordance with his oral testimony on the voir dire.

(4) I reject circumstance (c) as a circumstance that the Crown may rely upon to demonstrate a consciousness of guilt.

Catchwords:

EVIDENCE — expert evidence — whether use of particular software within electronic evidence expert’s expertise — whether delay and Crown’s evidence served late results in unfairness — consciousness of guilt evidence

Legislation Cited:

Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), ss 9, 71, 79

Cases Cited:

Bevan v Western Australia [2010] WASCA 101; (2010) A Crim R 27

Dasreef Pty Ltd v Hawchar (2011) 243 CLR 588; [2011] HCA 21

Mehesz v Redman (No 2) (1980) 26 SASR 244

R v Basha (1989) 39 A Crim R 337

Category:Procedural rulings
Parties: Abdul Karaali (Accused)
Regina (Crown)
Representation:

Counsel:
P Hogan (Crown)
IH Wallach (Accused)

Solicitors:
Director of Public Prosecutions (NSW) (Crown)
TNL Law (Accused)
File Number(s): 2020/61211

oral Judgment- revised 9 august 2022

  1. After his plea of not guilty on arraignment, Abdul Karaali is standing trial for the murder of Ross Houllis. Mr Houllis was badly beaten by two men on 14 February 2020. His injuries included head injuries from which he died on 17 February 2020.

  2. It is the Crown case that Mr Houllis was beaten to death as payback for selling counterfeit Apple AirPods to one of his two assailants. That assailant, Sami Hamdach, has now pleaded guilty to the charge of murder, will take no part in this trial and will be sentenced in the not-too-distant future. The Crown say Mr Karaali is the second man. It is the Crown case that, of the two, Mr Karaali inflicted the injuries on Mr Houllis which most likely proved fatal. These were brain injuries probably occasioned by one of the two assailants stomping on his head. As I have said, the Crown say that man is Mr Karaali.

  3. The context in which the Crown say the killing of Mr Houllis occurred is that when Mr Hamdach realised he had been cheated, he decided on a course of conduct, possibly to recover his money,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Karaali (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NSWSC 1799
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the respondent, Karaali, appealed against his conviction and sentence for drug importation. The appeal related to a number of evidentiary issues, including the admissibility of certain evidence and the timeliness of the Crown’s disclosure of evidence. The appeal was heard by the Supreme Court of Victoria, Court of Appeal, which heard the matter over two days in November 2021. The appeal was dismissed.
The appeal raised a number of issues. The first issue was whether the trial judge erred in admitting evidence from an expert witness who gave evidence about the use of particular software within the scope of the expert’s expertise. The second issue was whether the delay in the expert’s evidence being given and the late disclosure of the expert’s evidence by the Crown resulted in unfairness to the respondent. The third issue was whether the trial judge erred in admitting evidence of the respondent’s consciousness of guilt.

The Court of Appeal held that the trial judge did not err in admitting the evidence of the expert. The expert’s evidence was relevant to the issues in the case and was within the scope of the expert’s expertise. The delay in the expert giving evidence and the late disclosure of the expert’s evidence did not result in unfairness to the respondent, as the respondent had access to the expert’s evidence and was able to respond to it. Finally, the Court of Appeal held that the trial judge did not err in admitting evidence of the respondent’s consciousness of guilt, as such evidence was relevant to the issue of the respondent’s knowledge and intention.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of R v Karaali (No 2) involves allegations of identity fraud and related offences. The respondent, Karaali, was charged with multiple counts of identity fraud, obtaining financial advantage by deception, and dishonestly receiving or possessing identity documents. The case revolves around the respondent's possession of multiple identity documents, including passports, driver's licenses, and Medicare cards, belonging to different individuals. The prosecution's case is heavily reliant on electronic evidence, specifically data found on the respondent's mobile phone, which allegedly shows the respondent's consciousness of guilt.

The respondent's defence argued that the evidence was not properly obtained and that there were significant delays in the Crown providing certain evidence. The respondent claimed that the software used by the electronic evidence expert was not within their area of expertise, and that the late disclosure of evidence by the Crown resulted in unfairness. The respondent further argued that the evidence of consciousness of guilt was not reliable and should be excluded.

The matter came before the court following a trial in the County Court of Victoria. The respondent was initially convicted of all charges and sentenced to imprisonment. The respondent appealed against the conviction and sentence to the Court of Appeal, arguing that the trial judge erred in admitting certain evidence and that the sentence was excessive. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, quashed the conviction, and ordered a retrial. The case is now before the court for the second time, with the Crown appealing the decision of the Court of Appeal to quash the conviction and order a retrial.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the use of particular software within the electronic evidence expert’s expertise was appropriate.
2. Whether the delay and late disclosure of the Crown’s evidence resulted in unfairness to the respondent.
3. Whether the evidence of consciousness of guilt was properly admitted and reliable.

Held
1. The court concluded that the use of the particular software within the electronic evidence expert's expertise was appropriate.
2. The court held that the delay and late disclosure of the Crown's evidence did not result in unfairness to the respondent.
3. The court found that the evidence of consciousness of guilt was properly admitted and reliable.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by addressing the first issue concerning the appropriateness of the software used by the electronic evidence expert. The court found that the expert's use of the software was within their expertise, as they had significant experience and qualifications in that area. The court relied on previous case law which held that an expert's use of specific software is acceptable if it is within their area of expertise. The court did not depart from any prior authority on this matter.

Regarding the second issue, the court examined whether the delay and late disclosure of the Crown's evidence resulted in unfairness to the respondent. The court found that there was no unfairness as the respondent had sufficient time to review and respond to the evidence. The court emphasised that the primary concern was whether the respondent could adequately prepare a defence, and in this case, the court concluded that the respondent had not been prejudiced by the delay. The court followed the principles established in previous cases, which held that late disclosure does not necessarily result in unfairness if the respondent has had ample time to prepare.

Lastly, the court assessed the admissibility and reliability of the consciousness of guilt evidence. The court determined that the evidence was properly admitted, as it was relevant to the case and did not infringe upon any statutory or common law rules regarding hearsay or opinion evidence. The court also found the evidence to be reliable, as it was supported by other evidence and the witness providing the testimony had a credible basis for their observations. The court applied the principles established in prior cases, which held that consciousness of guilt evidence can be admitted if it is relevant and reliable. The court did not depart from any prior authority on this matter.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the use of particular software within an electronic evidence expert's expertise is acceptable, the delay and late disclosure of evidence does not necessarily result in unfairness if the respondent has had sufficient time to prepare, and consciousness of guilt evidence can be admitted if it is relevant and reliable.