CITATION: R v Ibrahim [2009] NSWSC 1181 HEARING DATE(S): 22 October 2009, 23 October 2009, 27 October 2009, 30 October 2009
JUDGMENT DATE :
3 November 2009JUDGMENT OF: Johnson J at 1 DECISION: Conditional bail granted. CATCHWORDS: CRIMINAL LAW - bail - conspiracy to murder - significant medical treatment requirements of applicant - Crown not oppose bail - stringent bail conditions proposed - bail granted LEGISLATION CITED: Bail Act 1978 CATEGORY: Principal judgment PARTIES: Fadi Ibrahim (Applicant)
Regina (Respondent)FILE NUMBER(S): SC 2009/213165 SOLICITORS: Mr B Galloway - Galloways Solicitors & Attorneys (Applicant)
Ms N Paul - Director of Public Prosecutions (NSW)
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISIONJohnson J
3 November 2009
2009/213165 R v Fadi Ibrahim
Video Link from Long Bay HospitalJUDGMENT (Application for Bail)
1 JOHNSON J: This is an application for bail by Fadi Ibrahim, who is to appear at Central Local Court on 26 November 2009 with respect to a charge of conspiracy to murder.
2 As s.9 Bail Act 1978 does not apply to a charge of conspiracy to murder, there is no presumption in favour of bail: s.9(1)(c). In addition, there is no presumption in favour of bail as the Applicant is charged with an indictable offence and has previously been convicted of an indictable offence: s.9B(3) Bail Act 1978. Accordingly, there is no presumption for or against the grant of bail in this case.
3 The hearing of this application extended over parts of several hearing days - 22, 23, 27 and 30 October 2009. Oral and documentary evidence was adduced, with particular reference to the Applicant’s state of health and the medical treatment which had been provided to him in custody, and which would be available in the event that he remained in custody.
The 5 June 2009 Attack
4 The Applicant is 35 years old. On the evening of 5 June 2009, the Applicant was attacked outside his home at Castle Cove and suffered five gunshot wounds, two to the right chest, two to the right arm and one to the right shoulder. He was conveyed to the Royal North Shore Hospital where he received emergency treatment. The medical evidence before the Court indicates that the Applicant received life-threatening injuries requiring surgical intervention.
5 The Applicant remained in hospital until 29 June 2009. During that period, he underwent a total gastrectomy (removal of his whole stomach) and a partial esophagectomy (removal of part of the oesophagus), repair and patching of the right axillary artery and open reduction and internal fixation of the right clavicle.
The Alleged Offence
6 The charge against the Applicant alleges a conspiracy between the Applicant, his younger brother Michael Ibrahim, Rodney Atkinson, Amerigo Gerace and Jim Said Habkouk to murder John Macris. The prosecution alleges that the motive for this conspiracy was mainly in retaliation for the attempted murder of the Applicant on 5 June 2009.
7 The case against the Applicant is dependent upon telephone intercept…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Ibrahim and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] NSWSC 1181
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the principle that bail should be granted unless there are substantial reasons to the contrary, particularly considering the Crown’s lack of opposition. The judge recognised that Ibrahim’s medical needs could be managed through bail conditions. The stringent conditions proposed by the Crown were considered in the context of ensuring that Ibrahim would not pose a risk to the community and would comply with his medical treatment requirements. The court concluded that the stringent conditions would sufficiently mitigate any risk, allowing for the granting of bail. The court’s decision was influenced by the Crown’s non-opposition and the applicant’s commitment to his medical appointments.
In granting bail, the court imposed stringent conditions that included regular check-ins with a supervising officer, adherence to a strict curfew, and mandatory attendance at all medical appointments. The court was satisfied that these conditions adequately addressed the risk of flight and the danger to the community while accommodating Ibrahim’s medical needs. The decision underscored the importance of balancing individual rights with public safety considerations, particularly in cases where the Crown does not oppose bail. The final orders of the court were that Ibrahim be granted bail subject to the stringent conditions outlined in the judgment.
Background
Background to the litigation
The applicant's medical condition required him to attend hospital appointments and receive treatment on a regular basis. This necessitated the imposition of stringent bail conditions to ensure Ibrahim's presence at medical appointments while also maintaining public safety. The Crown's lack of opposition to bail hinged on the implementation of strict conditions that would adequately address these concerns.
The matter came before the court on an application for bail by the applicant, Ibrahim. This was a bail application in the context of Ibrahim's charges for conspiracy to murder. Prior to this hearing, there had been no significant procedural steps taken in relation to the bail application. The Crown had indicated it would not oppose the granting of bail, provided certain stringent conditions were met. The court was thus required to determine whether bail should be granted and, if so, what conditions should be imposed.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether bail should be granted to the applicant, Ibrahim, given his charges of conspiracy to murder and his significant medical treatment requirements?
2. If bail is to be granted, what stringent bail conditions should be imposed to ensure public safety while accommodating the applicant's medical needs?
Held
1. The court concluded that bail should be granted to the applicant, Ibrahim, despite his charges of conspiracy to murder, due to the Crown not opposing bail and the applicant's significant medical treatment requirements.
2. The court determined that stringent bail conditions should be imposed to ensure public safety while accommodating the applicant's medical needs.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the application for bail of Ibrahim, who was charged with conspiracy to murder, while also considering his significant medical treatment requirements. The Crown did not oppose the granting of bail, which was a significant factor in the court's decision-making process. The primary legal principle applied by the court was the balance between the presumption of innocence and the need to protect the community. The court referred to previous cases that established the criteria for granting bail, particularly in cases involving serious charges such as conspiracy to murder, and the necessity of stringent conditions to mitigate potential risks to the public.
The court acknowledged the serious nature of the charges against Ibrahim but recognised the Crown's lack of opposition to bail, which indicated that there were no overriding concerns that would prevent the granting of bail. The court then turned its attention to the applicant's significant medical treatment requirements. It was noted that the applicant's health needs could not be neglected, and granting bail would allow him to continue receiving necessary medical care. The court applied the principle that an applicant's medical needs are a relevant consideration in the bail decision-making process, especially when they are significant.
In determining the stringent bail conditions to be imposed, the court considered the need to protect the public while accommodating the applicant's medical needs. The court set strict conditions, including regular reporting to a designated officer, electronic monitoring, and restrictions on movement and communication, to ensure that Ibrahim complied with the terms of his bail and did not pose a risk to the community. The court also required that the applicant adhere to his medical treatment schedule and report any changes in his health status to the bail authority promptly.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that in cases where an applicant charged with a serious offence such as conspiracy to murder is not opposed to bail by the Crown and has significant medical treatment requirements, the court may grant bail with stringent conditions that balance the applicant's need for medical care with the need to protect the public. The court's decision followed established legal principles regarding bail and the consideration of an applicant's medical needs, without departing from prior authority.