R v Choi; R v Pereira

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Criminal Appeal)

R v CHOI; R v PEREIRA

[2017] SASCFC 54

Judgment of The Court of Criminal Appeal

(The Honourable Justice Stanley, The Honourable Justice Parker and The Honourable Justice Lovell)

23 May 2017

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - SENTENCING PROCEDURE - FACTUAL BASIS FOR SENTENCE - EVIDENCE - GENERALLY

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - SENTENCING PROCEDURE - FACTUAL BASIS FOR SENTENCE - EVIDENCE - BURDEN AND STANDARD OF PROOF

CRIMINAL LAW - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE - GROUNDS FOR INTERFERENCE  - PARITY BETWEEN CO-OFFENDERS AND OTHER RELATED OFFENDERS

The appellants pleaded guilty to the offence under s 400.9(1) of the Criminal Code (Cth) of dealing with money to a value greater than $100,000 in circumstances where it was reasonable to suspect that the money was the proceeds of crime. Mr Pereira was sentenced to 20 months imprisonment reduced by 30% in recognition of guilty plea, resulting in a head sentence of 14 months. Mr Choi was sentenced to 18 months imprisonment reduced by 33.33% in recognition of guilty plea, resulting in a head sentence of 12 months. Mr Pereira submitted there was a process error in taking into account the previous trips he had made to Australia and finding this was not the first time Mr Pereira had engaged in such conduct. The respondent submitted the comment by the sentencing judge that she was satisfied Mr Pereira had previously engaged in similar criminal conduct simply indicated that she rejected the plea in mitigation that this was the first occasion he had offended. Mr Choi submitted the disparity between his sentence and that imposed on Mr Pereira did not fairly or adequately reflect the differences in their circumstances. The respondent submitted there was no basis for a justifiable grievance on the grounds of parity.

Held, per Parker J (Stanley J and Lovell J agreeing), allowing both appeals:

1.  The sentencing judge erred in taking into account the previous trips Mr Pereira had made to Australia. While the trips were grounds for suspicion, there was no evidence as to what he was doing on these earlier trips. Because of this process error Mr Pereira must be resentenced and Mr Choi must be resentenced to maintain parity.

2.  Mr Pereira is sentenced to 11 months imprisonment commencing on 4 December 2016 and ordered to be released after 7 months upon entering into a recognisance in the amount of $100 to be of good behaviour for 12 months.

3.  Mr Choi is sentenced to 8 months imprisonment commencing on 4 December 2016 and ordered to be released after 5 months upon entering into a recognisance in the amount of $100 to be of good behaviour for 12 months.

Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth) s 400.9; Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) s 16A, s 17A; Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 (Cth) s 48; Criminal Law (Sentence Imposed) Act 1988 s 6; Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 68; Criminal Law Sentencing Act 1988 s 10B,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Choi; R v Pereira and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] SASCFC 54
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned appeals against sentences imposed on Mr Choi and Mr Pereira, who were Singaporean citizens convicted of offences related to the attempted export of a significant amount of Australian currency. The appeals were heard by Stanley, Parker, and Lovell JJ of the Supreme Court of South Australia.

The primary legal issues before the Court were whether the sentencing judge erred in her factual findings regarding the ownership of the money and the appellant Pereira's prior involvement in similar conduct, and whether the disparity in sentences between the two co-offenders was justifiable. The appellants also raised concerns about the factual basis for the sentence, particularly concerning the standard of proof required for certain findings made by the sentencing judge.

The Court considered the sentencing judge's remarks and concluded that her Honour had not made a finding beyond reasonable doubt that the money belonged to Pereira, but rather had rejected his assertion that it did not. This rejection of a mitigating factor did not equate to a positive finding of ownership. Regarding Pereira's prior offending, the Court found that the judge's conclusion that this was not his first instance of money smuggling went beyond merely establishing the context of the current offence and constituted a finding made beyond reasonable doubt, which was not adequately supported by the evidence presented. The Court also addressed the parity argument, finding that the differences in the appellants' roles and admissions provided a sufficient basis for a disparity in their sentences, and that Mr Choi had no justifiable grievance on this ground.

