R v Dobie

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

[2001] QCA 162

COURT OF APPEAL

de JERSEY CJ
THOMAS JA
MACKENZIE J

CA No 42 of 2001

THE QUEEN

v.

KEITH WILLIAM DOBIE  Applicant

BRISBANE

..DATE 27/04/2001

JUDGMENT

THE CHIEF JUSTICE:  The applicant pleaded guilty to six charges, one of being knowingly concerned in an attempted defrauding of the Commonwealth, one of being knowingly concerned in defrauding the Commonwealth, one of defrauding the Commonwealth and three of attempted defrauding of the Commonwealth.  The learned sentencing Judge took another seven counts into account, one of defrauding the Commonwealth and six of attempting to defraud the Commonwealth.

The offences involved the applicant in the submission to the Australian Taxation Office of fraudulent tax returns in various people's names designed to secure payments as tax refunds.  In fact, by these means the applicant gained $14,958 and was seeking to gain another $52,451.  He acted in some of the cases in conjunction with one Krogh who apparently devised the scheme, a scheme described by the learned sentencing Judge as "reasonably elaborate".

The applicant committed the first two offences, in time, while he was serving a term of three and a half years' imprisonment for other offences, imposed upon him on
15 January 1999.  They were offences of dishonesty.  He has a lengthy criminal history for dishonesty.  He is presently 41 years old, a single man, who has been described as an habitual offender in relation to matters of dishonesty.
He is a compulsive gambler who earnestly wishes to counter his addiction.  The sentencing Judge concluded that that addiction played no direct role in relation to these offences.

A matter of great significance is that after committing the first two offences he was on 10 July 2000 released on home detention and then proceeded to commit the remaining offences.  The Judge properly considered that an aggravating circumstance.  He was sentenced on each count to three years' imprisonment to commence upon the expiration of his then current sentence on the basis that he be released after nine months of those three year concurrent terms.  No reparation order was sought or made.  The Crown Prosecutor had sought a penalty of that order on the basis that it would sufficiently reflect the applicant's prior criminal history, his pleas and the totality principle. 

The applicant complains now in particular that the treatment accorded him is disproportionate to that accorded Krogh who, for his initial similar offending, was sentenced to four years imprisonment with an 18 month non-parole period and then for this similar post-incarceration offending in league with the applicant two years' imprisonment - two years, that is, to be contrasted with the three years imposed upon the applicant.  The result in a comparative sense is that whereas Krogh is subject to a non-parole period in the aggregate of two years and three months the applicant will have to serve three years and nine months.

It is fair to observe that Krogh and the applicant carried comparable criminality in respect of these offences albeit that the plan was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Dobie and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] QCA 162
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of The Queen versus Keith William Dobie, the Court of Appeal was presented with an application concerning the applicant's appeal against his sentence. Dobie had pleaded guilty to multiple charges of defrauding the Commonwealth and had been sentenced by the learned sentencing Judge. The key issue for the Court of Appeal was whether the penalties imposed upon Dobie were appropriate given the nature of the offending, his pleas, and the totality principle, as well as other relevant circumstances. Additionally, the Court considered the applicant's contention that the treatment accorded him was disproportionate to that of his co-offender, Krogh.

The Court of Appeal examined the nature of the offending, the respective roles of Dobie and Krogh in the fraudulent scheme, and the applicant's criminal history. The Court noted that while Dobie and Krogh carried comparable criminality in relation to the offences, Dobie had a substantially worse criminal history involving dishonesty, whereas Krogh did not have any prior convictions. The Court also observed that Dobie committed more offences in number than Krogh and acted with a degree of independence, particularly during his period of home detention. The Court concluded that the penalties imposed were appropriate, taking into account the totality principle and other circumstances, and that there was sufficient reason to justify treating Dobie more severely than Krogh due to his substantial relevant prior criminal history.

In light of the reasoning provided by the Court of Appeal, it was determined that the penalties imposed upon Dobie were appropriate. The Court found no sufficient reason to warrant disturbing the penalties imposed upon Dobie, and accordingly, the application was refused. The Court of Appeal upheld the order proposed by the Chief Justice, Thomas JA, and MacKenzie J, finding that the factors referred to adequately accounted for the difference in treatment of the two individuals involved in the scheme.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established