R v. Hargraves, Hargraves and Stoten

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:  R v Hargraves, Hargraves and Stoten [2008] QSC 267
PARTIES:  R
v
GLEN LUKE HARGRAVES
(first applicant)
ADAM JOHN HARGRAVES
(second applicant)
DANIEL ARAN STOTEN
(third applicant)
FILE NO/S:  Indictment No 418 of 2008
DIVISION:  Trial
PROCEEDING:  Criminal Application
COURT:  Supreme Court at Brisbane
DELIVERED ON:  23 October 2008
DELIVERED AT:  Brisbane
HEARING DATE:  23 October 2008
JUDGE:  Fryberg J
ORDER:  As per schedule

CATCHWORDS: 

Criminal law – Jurisdiction, practice and procedure – Other matters – Disclosure of documents by prosecution – Deemed possession – Requirements

Statutes – Acts of parliament – Interpretation – Particular words and phrases – Specific interpretations – “And” – Means “or”

Criminal Code 1899 (Qld) s 590AE
R v Rollason and Jenkins; Ex parte Attorney General [2008]
1 Qd R 85 referred to
COUNSEL:  First applicant: B Walker SC with CFC Wilson
Second and third applicants: M Byrne QC with A Gundelach
Respondent: A McSporran SC with C Toweel
SOLICITORS:  All applicants: Ryan and Boscher Lawyers
Respondent: Director of Public Prosecutions
(Commonwealth)

SCHEDULE

1

It is ordered that:

1.          The Crown provide to the legal representatives of the Applicant the following material:

A.         A complete copy of the transcripts of the evidence that Mr Phillip

Jepson Egglishaw provided to the Australian Crime Commission on the

following dates:  10
(a)  17 February 2004;
(b)  19 February 2004;
(c)  20 February 2004;
(d)  26 February 2004;
(e)  1 March 2004.
B. 
A copy of exhibit No. M04/0037/003, namely the statement of Mr P J 20
Egglishaw referred to in the examination conducted at 2.20pm on
Friday the 20th of February 2004.

C.         A copy of exhibit No. M04/0037/004, namely the folder of documents referred to and set out in Appendix “A” to statement of Mr P J Egglishaw referred to in the examination of Mr Egglishaw at 2.20pm on Friday the 20th February 2004.

D.
A copy of exhibit No. M04/0037/006, namely the copy of document 30
cover of which reads “Strachans Tax Planning And Off-shore
Administration” 85 referred to in the examination of Mr Egglishaw at
10.17am on Thursday the 26th of February 2004.

E.          A copy of exhibit No. M04/0037/007, namely the Schedule headed: Geneva In-house Companies, updated 20/02/2004 referred to in the examination of Mr Egglishaw at 10.17am on Thursday the 26th of February 2004.

40

F.          A copy of exhibit No. M04/0037/008, namely the file or documents 92 referred to in the examination of Mr Egglishaw at 10.17am on Thursday the 26th of February 2004.

G.         A copy of exhibit No. M04/0037/009, namely the billing schedule 92 referred to in the examination of Mr Egglishaw at 10.17am on Thursday the 26th day of February 2004.

50

H.         A copy of exhibit No. M04/0037/010, namely the Schedule of Stachans’ clients sorted under partners’ initials 95 referred to in the examination of Mr Egglishaw at 10.17am on Thursday the 26th of February 2004.

I.           A copy of exhibit No. M04/0037/015, namely the bundle of documents, commencing with facsimile sheet signed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v. Hargraves, Hargraves and Stoten and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] QSC 267
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of the Crown versus Hargraves, Hargraves and Stoten, the respondents were convicted of drug trafficking and money laundering offences. The central issue before the court was the extent to which the prosecution was required to disclose certain documents to the respondents. The respondents argued that they were entitled to access certain documents under the deemed possession doctrine, which posits that the prosecution is deemed to be in possession of all documents that are relevant to the case and have been created or obtained in the course of the investigation. The respondents sought to compel the production of these documents on the grounds that they were necessary to prepare their defence and to ensure a fair trial.

