R v Faiello and Newman No. DCCRM-02-224

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

R  v  NICOLA ROCCO FAIELLO AND NATALIE JOANNE NEWMAN
[2003] SADC 89

CHIEF JUDGE WORTHINGTON
CRIMINAL

  1. The first accused, Mr Faiello, and the second accused, Ms Newman, complain of abuse of process.  The following outline will suffice for present purposes. 

  2. On Sunday, 23 September 2001 the first accused and Ms Ursula Thompson were arrested and charged by police for taking part in the sale of a prohibited substance, ecstasy. On the Crown case, the first accused had been seen by police officers in a car, owned by Ms Thompson, holding a bag in which there were 112 tablets containing ecstasy.

  3. The DPP subsequently charged them jointly with possessing ecstasy for sale. The first accused was committed for trial on 14 February 2002, but the magistrate found that Ms Thompson had no case to answer. The first accused appeared in this court on 25 March 2002 for arraignment on the charge of possessing ecstasy for sale.

  4. On 17 April 2002 the second accused gave a signed statement to her solicitor in which she said that, inter alia, the ecstasy tablets belonged to her and not the first accused, and she gave an account of how they came into her possession and how they came to be in the car owned by Ms Thompson. A copy of that statement was sent to the DPP, and on 29 May 2002 she was interviewed at the Adelaide Police Station by Police Officer Mann in the company of her solicitor. On the basis of that statement and the interview, she was charged with possessing ecstasy for sale. On 26 July 2002 she pleaded not guilty and was committed for trial to this Court.

  5. The Director then filed an information in this Court on 30 August 2002 jointly charging both accused with two offences: possessing methylamphetamine for sale and possessing ecstasy for sale. These were counts 1 and 2 on the information presented for the 2 September 2002 sessions. It is said that the charge concerning methylamphetamine was included because there were traces of it in the tablets.  For present purposes, nothing turns on that. The second accused was also charged separately on the same information with fabricating evidence (count 3). The evidence alleged to have been fabricated was contained in the statement she gave to her solicitor and her interview with Mr Mann. Both accused were arraigned on 2 September 2002 and pleaded not guilty.

  6. There were then a number of directions hearings, and on 15 January 2003  the matter was set down for trial on Tuesday, 3 June 2003. For reasons unassociated with this case, the trial could not start until the following day, 4 June. However, on 23 May 2003, just after he had received the brief, Mr Schapel, for the second accused, requested the DPP for particulars of the count of fabricating evidence. On 28 May, six days before the trial was due to begin,  the Director filed a fresh information in this court and sent a copy to Mr Schapel. That…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Faiello and Newman No. DCCRM-02-224 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] SADC 89
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Nicola Rocco Faiello and Natalie Joanne Newman are the appellants in this criminal case before the South Australian District Court. The primary issue is whether the court should quash or permanently stay the proceedings against them due to an alleged abuse of process by the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP). The appellants argue that the change in the nature of the charges and the manner in which they were presented is oppressive and constitutes an abuse of the court's process. The court must decide whether the change in charges, particularly for Ms Newman, is so inconsistent with the original proceedings that it constitutes an abuse of process warranting a permanent stay of the proceedings.

The court considered the arguments presented by both appellants. For Ms Newman, the charge she faces at trial is entirely inconsistent with the charge upon which she was initially committed for trial. The court found that the proceedings against her have caused oppression and are a misuse of the court’s procedures, as she was not made aware from the outset of the charge she would ultimately face. The change in the charge from possession of drugs to fabricating evidence is not merely a refinement of the charge but a complete contradiction. This inconsistency and the resulting uncertainty and oppression justify a permanent stay of the proceedings against her. For Mr Faiello, the court found that while the situation was unsatisfactory, the charge against him remained consistent from the start and had not been repudiated by the DPP. The court concluded that there was no abuse of process in relation to him.

The court ordered a permanent stay of the charge against the second appellant, Natalie Joanne Newman, but denied the application by the first appellant, Nicola Rocco Faiello. The proceedings against Ms Newman were found to have been abused, causing her oppression and uncertainty, while the proceedings against Mr Faiello were deemed consistent and not abusive.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.