R V HANDLEY AND STEWART
[2000] SADC 98
Judge Noblet
Criminal
This is an application for an order that two persons jointly charged with armed robbery be tried separately. The prosecution alleges that Michael Gary Handley and Sean Kym Stewart, while armed with a replica pistol and a tomahawk, robbed Mark Young, an attendant at a Mobil Quicks Service Station, of cigarettes to the value of $3861.37 and cash in the amount of $1027. It is alleged that they tied up the attendant with tape and that Stewart stood guard over him while Handley operated a time delay safe to obtain cash. The safe enables tubes of cash up to the value of $40 to be removed at 2 minute intervals. It is further alleged that Handley put on the attendant’s t-shirt and served several customers during the next 45 minutes or so while waiting for the time delay to make more cash available. Handley has made no admissions and declined to answer any questions.
Ten days after the robbery, Stewart volunteered information to the police. He was interviewed and the interview was recorded on audio tape. He made full admissions to the police but claimed that he was forced to participate in the robbery by Handley. He claims that Handley woke him up at two o’clock in the morning and that he feared that Handley would hit him with the tomahawk he was carrying if he did not help with the robbery. It is clear that Stewart’s defence at trial will be based upon duress. He wants the whole of the record of interview to go before the jury, including what he told the police about Handley’s propensity for violence.
I take as my starting point the following passage from the judgment of Bray CJ and Mitchell and Sangster JJ in R v Harbach (1973) 6 SASR 427 at 432:
“But three things are clear. The first is that when the accused are charged with committing the crime jointly prima facie there should be a joint trial: R v Pullman ([1954] SASR 116 at 121; R v Kerekes (1951) 70 WN (NSW) 102, per Owen J (at 104). ..... The second is that a joint trial may be ordered notwithstanding that one result will be that evidence inadmissible against one of the accused, though admissible against the other, will be before the jury (R v Pullman; Youth v The King [1945] WM 27) and the third is that it may be ordered notwithstanding that one of the accused or each of the accused is trying to cast the blame for the crime of the other (R v Grondkowski [1946] KB 369), though both of these are highly relevant considerations to the exercise of the discretion: see Grondkowski (supra) (at 373 - 374).
There may appear to be an anomaly here. It may appear strange that material which would be sedulously kept from a jury, if an accused person were being tried alone, should be allowed to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Handley and Stewart No. DCCRM-00-156 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] SADC 98
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court must decide whether the application for separate trials should be granted. The legal issues include the general principle that defendants jointly charged with a crime should be tried together, the potential prejudice to a defendant if evidence inadmissible against them is admitted, and the interests of justice in ensuring that the jury has a full picture of the case.
The court considered the authorities and found that while there may be some prejudice to Handley if Stewart's admissions are admitted in a joint trial, this can be mitigated by appropriate directions to the jury. The court also found that there would be prejudice to Stewart if tried separately, as the jury would not be able to see Handley, the alleged coercer. The court concluded that the interests of justice and the need to avoid inconsistent verdicts favour a joint trial. The application for separate trials was therefore dismissed.
The court ordered that the trial proceed as a joint trial, with appropriate directions to the jury regarding the limited use of Stewart's admissions against Handley. The court reserved the right to consider any further application from Handley's counsel to exclude portions of Stewart's evidence on the ground of irrelevance, either before or during the trial.