R v Hamilton

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

COURT OF APPEAL

[1996] QCA 544

DAVIES JA
MOYNIHAN J
HELMAN J

CA No 440 of 1996

THE QUEEN

v.

BERNARD JOHN HAMILTON

BRISBANE

..DATE 06/12/96

JUDGMENT

DAVIES JA:  This is an appeal against a conviction in the District Court on 11 September this year of unlawful wounding.  The event occurred in a hotel which was celebrating its reopening.  The complainant a man named Garden was standing towards the end of the night somewhere near a band which was packing up to go home and suddenly he found that he had been hit.  He had pain in his left eye and he was on his back on the ground being punched about the torso by a man who as it turns out was the appellant.

The complainant's wife was present at the time.  From her evidence it appears that she did not know precisely what had caused her husband to go to the ground but saw him being punched on the ground and attempted to pull the appellant from him.  Two apparently independent witnesses gave more direct evidence of what had occurred before the complainant went to the ground.  One of these Mrs Ashbrook said that she saw the appellant work up to Mr Garden, appeared to have a short conversation with him.  The appellant had a glass in his hand and he swung his arm up at Mr Garden with the glass in it directly into Mr Garden's face.

Another independent witness Mr Verrall looked over and award Mr Garden was bleeding and noticed the base of the glass in the appellant's hand.  The appellant himself did not give evidence at this trial and no evidence was adduced of any admissions made to him to the police.  There were some inconsistencies, as one would expect in cases of this kind, between the witnesses I have just referred to and some other witnesses whom I will not mention in detail.  But those inconsistencies in my view were no more than one would expect ordinarily from honest people, many of whom who had had substantial amounts to drink.  In the circumstances in my view it was quite open to the jury to accept the evidence of Mrs Ashbrook and Mr Verrall that the unlawful wounding assault had occurred generally in the way Mrs Ashbrook described it. 

The appeal against conviction is on three grounds.  One was that the verdict was against the weight of evidence and in my view there is no substance in that for the reasons I have already mentioned.  The second is that the verdict was unsafe and unsatisfactory.  Again this relies on inconsistencies in the crown evidence and what I have said so far satisfactorily disposes of that argument.  The third ground of appeal to this Court was one which was added by leave.  It complains of an error in the trial Judge's direction to the jury that they could convict the appellant even if they were not satisfied that the appellant had a glass in his…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Hamilton and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1996] QCA 544
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Court of Appeal, the appeal was brought by Bernard John Hamilton against his conviction for unlawful wounding, which was handed down by the District Court on 11 September 1996. The event in question occurred in a hotel celebrating its reopening, where the complainant, Mr. Garden, was unlawfully wounded by the appellant, Mr. Hamilton. Mr. Garden was struck in the face by a glass, causing him pain in his left eye, and was subsequently punched about the torso while on the ground. The incident was witnessed by Mr. Garden's wife, as well as two independent witnesses, Mrs. Ashbrook and Mr. Verrall. Mrs. Ashbrook testified that she saw Mr. Hamilton approach Mr. Garden, have a brief conversation, and then swing his arm with a glass in his hand directly into Mr. Garden's face. Mr. Verrall corroborated this account, noticing that Mr. Garden was bleeding and seeing the base of the glass in Mr. Hamilton's hand. Mr. Hamilton did not give evidence at the trial, and no admissions were made to the police. The appeal against the conviction was based on three grounds, but the Court of Appeal found no substance in any of them.

The Court of Appeal examined the three grounds of appeal against the conviction, including whether the verdict was against the weight of the evidence, whether the verdict was unsafe and unsatisfactory, and whether there was an error in the trial judge's direction to the jury. The Court found that the inconsistencies in the crown evidence were no more than what would ordinarily be expected from honest people who had consumed substantial amounts of alcohol. The Court concluded that the jury was open to accept the evidence of Mrs. Ashbrook and Mr. Verrall that the unlawful wounding assault had occurred in the way Mrs. Ashbrook described it. Furthermore, the Court found no error in the trial judge's direction to the jury, as the question was whether the jury was satisfied that the blow which was struck by Mr. Hamilton to Mr. Garden caused the wound to Mr. Garden's face. The Court dismissed the appeal against the conviction.

The Court of Appeal also considered the appellant's application for leave to appeal against his sentence of two years. The appellant was 29 years old and had a previous conviction for assault occasioning bodily harm in the same hotel. The Court found that the sentence appeared towards the high end of the appropriate range, but was not outside that range. The Court refused the application for leave to appeal against the sentence. The appeal was dismissed, and the application for leave to appeal against the sentence was also refused.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established