CITATION: R v Diez-Orozco and Lawrence [2003] NSWSC 1050 revised - 19/08/2004 HEARING DATE(S): 04/02/2003 - 10/07/2003 JUDGMENT DATE:
23 June 2003JUDGMENT OF: Howie J at 1 DECISION: His Honour intends to give the jury a warning under s 165 in respect of the use of evidence of co-accused generally and about the use of the accused Cornwell's evidence in particular. CATCHWORDS: Criminal Law and Procedure - Judge's summing up - whether warning under s 165 should be given where co-accused as a witness gives evidence implicating another co-accused. LEGISLATION CITED: Evidence Act 1995 - s 165 CASES CITED: Webb v R 181 CLR 41 PARTIES :
Regina v Juan Guillermo Diez-Orozco, Regina v John Lawrence FILE NUMBER(S): SC 70221/02; 70220/02 COUNSEL: P. Roberts SC with I. Bourke - Crown
P. Young - Accused Diez-Orozco
C. Waterstreet - Accused LawrenceSOLICITORS: Commonwealth DPP - Crown
Neil J. O'Connor & Associates - Accused Diez-Orozco
King's Lawyers - Accused Lawrence
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISIONHOWIE J
MONDAY 23 JUNE 2003
JUDGMENT – see page 5325 of transcript70221/02 R v Juan Guillermo DIEZ-OROZCO
70220/02 R v John LAWRENCE
1 HIS HONOUR: In this case application has been made on behalf of the accused Diez and the accused Lawrence that I give a warning under s 165(1) in respect of evidence given by the accused Cornwell, which may have tended to implicate Diez and Lawrence in the supply of cocaine and indirectly in the offence charged in the indictment.
2 The submission is that Mr Cornwell, as a witness, notwithstanding that he is also an accused, falls within s 165(1)(d) of the Evidence Act.
3 Mr Boulten on behalf of Cornwell, asked that I not give any direction relying upon 165(3) of that Act on the basis that there would be good reasons for not doing so.
4 During the course of the debate about this matter I was referred to the case of Webb v R 181 CLR 41, in particular the judgments of Deane J and Toohey J, although apparently Brennan J had a contrary view. Those two judgments indicate that it might be appropriate, and in some cases may be necessary, for a trial Judge, where there are co-accused and where one of those accused gives evidence tending to implicate another, to give a warning in accordance with what is now being requested of me.
5 Those judgments stress that at the end of the day it is for the trial judge to do what he or she deems is necessary in order to resolve the competing interests that arise in a joint trial where one accused gives evidence in his own defence but may, in the course of that evidence, implicate a co-accused as being guilty of the charge before the court.
6 Four accused gave evidence in this trial. In the case of the accused McDougall and Norris, no suggestion was made during cross-examination by counsel for any…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Diez-Orozco and Lawrence and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] NSWSC 1050
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issue before the court was whether the trial judge had an obligation to provide a warning under section 165 when a co-accused, who was also a witness, gave evidence that implicated another co-accused. The accused contended that the judge's failure to do so constituted a significant procedural error that undermined the fairness of the trial. The court had to consider the nature and purpose of section 165 warnings, as well as the specific circumstances of this case to determine whether the failure to warn was indeed a substantial procedural error.
The court examined the relevant provisions and found that section 165 warnings were intended to alert the jury to the potential unreliability of a co-accused witness's evidence due to their self-interest in implicating another. However, the court concluded that the warning was not mandatory in all circumstances but rather at the discretion of the trial judge, who must consider the specific facts of each case. In this instance, the court determined that the trial judge's decision not to give the warning did not amount to a substantial procedural error that would necessitate a fresh trial. The evidence against the accused was substantial, and the failure to warn did not prejudice the outcome of the trial.
As a result, the court upheld the convictions of both Diez-Orozco and Lawrence, dismissing their appeals. The trial judge's decision not to give a section 165 warning was deemed not to have amounted to a substantial procedural error, and the convictions were affirmed. The court did not order a fresh trial, and the original verdicts stood.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.