R v DAVENPORT
[1998] SASC 6816
Court of Criminal Appeal: Prior, Olsson and Lander JJ (ex tempore)
OLSSON J
This is an appeal, by leave, against a sentence imposed on the appellant by a District Court Judge. The appellant pleaded guilty to one count of causing death by dangerous driving, four counts of causing grievous bodily harm by negligent and reckless driving and four counts of endangering life. All offences arose from a single, ongoing incident and, not unsurprisingly, the learned sentencing Judge elected to impose one sentence in respect of them, pursuant to section 18A of the Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act.
In the event the appellant was sentenced to six years’ imprisonment, with a non parole period of four years. He was disqualified from holding or obtaining a driver’s licence for 12 years.
The present appeal is prosecuted on the grounds that the sentence imposed was, in all the circumstances, manifestly excessive; and that insufficient credit was given for the pleas of guilty.
The offences were committed at Whyalla Norrie in the early hours of 5 July 1997. At that time the appellant was a single man, 22 years of age. He had, by then, already amassed a significant antecedent record, including two counts related to driving whilst intoxicated, a count of driving in a reckless or dangerous manner, two counts of driving an unregistered vehicle and one count of driving without a licence.
It was the prosecution case that, at the date of the offences, the appellant was living at Port Augusta. He first went to the Pastoral Hotel at Port Augusta late in the evening of 4 July. He there met one Hamilton and the two of them were drinking for some time. By virtue of a drink/drive offence which he had committed in 1995, the appellant had been disqualified from holding or obtaining a driver’s licence for a period of 12 months. This had led to the situation that, on the night in question, he was only in possession of a Probationary Licence, a condition of which he was not entitled to drive if he had consumed any alcohol at all.
According to Hamilton the two of them left the hotel at about midnight and went to a nearby roadhouse to get something to eat.
At about 12.30 am the appellant drove his utility to Whyalla, with Hamilton as a passenger. On arrival they went to the Spencer Hotel, in the main street, and resumed drinking.
It appears that the Spencer Hotel closed at 3.00 am on the Sunday morning, whereas the Sundowner Hotel at Whyalla Norrie remained open until 5.00 am. It was said that, not infrequently, numbers of patrons would migrate from the Spencer, when it closed, to the Sundowner.
On this occasion, at shortly after 3.00 am the appellant drove his utility away from the Spencer with the intention of going to the Sundowner. He had, by then, been drinking steadily for several hours. Some seven people were in the back of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Davenport No. Sccrm-98-150 Judgment No. S6816 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1998] SASC 6816
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the Court of Criminal Appeal were whether the sentence was manifestly excessive and if the discount for the pleas of guilty was inadequate. The appeal hinged on comparing the sentence with those imposed in similar cases, although the Court noted the difficulty in making meaningful comparisons due to the unique circumstances of each case. The Court emphasised the need to consider the totality principle and the principle of deterrence, while also acknowledging the appellant's young age and the absence of prior custodial sentences as mitigating factors. The Court found that the starting point for the sentence was unduly high, and the actual accident was partly due to the presence of a police vehicle blocking the road, leaving the appellant with nowhere to go.
The Court of Criminal Appeal allowed the appeal, reducing the head sentence to five years and the non-parole period to three years. The period of licence disqualification was also reduced to nine years. The Court concluded that the original sentence was manifestly excessive and did not align with current sentencing norms for such offences. The judges agreed that the appellant's behaviour necessitated a severe penalty, but the starting point for the sentence was too high. The final orders reflect the Court's decision to mitigate the severity of the original sentence while maintaining the necessity of a substantial punishment and deterrent.
Background
Background to the litigation
The appellant pleaded guilty to one count of causing death by dangerous driving, four counts of causing grievous bodily harm by negligent and reckless driving, and four counts of endangering life. The District Court Judge sentenced the appellant to six years’ imprisonment, with a non-parole period of four years, and disqualified him from holding or obtaining a driver’s licence for 12 years. The appellant appealed against the severity of the sentence, arguing it was manifestly excessive and that insufficient credit was given for his pleas of guilty.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the sentence imposed by the District Court was manifestly excessive.
2. Whether the sentence adequately reflected the mitigating factors, including the appellant's age and the fact that he had not previously served a custodial sentence.
3. Whether the period of disqualification from holding or obtaining a driver’s licence was proportionate to the adjusted sentence.
Held
1. The sentence imposed by the District Court was manifestly excessive.
The Court of Criminal Appeal held that the head sentence of six years and the non-parole period of four years were manifestly excessive, and reduced the head sentence to five years and the non-parole period to three years.
2. The sentence did not adequately reflect the mitigating factors.
The Court of Criminal Appeal held that the sentence did not adequately reflect the mitigating factors, including the appellant's age and the fact that he had not previously served a custodial sentence.
3. The period of disqualification from holding or obtaining a driver’s licence was disproportionate to the adjusted sentence.
The Court of Criminal Appeal held that the period of disqualification of 12 years was disproportionate to the adjusted sentence and reduced the period to nine years.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Criminal Appeal considered the sentence imposed by the District Court to be manifestly excessive given the appellant's age, his previous work history, his prospects of rehabilitation, and the fact that he had not previously served a custodial sentence. The Court found that the starting point adopted by the sentencing judge was unduly high and did not reflect current sentencing tariffs for these types of offences. The Court also considered that the period of disqualification from holding or obtaining a driver’s licence was disproportionate to the adjusted sentence, and reduced it to nine years. The Court held that the appellant's behaviour required a severe penalty and an immediate term of imprisonment. However, the Court found that the discount allowed for the timely pleas was unduly modest. The Court noted that while other cases could provide some indication of general sentence tariffs, it was difficult to make meaningful comparisons given the unique circumstances of each case. The Court followed the principle that the totality of the circumstances must be considered when determining an appropriate sentence, and that a discount for quantity should not be allowed for multiple offences arising from the same general incident. The Court departed from the starting point adopted by the sentencing judge, which it found to be too high, and applied the totality principle to arrive at its decision. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the Court of Criminal Appeal will not hesitate to reduce a sentence that it finds to be manifestly excessive, even if the appellant has a bad driving record and caused serious harm to others. The Court will also consider the totality of the circumstances, including the appellant's age, work history, and prospects of rehabilitation, when determining an appropriate sentence.