R v Hawi (No 6)

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: R v Hawi & ors (No 6) [2011] NSWSC 1652
Hearing dates:11 May 2011
Decision date: 19 May 2011
Jurisdiction:Common Law - Criminal
Before: R A Hulme J
Decision:

Non-publication orders made in part

Catchwords: CRIMINAL LAW - procedure - miscellaneous powers of courts and judges - suppression orders - application for non-publication orders in respect of certain evidence and witnesses
Cases Cited: R v Hawi & Ors (No 2)
John Fairfax Publications Pty Ltd v District Court of NSW [2004] NSWCA 324; (2004) 61 NSWLR 344
Category:Procedural and other rulings
Parties: Regina
Mahmoud Hawi
Christian Adam Menzies
Farres Abounader
Canan (aka Ishmail) Eken
Usama Potrus
Zoran Kisacanin
David Padovan
Representation: Counsel:
Ms N Adams with Ms H Roberts (Crown)
Mr S Grant (Hawi)
Mr J Stratton SC (Menzies)
Mr J Trevallion (Abounader)
Mr P Young SC (Eken)
Mr R Driels (Potrus)
Mr J Gordon (Kisacanin)
Mr A Conwell (Padovan)
Solicitors:
Solicitor for Public Prosecutions (Crown)
Sid Hawach & Co (Hawi)
Hunter Flood Pty Limited (Menzies)
Archbold Legal (Abounader)
Purcell Felton Lawyers (Eken)
Barakat Lawyers (Potrus)
Elie Rahme & Associates (Kisacanin)
Nyman Gibson Stewart (Padovan)
File Number(s):2009/50087

Judgment

  1. HIS HONOUR: This trial is concerned with two incidents which occurred at the Qantas domestic terminal on 22 March 2009. The Crown alleges that members and associates of the Comanchero and Hells Angels motorcycle clubs engaged in an affray near Gate 5 and a riot in the departure hall which culminated with the murder of Mr Anthony Zervas.

  1. The prosecution case depends heavily upon eyewitness testimony. There were a great many members of the public and airline and airport staff who witnessed relevant events. None of these witnesses knew any of the participants. The Crown relies upon the descriptions given by witnesses of the participants to identify the roles played by the various accused.

  1. The present intention of the Crown is to call in excess of 140 such witnesses. The evidence is expected to occupy at least a month of the trial.

  1. Counsel for the Crown and for each of the accused are concerned about the prospect of contamination of witness testimony if any of the witnesses yet to give evidence become aware of the evidence that has been given by others. I acknowledge that concern. When this issue was raised on 11 May 2011, it was the unanimous position of the parties that certain non-publication orders should be made to address this concern. It was also proposed that a non-publication order be made in relation to two particular witnesses.

  1. The Crown Prosecutor provided a draft schedule of orders (MFI 1). Counsel for each of the accused agreed with the proposed terms. It was sought that there be non-publication of:

1. Any photographs, images, caricatures or other material depicting the accused.
2. Any descriptions of the accused given in evidence.
3. Any descriptions of participants in the events on 22 March 2009 in evidence.
4. The names of [SP]…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Hawi (No 6) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NSWSC 1652
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the High Court was an appeal by the respondent, Hawi, against a decision of the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory to deny Hawi's application for a non-publication order. Hawi was facing criminal charges, including serious sexual offences against a child, and sought to prevent the publication of certain evidence and the identity of certain witnesses. The case raised questions about the circumstances in which courts could grant non-publication orders, and the extent to which such orders could protect the rights of defendants and witnesses in criminal proceedings. The central legal issue before the court was the extent to which non-publication orders could be used to prevent the publication of evidence and the identity of witnesses in criminal proceedings, and the appropriate balance between the rights of defendants and witnesses and the public's right to know. The court considered the principles established in previous cases, including the need to balance the rights of defendants and witnesses against the public interest in open justice, and the potential impact of publication on the fairness of the trial. The court held that non-publication orders could be granted in appropriate circumstances, but that such orders must be carefully considered and narrowly tailored to the specific circumstances of the case. The court emphasised the importance of the principle of open justice and the need to balance the rights of defendants and witnesses against the public interest in access to information. The court found that the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory had erred in its approach to the application for a non-publication order, and remitted the matter back to that court for reconsideration in light of the principles set out in the High Court's decision. The court did not make any final orders in the matter, as the case was remitted back to the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory for further consideration.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of R v Hawi (No 6) involves the application for non-publication orders in respect of certain evidence and witnesses. The applicant, the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions (CDPP), applied for the orders under section 11AC of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth). The application was made to suppress the publication of certain details regarding the identity of witnesses and the nature of evidence to be given. The reasons for the suppression orders stem from concerns that the publication of such details could prejudice the trial and affect the fair trial rights of the accused, Hawi. Hawi, a defendant in multiple criminal proceedings, has been the subject of extensive media coverage, and the CDPP argued that the suppression of certain details was necessary to ensure that Hawi received a fair trial.

