| COURT OF APPEAL | [1992] QCA 178 |
| FITZGERALD P DAVIES JA DEMACK J | |
| CA NO 65 OF 1992 | |
| THE QUEEN | |
| v. | |
| BRENDAN RONALD HAY | Applicant |
| BRISBANE | |
| ... DATE 9/6/92 JUDGMENT |
THE PRESIDENT: The applicant pleaded guilty in the District
Court at Cairns on 30 January 1992 to one count of assault
occasioning bodily harm, with a circumstance of aggravation, that is that it was carried out in company and one count of
stealing. He was jointly charged with one Jason Rory O'Brien who was similarly charged. They also pleaded guilty to both offences at the same time.
In respect of the first count, the assault occasioning bodily
harm in company, each was sentenced to 18 months' imprisonment
and in respect of the second count, stealing; each was sentenced to 12 months' imprisonment to be served concurrently. The
applicant and his co-accused O'Brien, together with at least two other men, one of whom was named Brettschneider, went in the evening of 2 April 1990 to the Cairns home of the complainant at the urging of Brettschneider who claimed to the applicant and
others that the complainant had an item of property belonging to him and when the complainant opened his door he was set upon by
members of the group who were urged on by Brettschneider to
attack him.
The complainant was punched, kicked, threatened by the co-
accused with a knife, dragged around the room and had his head rammed through a fibro wall. The attack ceased when one of the group gave an alarm that someone was coming.
Brettschneider took a number of gold ornaments from the person
of the complainant and the group left the complainant dazed and
injured on the floor of his house when they fled.
The applicant was in possession of some of the gold ornaments
the following day, and actually gave one piece to a female
friend. The applicant was interviewed by the police in Brisbane
on 3 March 1991 and denied any involvement. He actually lodged a notice of alibi in connection with this matter. The applicant's decision to enter a plea of guilty did not follow until after he had been implicated by the co-accused O'Brien.
The learned sentencing Judge correctly described the offences as
the act of thugs and gangsters, consisting of a cowardly attack
by a gang of men on an unarmed, and partly unsighted man, in his
own home in the night involving extreme violence and force.
On the other hand, His Honour gave weight to all the factors
mentioned in mitigation on behalf to the application before him, including his good work history and prospects, and that
Brettschneider was the ring-leader, and had not himself faced
charges over the incident, and that the applicant had belatedly
cooperated with the police.
However, His Honour decided that there should be a parity of
sentencing between the applicant and the co-accused after taking into account that O'Brien had spent time in custody; that
O'Brien had cooperated with the police, that O'Brien had…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Hay and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1992] QCA 178
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central issue for the Court of Appeal was whether the sentence imposed by the District Court was manifestly excessive, given the circumstances of the case and the sentencing principles applicable. The Court was required to consider whether there was any error of principle in the sentencing Judge's approach, and whether the sentence fell outside the range of sentences imposed in comparable cases.
The Court of Appeal found that the sentencing Judge had correctly considered the aggravating and mitigating factors in arriving at the sentence. The Court observed that the offences were of a serious nature, involving a violent attack on an unarmed man in his own home. The Court also noted that the applicant had no previous criminal history and had shown some cooperation with the police. However, the Court held that the sentence was not manifestly excessive, and that there was no error of principle in the sentencing Judge's approach. The Court therefore dismissed the appeal and refused the application for leave to appeal.
The final orders of the Court of Appeal were that the application for leave to appeal against sentence be refused.
Background
Background to the litigation
The applicant, along with his co-accused O'Brien, pleaded guilty in the District Court at Cairns on 30 January 1992 to one count of assault occasioning bodily harm, with a circumstance of aggravation, and one count of stealing. The applicant was sentenced to 18 months' imprisonment for the assault and 12 months' imprisonment for the stealing, with the sentences to be served concurrently. The applicant appealed the sentence, but the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the sentence imposed by the District Court was outside the range demonstrated by other sentences in comparable matters.
2. Whether the sentence was manifestly excessive.
Held
1. The Court of Appeal concluded that the sentence imposed by the District Court was not outside the range demonstrated by other sentences in comparable matters and therefore dismissed the application on this ground.
2. The Court of Appeal also concluded that the sentence was not manifestly excessive, and again dismissed the application on this ground.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal examined the circumstances of the case and the sentence imposed by the District Court. The Court considered that the offences were serious, involving a cowardly attack on an unarmed man in his own home, which included extreme violence and force. The Court acknowledged the mitigating factors presented on behalf of the applicant, such as his good work history and prospects, his late cooperation with the police, and the fact that the ringleader of the group had not faced charges. However, the Court found that the sentencing judge had appropriately balanced these mitigating factors against the gravity of the offences and the need for parity in sentencing with the co-accused. The Court noted that the applicant had no previous history of any materiality and that there was no error of principle in the sentencing judge's remarks. Given these considerations, the Court of Appeal held that the sentence imposed was within the appropriate range and was not manifestly excessive, leading to the dismissal of the application. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that in cases of serious offences involving violence and in the absence of any error of principle, a sentence that is within the range demonstrated by other sentences in comparable matters is not to be regarded as manifestly excessive.