R v Grant Charles Roberts No. DCCRM-96-660 Judgment No. D3576

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

Court

DISTRICT COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

Reasons For Ruling of His Honour Judge Kitchen (ex tempore)

Hearing

06/11/96, 09/12/96, 12/12/96, 03/02/97, 10/02/97.

Catchwords

CRIMINAL LAW - PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE Young Offenders Act S29(1) - whether a plea of guilty is comprehended in the expression "found guilty on trial". R v Symons (1981) VR 297

Representation

Crown DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS:
Counsel: MS C MEALOR

Accused GRANT CHARLES ROBERTS:
Counsel: MR G ALGIE - Solicitors: DIXON GALLASCH

DCCRM-96-660

Judgment No. D3576

3 February 1997

(Criminal)

THE DISTRICT COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

CRIMINAL JURISDICTION

DCCRM-96-660

R v GRANT CHARLES ROBERTS

REASONS FOR RULING OF HIS HONOUR JUDGE KITCHEN

On 18th March 1996, pursuant to Section 17 of the Young Offenders Act 1993 (the Act), the accused was committed for trial in this Court for the offence of arson.On 8th July 1996 he pleaded not guilty in this Court to an Information charging him with that offence and he was remanded for trial.The particulars in the Information alleged that the accused "on the 14th October 1995 at Craigmore, knowing that he had no lawful authority to do so, intentionally or with reckless indifference damaged by fire a school building the property of the Education Department of South Australia, the said damage amounting to about $l.2 million".

On the day set for his trial the DPP amended the Information by deleting from the particulars of the offence the words "intentionally or" and the accused pleaded guilty to the Information as amended.

Section 17 of the Act provides that where the Youth Court or the Supreme Court determines, on the application of the DPP or a police prosecutor, that a youth charged with an offence should be dealt with in the same way as an adult because of (inter alia) the gravity of the offence, the Youth Court may commit the youth to the Supreme Court or the District Court for trial or sentence.

Section 29(1) of the Act provides that where a youth is committed for trial, and is found guilty on trial, or is committed for sentence, the court to which the youth was committed may deal with the youth as an adult or make any order in relation to the youth that may have been made by the Youth Court on sentencing a youth, or remand the youth to the Youth Court for sentencing.

In my opinion the amendment to the Information did not charge a lesser offence, so the provisions of Section 29(2) of the Act, dealing with a case where a plea is entered to a lesser offence than that charged in the Information, are not relevant.

The question is whether the phrase in Section 29(1) of the Act "and is found guilty on trial" means that there must be a finding of guilt after a trial, as that word is usually understood, or whether it is capable of including a finding of guilt on a plea of guilty.

"Trial" is not defined in the Act.

If the phrase "found…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Grant Charles Roberts No. DCCRM-96-660 Judgment No. D357... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1997] SADC 3576
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of R v Grant Charles Roberts involved the defendant being committed for trial under Section 17 of the Young Offenders Act 1993 for the offence of arson. The particulars of the Information alleged that the defendant, on 14th October 1995, intentionally or with reckless indifference, damaged a school building by fire, resulting in damages of about $1.2 million. The defendant initially pleaded not guilty but later pleaded guilty to the amended Information, which omitted the words "intentionally or." The court had to determine whether the phrase "found guilty on trial" in Section 29(1) of the Act included a finding of guilt on a plea of guilty, or whether it required a trial to have taken place.

The key legal issue was the interpretation of the phrase "found guilty on trial" in Section 29(1) of the Young Offenders Act 1993. The court needed to ascertain if the phrase could encompass a finding of guilt on a plea of guilty, or if it necessitated an actual trial to have occurred. The court considered historical context, the purpose of the statute, and relevant precedents. The court also examined similar sections in the repealed Children's Protection and Young Offenders Act 1979, finding that the previous statute did not confine the court's power to impose a sentence only to cases where there had been a trial after a plea of not guilty.

The court concluded that the phrase "found guilty on trial" should be interpreted to include a finding of guilt on a plea of guilty. This interpretation was based on the context and purpose of the statute, the lack of definition for "trial" in the Act, and the precedents from both United Kingdom and Victorian authorities. The court noted that it was difficult to impute to Parliament an intention that would exclude the court's power to sentence if there was merely a plea of guilty. Additionally, the court found that two instances in the Supreme Court, where judges proceeded to sentence a youth on their plea of guilty, supported this interpretation.

Consequently, the court ruled that by pleading guilty, the defendant had effectively been "found guilty on trial," and the court had jurisdiction to proceed with sentencing under Section 29(1) of the Act. This ruling allowed the court to sentence the defendant in accordance with the statute, avoiding any hiatus in the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.