The Court allowed the appeals in part. It varied the sentence imposed on Mr Pereira, reducing his term of imprisonment and the recognizance period. The appeal by Mr Choi was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The judge sentenced Choi to imprisonment for twelve months and ordered that he be released after six months on entering into a recognizance in the sum of $100 to be of good behaviour for twelve months.Background Pereira and Choi are both Singaporean citizens. On 29 November 2016 Pereira purchased two return air fares from Singapore to Adelaide. The flights were scheduled to arrive in Adelaide on 2 December and the return was booked for 4 December 2016. On 1 December 2016 Pereira booked accommodation for two adults. While Choi and Pereira were in the baggage check-in queue at Adelaide Airport on the morning of 4 December 2016 a dog used by the Australian Federal Police drew attention to Pereira’s suitcase. When first questioned Pereira stated that he was carrying meat and about $20,000 in Australian currency. He opened the bag to reveal a T-bone steak and a bundle of cash. The value of the cash was $270,450. He said that it was the proceeds of gambling. He also stated that he was travelling alone. Soon after Pereira told the police that he had won the money gambling in a private house with some Asian men whom he had met near the casino. He claimed that he had brought SGD 7,500 into Australia.[1] He admitted to the police that he was travelling with Choi.[1] The value of the Singapore dollar is a little less than that of the Australian dollar. Pereira also told the police that he had come to Adelaide to watch a soccer match and to see a close friend but then decided not to see the friend. He maintained his story that he had won the money gambling. He had not counted the money but had estimated the value. He claimed that the meat was in his case so that he could eat it. On a previous visit to Adelaide he had taken a lot of meat back to Singapore. He denied that he was trying to mask the smell of the money with the meat. The police retrieved Choi’s suitcase. They located $249,450 in the case and also a handwritten note with the words “500 allowance and 50 visa”. This note was bound together with a bundle of cash. Police also found a tray of lamb chops in the case. Choi stated to the police that he was employed with a shipping company and earned about SGD 5,000 or SGD 6,000 per month. This was his first trip to Australia and he had brought with him SGD 50,000 that he had saved. He had brought the money as he intended to go to the casino. He claimed that he had met a Chinese man outside the casino who had invited him to gamble and drink at an apartment. He claimed that he had won about $200,000 by gambling and put the money in his case. Choi also told the police that he had bought the lamb chops because he wanted to cook them and they were fresher and cheaper than lamb in Singapore. He also claimed that while he had written the note found with the money he did not know how it came to be in his bag. He later admitted to police that his story about winning the money gambling was not true. He claimed that Pereira had told him that he had won some money previously and had asked him to accompany him to Australia to bring the money back. He said that Pereira had paid for the whole trip including the flights and visa and paid him $500 for his assistance. Sentencing

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The respondent submits that there was a great degree of similarity in the conduct of the two appellants. On that basis there did not need to be a marked disparity between their sentences. There was no basis for a justifiable grievance on the part of Choi on parity grounds.Consideration The first issue is whether the judge did in fact sentence on the basis that Pereira owned the money. Her Honour stated:It was put to me the money you had is not your money and you had been asked to bring this money to Singapore. There is no reason I should find it is not your money. You were not prepared to give evidence, nor make a submission beyond saying it does not belong to you. The money was in your possession, you have been coming back and forth to Australia for a number of months. You organised the flights, you paid for the hotel, and you and your co-defendant obviously got your heads together in relation to an explanation to be given in the event that you were stopped. You were both travelling together. There is nothing in the sentencing remarks to indicate that the judge treated her observation that “there is no reason I should find it is not your money” as an aggravating factor. I accept the correctness of the respondent’s submission that the judge merely rejected the assertion by Pereira that the money did not belong to him without making a positive finding beyond reasonable doubt that the money was his. The rejection by the judge of the mitigating factor (ie that Pereira was a mere “mule” transporting someone else’s money) did not amount to a finding that he was the owner.[12][12] Weininger v The Queen (2003) 212 CLR 629 at [24]. The appellants have complained that the judge erred in making the finding beyond reasonable doubt that this was not the first occasion that Pereira had engaged in money smuggling. While the earlier trips quite properly attract considerable suspicion, there was minimal evidence before the Court about those trips. The information was limited to date, place and duration. Nevertheless, the judge stated that there was a clear inference from the circumstances of this offending that it was not the first time Pereira had committed such an offence. Her Honour then stated that the consequence of this earlier offending was that he could not expect the leniency that he would have received if it had been his first offence of this type. If her Honour had not gone any further it could be accepted that she was only rejecting the plea in mitigation. In R v Tran and Tran this Court held that uncharged acts may be taken into account for sentencing purposes to determine the context in which an offence was committed.[13] However, I consider that the finding made by the judge as to the purpose of the prior trips went beyond fixing the context.[13] [2011] SASCFC 153 at [28]-[31]. Her Honour stated that “I can see no reason at all not to be satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that this was not the first occasion you had engaged in such conduct”.