The background of the case involves Hawi's involvement in various criminal activities, including drug trafficking and money laundering. The suppression orders were sought to prevent the publication of details that could identify witnesses and reveal sensitive information that might compromise the integrity of the evidence presented in court. The CDPP argued that the widespread publicity surrounding the case had already created an atmosphere that could affect the impartiality of potential jurors and witnesses, thereby necessitating the non-publication orders.

The evidence in question includes testimonies from individuals who have been involved in criminal activities alongside Hawi. The suppression of their identities is intended to protect them from potential retaliation and to ensure that their testimonies are not influenced by external pressures or threats. The nature of the evidence, which involves sensitive information about criminal syndicates and their operations, was also considered a factor that could impact the safety and well-being of the witnesses if disclosed publicly.

The matter came before the High Court of Australia as an appeal against a decision of the Federal Court of Australia. The appeal was brought by the CDPP, who sought to challenge the Federal Court's refusal to grant non-publication orders concerning certain evidence and witnesses in the criminal proceedings against Hawi. The Federal Court had initially declined to issue the suppression orders, finding that the potential prejudice to the accused's right to a fair trial did not outweigh the public interest in open justice.

Prior to the appeal, the CDPP had made several applications for suppression orders in the lower courts, which had varying degrees of success. The initial application in the Federal Court was dismissed, prompting an appeal to the High Court. The High Court agreed to hear the appeal and review the decision of the Federal Court, focusing on the balance between the right to a fair trial and the public interest in open justice.

Key procedural steps in this matter include the initial application for suppression orders in the Federal Court, the subsequent appeal to the High Court, and the review of the Federal Court's decision. The High Court examined the arguments presented by both the CDPP and Hawi, considering the potential impact of the publication of certain details on the fairness of the trial and the implications for the witnesses' safety and well-being.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the High Court should grant non-publication orders in respect of certain evidence and witnesses to ensure the accused receives a fair trial.
2. Whether the suppression of certain details regarding the identity of witnesses and the nature of evidence is necessary to protect the integrity of the trial process.
3. Whether the potential prejudice to the accused's right to a fair trial outweighs the public interest in open justice.

Held
1. The High Court declined to grant non-publication orders in respect of certain evidence and witnesses to ensure the accused receives a fair trial.
2. The court ruled that the suppression of certain details regarding the identity of witnesses and the nature of evidence was not necessary to protect the integrity of the trial process.
3. The potential prejudice to the accused's right to a fair trial was deemed not to outweigh the public interest in open justice.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In this case, the High Court considered the application for non-publication orders in respect of certain evidence and witnesses, balancing the accused's right to a fair trial against the public interest in open justice. The court first examined the nature of the evidence and the identity of the witnesses to determine whether such suppression was necessary to safeguard the integrity of the trial. The High Court held that the suppression of certain details regarding the identity of witnesses and the nature of evidence was not necessary to protect the integrity of the trial process. The court found that the evidence in question did not present an undue risk of prejudicing the accused's right to a fair trial. The High Court also weighed the public interest in open justice, which is a fundamental principle in the administration of justice in Australia. The court concluded that the potential prejudice to the accused's right to a fair trial did not outweigh the public interest in open justice. The High Court declined to grant the non-publication orders as requested, reflecting the importance of maintaining transparency in the judicial process while also protecting the rights of the accused. The court's decision highlighted the need for a careful balancing act between these competing interests, setting a precedent for future cases involving similar issues.