R v Hatchard No. Sccrm-98-217 Judgment No. S111

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

R  v  HATCHARD
[1999] SASC 111

COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL:   Millhouse, Prior and Duggan JJ

  1. MILLHOUSE J.       Broadly for the reasons given by Duggan J I agree that the appeal should be dismissed.

  2. PRIOR J.          I agree with the reasons published by Duggan J.   The verdict is not unreasonable.  It can be supported having regard to the evidence and the credibility findings made by the trial judge.   No miscarriage of justice has been established.  The appel must therefore be dismissed.

  3. DUGGAN J.     This is an appeal by the appellant against a conviction for the offence of rape.   He was convicted at a trial by judge alone.   It was argued on appeal that the learned trial judge failed to warn himself adequately of the danger of convicting on the unsupported evidence of the complainant on account of the lateness of the complaint.   The appellant also claimed that the verdict was unreasonable because of the unsatisfactory nature of the evidence.

  4. It was alleged at the trial that  on 7th  February 1994 the appellant had intercourse with the complainant without her consent by placing his finger into her vagina.  The complainant was 19 years of age at the time of the alleged offence.

  5. The allegations arose in the following circumstances.  In August 1993 the complainant was involved in motor accident when she tore the cartilage of one of her knees.  The injury caused her ongoing pain and some friends recommended that she undergo treatment by the appellant.  He does not have any formal medical qualifications, but the complainant was told that he was able to relieve pain.

  6. The complainant’s first visit to the appellant took place at a private home on 15th September 1993.  The appellant asked her to lie on a treatment table and he attached two discs to her knee.  The discs were connected to a machine and she said that they had a “biting” effect when the machine was turned on.  In the course of discussion with the appellant during this treatment the complainant told him that she had a condition known as polycystic ovary disease which affected the reproductive system.   She said he was aware of the nature of the disease, a matter which impressed her.   He then told her that in the past he had assisted a number of women who had difficulty becoming pregnant and he suggested that he might be able to help her in this respect.   She asked him how and he said that he could manipulate certain muscles which would have the effect of stimulating the ovaries.   The treatment for the complainant’s knee was then completed and she left the premises after paying her account.   She said she paid the money to a woman she believed was the appellant’s wife.   Before she left the appellant suggested that she make an appointment for further treatment.

  7. During a second visit to the appellant on 22nd November 1993 the treatment with the discs was repeated.   When the discs were removed from the complainant’s knee the appellant commenced…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Hatchard No. Sccrm-98-217 Judgment No. S111 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] SASC 111
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of R v Hatchard was an appeal against a conviction for the offence of rape. The appellant was convicted at a trial by judge alone and argued on appeal that the learned trial judge failed to warn himself adequately of the danger of convicting on the unsupported evidence of the complainant on account of the lateness of the complaint. The appellant also claimed that the verdict was unreasonable because of the unsatisfactory nature of the evidence. The complainant alleged that on 7 February 1994 the appellant had intercourse with her without her consent by placing his finger into her vagina. The appellant did not have any formal medical qualifications, but the complainant was told that he was able to relieve pain. The appellant suggested that he might be able to help her with her reproductive system. During a second visit to the appellant, he asked if he could go further and manipulate the muscles a little higher. The complainant said she was embarrassed and did not know what to say when the appellant spoke to her about these matters on this occasion. The appellant then asked if she would be interested in him carrying out his treatment on her. The complainant said she said "No" when he asked her if she was interested in doing this for her. The complainant had no contact with the appellant again until 7 February 1994 when she went to see him for treatment after she had a horse riding accident. She injured her ankle and knee in the accident. The appellant asked her to lie on the examination table. He applied the discs and later massaged her knee. According to the complainant the appellant then began discussing the topic he had raised during the last visit concerning the complainant’s orgasms. Eventually his hands moved up towards the complainant’s groin area as the massage continued and, according to the complainant, the appellant said: “Whilst I’m here and massaging you and manipulating these muscles, would you like me to manipulate the muscle for you to help you enjoy sex and orgasm much easier?” The complainant said she became flustered. She said she asked the appellant what it was that he did and he told her that there were certain muscles which he could manipulate to “stimulate the sexual parts”. He did not say anything further as to what that involved. The complainant said that the appellant told her he needed to “manipulate the muscles up at this height because they are all connected”. She said he was using medical terms. The complainant said she got the impression that the appellant was talking so as to take her mind off what he was doing physically and it was then that he inserted his finger into her vagina. The complainant said he pulled her knickers to one side in order to gain access to her vagina. The learned trial judge set out the complainant’s evidence in some detail in his judgment and stated that he had scrutinized it with particular care. He said he found her to be a witness of truth and, despite the late reporting of the matter, he found her to be reliable. His Honour said he did not take into account the fact that the appellant did not give evidence at the trial. He was satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that penetration of the complainant’s vagina took place; that the complainant did not consent to the penetration; and that there was no reasonable possibility that the appellant was mistaken and believed that the complainant had agreed to the digital penetration. The Court of Criminal Appeal dismissed the appeal against conviction.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

MILLHOUSE J PRIOR J DUGGAN J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MILLHOUSE J, PRIOR J, DUGGAN J

Full text does not contain this section.