R v Grosser No. Sccrm-02-217, Sccrm-02-388

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

R v GROSSER

[2003] SASC 264

Court of Criminal Appeal: Debelle, Lander and Gray JJ

  1. DEBELLE J         The applicant was convicted after trial by jury of the crime of attempted murder and of five counts of endangering life.  All of these crimes were committed at Nuriootpa on 3 May 1994.  The applicant was sentenced to imprisonment for a period of 22 years with a non-parole period of 18 years.

  2. The applicant has appealed against all of the convictions and against the sentence.  His application for leave to appeal was heard by Martin J on 14 February, 21 March, 2 May and 16 May 2003.  Leave to appeal against both the conviction and the sentence were refused.

  3. The applicant applies to this Court for leave to appeal against the conviction and the sentence.  The application for leave to appeal against conviction relates to some, but not all, of the issues the subject of the application to Martin J.

    Two Additional Witnesses

  4. The first ground complains of a refusal by Martin J to allow fresh evidence from a Mr Cole and a Mr Ian Grosser.  Mr Cole had sworn an affidavit and had been cross-examined on that affidavit.  In that affidavit, Mr Cole said that the man referred to as  “Cass” is a violent man and a member of a motor cycle gang.  He described two incidents of violent behaviour by Cass.  Mr Cole also said that he had seen Cass with a revolver.  It was the appellant’s case that he feared Cass and that he believed that it was Cass who had come to his house on 3 May.

  5. There are serious questions whether the evidence is relevant and admissible.  For present purposes, it may be assumed that it is.  Even with that assumption, the evidence would not have made any difference to the verdict of the jury.  I do not think there is a sound basis on which to allow the evidence to be led.  There was ample evidence at the trial that the appellant feared that Cass might seek him out and harm him.  That was not really in issue.  The real issue is whether it was a reasonable possibility that the applicant truly believed that it was Cass who had come to his house on 3 May.  This issue was carefully examined by the trial judge in his direction.  The evidence which could be given by Mr Cole does not assist in the resolution of that question.  The application is not sufficiently arguable.  Leave to appeal on this ground should be refused.

  6. Mr Ian Grosser is the applicant’s cousin.  He had sworn an affidavit proving a statement made by him to a solicitor.  In that statement, Mr Ian Grosser says that the applicant had told him about allegations of corruption he had made to the police and that he thought that the NCA building or police headquarters in Angas Street might be bombed.  He also told him about the person called Cass.  He also says that he assisted…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Grosser No. Sccrm-02-217, Sccrm-02-388 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] SASC 264
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of R v Grosser, the applicant sought leave to appeal both against his conviction and against the sentence imposed upon him. The case involved serious criminal charges against the applicant, and the outcome of the trial was a substantial sentence of imprisonment. The court was required to determine whether there were any grounds upon which the applicant could appeal against either his conviction or his sentence.

The legal issues the court had to decide included whether the applicant's claims regarding the evidence of Detective Kinsman and the availability of expert witnesses were valid grounds for an appeal against conviction. The applicant argued that Detective Kinsman had misled the jury and that he had been denied natural justice due to the unavailability of certain expert witnesses. The court found that the issues regarding Detective Kinsman's credibility were peripheral and not sufficient grounds for an appeal. Similarly, the court determined that the applicant had not demonstrated how the proposed expert evidence would differ from that already presented by the prosecution, nor had he shown that the expert evidence was relevant to his state of mind at the time of the offences. The court also considered the argument regarding the excessiveness of the sentence, ultimately concluding that it was arguable that the sentence was manifestly excessive.

The court reasoned that while the crimes committed by the applicant were indeed serious, the sentence imposed might be considered excessive. Consequently, the court granted leave to appeal against the sentence, both in terms of the head sentence and the non-parole period. However, the court refused leave to appeal against the conviction, as it found no arguable grounds in the applicant's claims regarding the evidence and expert witnesses. Therefore, the court concluded that leave to appeal against the conviction should be refused, but leave to appeal against the sentence should be granted.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For these reasons, leave to appeal is refused in respect of each of the so-called missing exhibits.The Evidence of Kinsman The applicant claims that a police officer, Detective Kinsman, misled the jury by giving evidence that Mr Hall, an officer in the Western Australian Police Force, denied telling the applicant that his life was in danger from South Australian police. The applicant had cross-examined Detective Kinsman to suggest that Mr Hall had informed the applicant that his life was in danger. In re-examination, Detective Kinsman refuted the allegations. A report was prepared which contained a statement of Mr Hall. It was Exhibit D202. The applicant says that this was a false document. The report was tendered by the applicant. The issues were relevant to the credit of Detective Kinsman only. It is peripheral to the issues at the trial. The applicant now complains that he is not able to pursue the matter and prove that Detective Kinsman lied. Because it relates only to the credit of Detective Kinsman, it was not a matter which the applicant was entitled to pursue. There is no arguable ground and leave to appeal is refused.Expert Witnesses The applicant submits that he was denied natural justice in that he was unable to obtain the services of expert witnesses. He says that he was unable to obtain the services of a forensic pathologist to rebut forensic evidence called by the prosecution. He also says that he did not have the opportunity to call two other witnesses, Mr Jankewicz and Dr Devilly. Mr Jankewicz was willing to give evidence as to the physical effects of CS gas, a gas which was pumped into the home during the incidents on 3 to 5 May. However, he could not give evidence as to the psychological effects of the gas. The applicant also wished to call a Dr Devilly, who was willing to give evidence on post-traumatic stress disorder. However, it seems that there was no request made on behalf of the applicant for Dr Devilly to assist. The applicant asserted this evidence related to his state of mind during the events of 3 to 5 May. CS gas had been used in an attempt to induce the applicant to surrender. The prosecution had called two witnesses to give evidence about the effects of CS gas. They were Dr Lehnane and Dr Wearne. The applicant had cross-examined both. The applicant has not described the nature of the evidence which the experts might give. He has not demonstrated that they would give any evidence different from that given by either Dr Lehnane or Dr Wearne. He has not explained the issue on which the forensic pathologist would give evidence. In any event, the issue of CS gas was not relevant to the applicant’s state of mind at the time of the commission of the offences with which he was charged. The applicant did not seek an adjournment of the trial for the purpose of arranging the calling of expert witnesses. There is no possibility of this ground succeeding and leave to appeal is refused. For all of these reasons, the application for leave to appeal against the conviction is refused.The Appeal Against Sentence

Decision

Reasons for decision

DEBELLE J LANDER J GRAY J
The applicant has been sentenced to a very substantial period of imprisonment. Although there was no doubt that the crimes for which the applicant has been convicted were extremely serious, it is arguable that the sentence is manifestly excessive. I would grant leave to appeal against sentence, both as to the head sentence and the non-parole period.ConclusionFor these reasons, I would not grant leave to appeal against the conviction but I would grant leave to appeal against sentence. I agree that leave to appeal against conviction should be refused for the reasons given by Debelle J. I also agree that leave to appeal against sentence should be granted. I agree.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: DEBELLE J, LANDER J, GRAY J

Full text does not contain this section.