R v Elgueta No. Sccrm-98-171 Judgment No. S2

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

R V ELGUETA
[1999] SASC 2

Court of Criminal Appeal:  Cox, Prior and Olsson JJ

  1. COX J.               Appeal against convictions for robbery and larceny.

  2. The appellant, Marco Antonio Elgueta, was charged in the District Court on an information that alleged the following offences, three by the appellant and his brother jointly and a fourth by the appellant alone -

“MARCO ANTONIO ELGUETA and

DANIEL ERNESTO ELGUETA

are charged with the following Offences

First Count

Statement of Offence

Robbery. (Section 155 of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act, 1935).

Particulars of Offence

Marco Antonio Elgueta and Daniel Ernesto Elgueta on the 3rd July, 1997 at Unley, robbed Sharon Margaret Hutton of money to the amount of about $780.

Second Count

Statement of Offence

Larceny of a Motor Vehicle. (Section 131 of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act, 1935).

Particulars of Offence

Marco Antonio Elgueta and Daniel Ernesto Elgueta on the 15th July, 1997 at Adelaide, stole one motor vehicle to the value of $17,000, the property of Euro Alfa Company.

Third Count

Statement of Offence

Armed Robbery. (Section 158(a) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act, 1935).

Particulars of Offence

Marco Antonio Elgueta and Daniel Ernesto Elgueta on the 21st July, 1997 at West Richmond, being armed with an offensive weapon, namely a knife, robbed Angela Mary White of a purse of the value of $60, and money in the amount of about $315.

MARCO ANTONIO ELGUTA

is charged with the following offence

Fourth Count

Statement of Offence

Armed Robbery.  (Ibid.)

Particulars of Offence

Marco Antonio Elgueta on the 16th July, 1997 at Plympton, being armed with an offensive weapon, namely a screwdriver, robbed Judy Kathryn Morrison of money in the amount of about $545.”

The appellant stood trial alone.  It was an agreed fact at the trial that Daniel Elgueta had pleaded guilty to counts one, two and three and had been remanded for sentence.  The appellant did not dispute that someone had committed the offences alleged against him, but he said that it was not him.  The issue, then, was identity.  The jury found him guilty on all four counts.

  1. The appellant, a young man of twenty-five, arrived in Adelaide from Perth in June 1997.  He found temporary accommodation in a flat in George Street, Parkside.  He was joined on July 2 by his younger brother, Daniel.  The following evening, about 7.50 pm, a man entered the TAB branch on Unley Road, Unley.  He presented a marked TAB ticket to the attendant for processing and she opened the cash drawer.  He got across the counter and assaulted her and threatened to stab her.  He took money from the drawer and left the premises.  He left the ticket behind and the evidence of a fingerprint expert was that he “found consistency” between a partial fingerprint on the ticket and a specimen fingerprint taken from the appellant after his arrest.  By this he meant that there were eight points of comparison between the two prints, not enough for absolute certainty but leaving only…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Elgueta No. Sccrm-98-171 Judgment No. S2 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] SASC 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of R v Elgueta involved the appeal of Marco Antonio Elgueta against his convictions for robbery and larceny. The appellant was charged with four counts of robbery and larceny, three of which were committed jointly with his brother, Daniel Ernesto Elgueta. The central issue in the appeal was the admissibility and impact of fingerprint evidence across multiple counts and the appropriateness of the trial judge's directions to the jury regarding this evidence. The evidence against Elgueta included multiple instances of his fingerprints found at the crime scenes, a partial fingerprint on a TAB ticket from one of the robberies, and the appellant's presence in the vicinity of the crimes.

The court considered two main grounds of appeal: the reliance on a photographic identification procedure and the trial judge's direction to the jury regarding the use of fingerprint evidence across multiple counts. Regarding the photographic identification, the court found that the evidence was admissible and relevant, and the trial judge's decision to allow it was within their discretion. Concerning the fingerprint evidence, the court examined the trial judge's directions to the jury and concluded that while the categorization of the evidence as "striking similarities" was not ideal, it did not result in a miscarriage of justice. The court noted that the fingerprint evidence was strongly probative of the appellant's involvement in the crimes and that the trial judge's direction did not unfairly prejudice the appellant.

In light of the analysis, the Court of Criminal Appeal, comprising Cox, Prior, and Olsson JJ, unanimously dismissed the appeal. The judges agreed that the evidence against Elgueta was compelling and that the trial judge's handling of the evidence, while not perfect, did not lead to an unfair trial or a miscarriage of justice. The convictions were thus upheld, and the appeal was rejected.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

COX J PRIOR J OLSSON J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: COX J, PRIOR J, OLSSON J

Full text does not contain this section.