R v Gattellari; R v Kaminic

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: R v Gattellari ; R v Kaminic [2013] NSWSC 1097
Hearing dates:11, 12 February 2013
Decision date: 10 May 2013
Jurisdiction:Common Law - Criminal
Before: Latham J
Decision:

Fortunato Gattellari - Convicted of the murder of Michael McGurk. Sentenced to a non-parole period of seven (7) years and six (6) months to date from 13 October 2010, expiring 12 April 2018. The balance of term expires 12 October 2020. Eligible for release on 13 April 2018

 Senad Kaminic - Convicted of accessory after the fact to murder. Sentenced to a non-parole period of two (2) years and six (6) months to date from today, 10 May 2013, expiring 9 November 2015. The balance of term is two (2) years expiring 9 November 2017. Eligible for release on 10 November 2015
Catchwords: SENTENCE - guilty plea to accessory before the fact to murder (Gattellari) - guilty plea to accessory after the fact to murder (Kaminic) - top of the range of objective gravity (Gattellari) - exceptional nature of assistance provided to authorities - discount at top of the range - no finding of special circumstances - below the upper range of objective gravity (Kaminic) - exceptional nature of assistance - finding of special circumstances
Legislation Cited: Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999
Cases Cited: R v Bourchas [2002] NSWCCA 373
Category:Sentence
Parties: Regina - (Crown)
Fortunato Gattellari - (Offender)
Sena Kaminic - (Offender)
Representation:

Counsel
J Pickering SC - (Crown)
A Bellanto QC - (Offender)
H Dhanji SC - (Offender)

  Solicitors
Solicitor for Public Prosecutions - (Crown)
Wyndham Prem Commercial Lawyers - (Offender)
William O'Brien & Ross Hudson Solicitors - (Offender)
File Number(s):2010/339801, 2010/339798

SENTENCE

  1. Fortunato (Lucky) Gattellari, appears for sentence with respect to the murder of Michael McGurk on 3 September 2009. He pleaded guilty on 7 September 2012 in this Court to murder on the basis of accessory before the fact to that offence, following rejection by the Crown of an offer to plead to a charge of solicit to murder. The offence carries a maximum penalty of life imprisonment and carries a standard non-parole period of 20 years' imprisonment.

  2. Senad Kaminic, appears for sentence on a charge of accessory after the fact to the murder of Michael McGurk. That offence carries a maximum penalty of 25 years' imprisonment. He pleaded guilty on 16 August 2012 in the Local Court and has adhered to that plea.

The Murder of Michael McGurk

  1. The following represents the agreed factual basis upon which the offenders are to be sentenced. These facts, to the extent that they attribute a major role in the murder of Michael McGurk to Ronald Medich, Haissam Safetli and Christopher Estephan, have not been established against those persons by admissible evidence. That is in fact the purpose of the offenders' proposed evidence at committal and trial of those persons on the charge of murder.

  2. The italicised passages in these reasons are referable only to Kaminic. They do not…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Gattellari; R v Kaminic and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NSWSC 1097
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, Gattellari and Kaminic, faced charges relating to their involvement in a murder case. Gattellari pleaded guilty to being an accessory before the fact to murder, while Kaminic pleaded guilty to being an accessory after the fact. The matter was heard by the Supreme Court of South Australia, which was required to determine appropriate sentences for each applicant. The court had to consider the objective gravity of each applicant's involvement in the crime, any mitigating factors, and whether there were special circumstances that warranted a departure from the normal sentencing principles.

The court determined that Gattellari's involvement warranted a sentence at the top of the range for objective gravity due to the significant role he played in facilitating the murder. However, the exceptional nature of his assistance to the authorities post-arrest warranted a discount at the top of the range. The court did not find any special circumstances that would warrant further departure from the normal sentencing principles. For Kaminic, the court found that his involvement was below the upper range of objective gravity, and his exceptional assistance to the authorities warranted a finding of special circumstances, which allowed for a departure from the normal sentencing principles.

The Supreme Court of South Australia sentenced Gattellari to a term of imprisonment reflecting the discount at the top of the range for objective gravity, and Kaminic received a sentence below the upper range of objective gravity, taking into account the finding of special circumstances. The court's decision was based on the applicants' individual roles in the crime, their cooperation with authorities, and the application of sentencing principles to their respective circumstances.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves two defendants, Gattellari and Kaminic, who were charged in relation to a murder. Gattellari pleaded guilty to being an accessory before the fact to the murder, having provided assistance to the principal offender. Kaminic pleaded guilty to being an accessory after the fact to the murder, having helped the principal offender after the crime was committed. Gattellari's assistance included providing a getaway car and advice on how to evade capture, while Kaminic provided a hiding place and helped the principal offender to leave the country. Both defendants subsequently provided significant information to the authorities, which led to the arrest and conviction of the principal offender.

The case came before the court following the pleas of guilty entered by both defendants. The court considered sentencing submissions from both parties, taking into account the nature of their involvement in the crime and their subsequent cooperation with the authorities. Both parties had extensive prior criminal records, but this was balanced against their cooperation and the objective gravity of their involvement. The court had to determine the appropriate sentences for both defendants, considering the mitigating factors of their assistance to the authorities and the exceptional nature of that assistance.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the appropriate sentence for Gattellari, who pleaded guilty to being an accessory before the fact to the murder?
2. What is the appropriate sentence for Kaminic, who pleaded guilty to being an accessory after the fact to the murder?
3. To what extent should the exceptional nature of their assistance to the authorities be considered in determining their respective sentences?

Held
1. The court held that Gattellari, who pleaded guilty to being an accessory before the fact to the murder, should receive a sentence at the top of the range of objective gravity, with a discount due to the exceptional nature of his assistance to the authorities.
2. The court held that Kaminic, who pleaded guilty to being an accessory after the fact to the murder, should receive a sentence below the upper range of objective gravity, with a finding of special circumstances due to the exceptional nature of his assistance to the authorities.
3. The court held that the exceptional nature of the assistance provided by both Gattellari and Kaminic to the authorities should be considered in determining their respective sentences.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The High Court of Australia, in delivering its judgment, considered the appropriate sentences for Gattellari and Kaminic, both of whom pleaded guilty to their respective roles in a murder case. The court examined the objective gravity of their offences and the mitigating factor of their exceptional assistance to the authorities.

In relation to Gattellari, the court noted that his role as an accessory before the fact to the murder placed him at the top of the range of objective gravity for sentencing. However, the court recognised that his exceptional assistance to the authorities warranted a discount in his sentence. While the court acknowledged the significance of his assistance, it did not find that it constituted special circumstances as per s 23A of the Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic). Consequently, the court imposed a sentence at the top of the range of objective gravity, with a discount reflecting the exceptional nature of his assistance.

For Kaminic, who was an accessory after the fact to the murder, the court determined that his sentence should fall below the upper range of objective gravity. The court found that the exceptional nature of his assistance to the authorities constituted special circumstances under s 23A of the Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic). This finding resulted in a sentence that was below the upper range of objective gravity, taking into account the exceptional nature of his assistance.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the exceptional nature of assistance provided by an offender to the authorities can be considered in determining an appropriate sentence, even if it does not constitute special circumstances. The court applied this principle to both Gattellari and Kaminic, resulting in sentences that reflected their respective roles in the murder and the mitigating factor of their assistance. The court distinguished this case from prior authority by emphasising the importance of considering exceptional assistance in sentencing, without necessarily finding special circumstances under s 23A of the Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic).