R v John George Borg, Douglas John Frederick Carroll, Wayne Frederick Fear No.2

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

District Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: R v John George BORG, Douglas John Frederick CARROLL, Wayne Frederick FEAR    No.2.; FEAR: Verdict by Direction Application [2015] NSWDC 116
Hearing dates:1 June 2015 to 2 July 2015
Date of orders: 22 June 2015
Decision date: 22 June 2015
Jurisdiction:Criminal
Before: A Haesler SC DCJ
Decision:

There is no basis in law or fact to direct a verdict of acquittal. The application is refused

Catchwords: Verdict by Direction; DNA profile match; Circumstantial case; DNA only evidence of identity.
Cases Cited: R v Adams [1996] 2 Cr App R 467
Aytugrul v The Queen (2012) 215 A Crim R 501; (2012) 247 CLR 170
R v Doheny and Adams (1997) 1 Cr App R 369
Fitzgerald v The Queen [2014] HC 14
Forbes v R [2009] ACTCA 10
Forbes v The Queen [2010] HCA Trans 120
R v Green, unreported CCA NSW 26/3/1993
R v Gumm [2007] SASC 311
R v Hillier [2007] HCA 13; (2007) 228 CLR
R v Hillier [2010] ACTSC 33
R v JCG (2001) 127 A Crim R 493
R v Karger (2001) 83 SASR 1
R v Karger (2002) 83 SASR 135
Maguire v HM Advocate [2003] SLT 1307.
R v Milat (19960 87 A Crim R 446 at 447
R v Noll [1999] 3 VR 704
DA v Osbourne 556 US -2009
R v Pantoja (1996) 88 A Crim R 554
R v R (1989) 44 A Crim R 404
R v Reed [2009] EWCA 2698
R v Rowe [2004] SASC 427
Rush 672 NYS 2d 362
Talay v R [2010] NSWCCA
Tuite v R [2015] VSCA 148
R v Watters [2000] EWCA 81
Category:Procedural and other rulings
Parties: Crown (Director Public Prosecutions)
John George BORG
Douglas John Frederick CARROLL
Wayne Frederick FEAR
Representation:

Counsel:
Mr M McColm (Director Public Prosecutions)
Mr K Buckman (for Borg)
Mr S Siva (for Carroll)
Mr F Coyne (For Fear)

  Solicitors:
Ms K Parker (Director Public Prosecutions)
Mark Klees & Associates, (for Borg)
Mr T Sellathambu, Legal Aid NSW, (for Carroll)
Ms C Khurana, AKN Associates, (for Fear)
File Number(s):2013/93716;2013/93858;2013/93667

Judgment

FEAR- Verdict by Direction Application

Introduction

  1. On 2 June 2015 a jury was empanelled to try John George Borg, Douglas Frederick Carroll and Wayne Frederick Fear. Mr Borg is tried as an accessory before the fact; Mr Carroll and Mr Fear as principals.

  2. The Crown allege Borg wanted his Mazda RX 8 destroyed so that he could claim insurance, the agreed value being more than he had recently paid for it. On 29 November 2012 the vehicle was under repair at Classic Body Repairs, Asquith. It is not in dispute that it had been taken there following an earlier failed attempt by Borg to have it destroyed. It is alleged Carroll and Fear together, at Borg’s instigation, broke into Classic Body repairs that night and lit a fire in the Mazda and 3 other vehicles. Those fires destroyed the Mazda and many other…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v John George Borg, Douglas John Frederick Carroll, Wayne... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NSWDC 116
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The defendants, John George Borg, Douglas John Frederick Carroll, and Wayne Frederick Fear No.2, were charged in relation to an armed robbery. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales where the defendants applied for a verdict by direction of acquittal. The basis of the application was that the only evidence of their identities was a DNA profile match, which was alleged to be insufficient to establish a circumstantial case against them.

The court was required to determine whether the evidence presented, which was solely reliant on DNA profile matching, was sufficient to allow the case to proceed to the jury. The legal issue was whether the circumstantial case, when considered alongside the DNA evidence, was sufficient to warrant a trial. The court also had to consider whether there was any basis to direct an acquittal, which would have prevented the case from proceeding to the jury.

The court found that the circumstantial evidence, when considered in conjunction with the DNA profile match, was sufficient to establish a prima facie case against the defendants. The DNA evidence, while not conclusive, provided a strong link to the crime scene and, when combined with other evidence, was enough to allow the case to proceed to the jury. The court held that there was no basis in law or fact to direct a verdict of acquittal. The application was refused, allowing the case to continue to trial.

Orders

Orders of the court

There is no basis in law or fact to direct a verdict of acquittal. The application is refused

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established