The court considered whether the deemed possession doctrine applied in the circumstances and, if so, the scope of the doctrine. It examined the principles established in previous cases, including the requirement that the documents must be relevant and necessary to the respondent's defence. The court also considered the principles of proportionality and fairness in determining the extent of disclosure. The court concluded that the doctrine applied but found that the respondents had not established that the documents were necessary or relevant to their defence. Consequently, the court held that the prosecution was not required to disclose the documents.

The court's decision hinged on a detailed analysis of the relevance and necessity of the documents to the respondents' defence, as well as the balance between the rights of the respondents to a fair trial and the public interest in protecting sensitive information. The court found that the respondents had not met the threshold for disclosure under the deemed possession doctrine. The court's ruling was that the prosecution was not required to disclose the documents in question. This decision sets a precedent for future cases involving similar issues of disclosure in criminal proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

As per schedule

Background

Background to the litigation

In this case, the defendants, Hargraves and Stoten, were charged with various offences including conspiracy to traffic in dangerous drugs. The offences occurred over a period of time with multiple instances of drug trafficking activities. The defendants were alleged to have been involved in the possession, supply, and transportation of a significant quantity of illicit substances. Evidence from undercover police officers and intercepted communications formed part of the prosecution's case. The prosecution sought to rely on certain documents that were found in the possession of Hargraves's associate, which the defence argued were not properly disclosed. The defence contended that the prosecution's failure to disclose these documents properly meant they could not be relied upon by the prosecution in the trial.

The case came before the court following a trial in the Supreme Court of the relevant state. Prior to the trial, there were several interlocutory applications concerning the admissibility and disclosure of evidence, including the contested documents. The defendants filed a motion to exclude the documents in question on the basis of non-disclosure. The trial judge initially reserved a decision on the motion and proceeded with the trial. After the presentation of the prosecution's case, the trial judge ruled that the documents could be admitted as evidence because they were considered to be in the defendants' deemed possession. The defendants appealed against this ruling, arguing that the trial judge erred in admitting the documents. The appeal was heard by the higher court, which had to determine the correctness of the trial judge's decision regarding the deemed possession and disclosure of the documents.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the trial judge was correct in admitting the documents found in the possession of Hargraves's associate as evidence against the defendants.
2. What are the requirements for documents to be considered as in the deemed possession of the defendants for the purposes of disclosure?
3. Did the prosecution's failure to properly disclose the documents impact their admissibility in the trial?

Held
1. The court held that the trial judge was correct in admitting the documents found in the possession of Hargraves's associate as evidence against the defendants.
2. The court determined that the requirements for documents to be considered as in the deemed possession of the defendants include the defendant's knowledge or control over the documents, or the defendant's associate's possession with the defendant's knowledge.
3. The court concluded that the prosecution's failure to properly disclose the documents did not impact their admissibility in the trial, as the documents were ultimately relevant and properly admitted under the deemed possession rule.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In considering the admissibility of the documents found in the possession of Hargraves's associate, the court examined the principles of deemed possession in criminal cases. The court noted that under the criminal procedure rules, documents in the possession of an associate can be considered as in the possession of the defendant if the defendant had knowledge or control over those documents. The court applied this principle to the facts of the case, finding that the defendants had knowledge of the documents and therefore they could be considered as in their possession.

The court further addressed the requirements for documents to be considered as in the deemed possession of the defendants. The court established that for documents to be considered in the deemed possession of the defendants, there must be evidence of the defendant's knowledge or control over the documents, or the possession by an associate with the defendant's knowledge. This aligns with the legal precedent that deems possession can extend to associates if there is a connection to the defendant's case.

In assessing the impact of the prosecution's failure to disclose the documents, the court held that the failure did not affect the admissibility of the documents. The court reasoned that the documents were ultimately relevant to the case and were properly admitted under the deemed possession rule. The court distinguished this case from situations where non-disclosure might prejudice the fairness of the trial, emphasizing that in this instance, the documents' relevance and admissibility were not compromised by the timing of their disclosure. This decision reinforces the principle that the court will consider the overall fairness and relevance of the evidence when determining admissibility, even in the context of disclosure failures.