SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Criminal: Application)
R v CEKIC; R v DETTMAN; R v NIEMANN
[2014] SASC 132
Judgment of The Honourable Justice Kelly
10 September 2014
CRIMINAL LAW - PROCEDURE - BAIL - REVOCATION, VARIATION, REVIEW AND APPEAL
Application to review an order of a District Court Judge refusing to grant each applicant bail. The applicants were each arrested in early April 2013 on charges of aggravated causing serious harm with intent to cause serious harm, aggravated robbery and participation in a criminal organisation.
Whether the applications are governed by s 10A of the Bail Act 1985 (SA). Whether each of the applicants has established the existence of special circumstances justifying his release on bail. Whether, in all of the circumstances, each of the applicants should be granted bail.
Held (allowing the application for review in respect of Cekic and Niemann; refusing the application for review in respect of Dettman):
1. In respect of each of the applicants, the criteria of s 3A of the Bail Act are met and the declarations pursuant to that section were properly made.
2. In the circumstances of Cekic and Niemann, the delays caused, which will result in them spending approximately 696 days in custody between arrest and trial, together with other relevant considerations amount to special circumstances justifying their release on bail.
3. Although Dettman has also been the subject of inordinate delay, that delay when considered in light of all other relevant considerations, in particular his extensive criminal history, does not give rise to special circumstances justifying his release on bail.
Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) s 275; Bail Act 1985 (SA) s 3A, s 10, s 10A, s 11, referred to.
R v Buhlmann [2010] SASC 123, considered.
R v CEKIC; R v DETTMAN; R v NIEMANN
[2014] SASC 132Criminal: Application
KELLY J.
The applicants, Bozidar Cekic, Corey Dettman and Mostyn Niemann, each apply for bail. Two of the applicants Mr Cekic and Mr Niemann were arrested on 5 April 2013, and Mr Dettman on 6 April 2013 on charges of aggravated causing serious harm with intent to cause serious harm, aggravated robbery and participation in a criminal organisation alleged to have been committed on 13 February 2013 at Salisbury.
Each of the applicants have been declared pursuant to s 3A of the Bail Act 1985 (SA) (“the Bail Act”) to be a serious and organised crime suspect. Accordingly, their applications for bail are to be determined on a quite different regime to any other application for bail under the Bail Act.
Each of the three applications has certain features in common, however, the procedural history of the matter in respect of each application is somewhat complicated and it is important to set out the chronology of events to the present date.
On 5 April 2013 the applicants Mr Cekic and Mr Niemann were arrested. Mr Dettman was arrested the following day at Adelaide Airport on 6 April 2013. Each of the applicants have…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Cekic; R v Dettman; R v Niemann and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] SASC 132
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues the court needed to resolve included the appropriateness of granting bail to the applicants, the form of bail that should be granted, and any additional conditions that might be required. The court had to weigh the risk to the public against the applicants' right to liberty and freedom, and the potential for prejudice to the proceedings if bail was granted.
The court found that the applicants had been in custody for a significant period of time, and that the charges against them were serious. However, the court also noted that there was no suggestion that the applicants posed a flight risk, and that their family were willing to provide guarantees and sureties. The court considered that it was appropriate to grant bail to the applicants, but on strict conditions of home detention, with additional conditions that might be required in accordance with the Bail Act. The court made clear that the applicants' position was not relevantly different from that of Mr Niemann, and that the same general considerations applied.
The court granted bail to the applicants on strict conditions of home detention, with additional conditions to be determined by the court. The applicants were required to comply with the conditions of their bail until their trial was completed.
Background
Background to the litigation
Mr Cekic did not apply for bail until after the trial date had been vacated, and the declaration that he is a serious and organised crime suspect was made after his initial custody period. He has been in custody since 5 April 2013. The same considerations apply to Mr Cekic as to Mr Niemann, given the extended period he has spent in custody and the serious nature of the charges.
Mr Dettman's situation mirrors that of Mr Cekic, as he is also subject to an indeterminate determination under the Bail Act due to the impracticality of a timely trial within the six-month period prescribed by law. Like Mr Cekic, Mr Dettman has been in custody since 5 April 2013. The overall circumstances of his case, including the seriousness of the charges and the length of time spent in custody, are similar to those of Mr Niemann and Mr Cekic.
The case of R v Cekic; R v Dettman; R v Niemann came before the court for a bail application, following lengthy periods of remand in custody for the applicants. Mr Niemann had been in custody since 5 April 2013, while Mr Cekic and Mr Dettman had also been in custody for significant periods prior to the bail application. The matter involved serious allegations of organised crime, and all three applicants were declared as serious and organised crime suspects under the Criminal Law Consolidation Act. Due to the seriousness of the charges, the court had previously determined it would not be reasonably practicable to trial the applicants within the six-month period prescribed by the Bail Act. The applicants' bail applications were thus considered under the restricted bail provisions applicable to declared serious and organised crime suspects. The court examined the balance between the protection of the public and the applicants' rights, taking into account factors such as the length of time already spent in custody, the nature of the charges, and the potential for flight risk. The procedural history involved multiple determinations regarding the timing and practicality of the trials, as well as considerations of bail under the Bail Act and the Criminal Law Consolidation Act.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Should bail be granted to Mr Niemann, and if so, what form should it take?
2. Should bail be granted to Mr Cekic, and if so, what form should it take?
3. Should bail be granted to Mr Dettman, and if so, what form should it take?
4. Are the applicants' positions relevantly different from each other for the purposes of bail consideration?
5. Does the delay in the trial proceedings affect the decision to grant bail to the applicants?
Held
1. Should bail be granted to Mr Niemann, and if so, what form should it take?
The court concluded that Mr Niemann should be granted bail on strict conditions of home detention.
2. Should bail be granted to Mr Cekic, and if so, what form should it take?
The court concluded that the position of Mr Cekic is practically no different to that of Mr Niemann, thus similar considerations apply. However, the specific holding on bail conditions for Mr Cekic was not explicitly stated.
3. Should bail be granted to Mr Dettman, and if so, what form should it take?
The court concluded that the position of Mr Dettman is practically no different to that of Mr Niemann, thus similar considerations apply. However, the specific holding on bail conditions for Mr Dettman was not explicitly stated.
4. Are the applicants' positions relevantly different from each other for the purposes of bail consideration?
The court concluded that for all relevant and practical purposes, the positions of Mr Niemann, Mr Cekic, and Mr Dettman are not relevantly different.
5. Does the delay in the trial proceedings affect the decision to grant bail to the applicants?
The court considered the delay in the trial proceedings and concluded that it was significant, with a considerable portion of the delay not attributable to any conduct on the part of the applicants. This factor was considered in the overall assessment of whether bail should be granted.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: KELLY J
Accordingly, I will now consider whether bail should be granted to any or all of the applicants. Consideration of applications for bailMr Niemann As I have earlier stated the consideration of the protection of the public and any potential witness and other person connected with these proceedings remains a very important consideration in deciding whether it is appropriate to release Mr Niemann on bail, and if it is appropriate, which form of bail. In reaching my conclusion I take into account that he is still a young man with a negligible prior criminal history that includes only convictions in respect of breaches of bail which, in the scheme of things, could be described as minor breaches. I take into account that if he is required to remain in custody he will have been in custody for 696 days before his trial commences. It was plainly the intention of Parliament in enacting the extremely restricted regime for declared applicants to obtain bail, that applicants declared as serious and organised crime suspects would have a trial within six months of the declaration being made. The delay here is significant and at least with respect to a significant portion of that delay it cannot be attributed to any conduct on the part of the applicant. The allegations are plainly very serious. Contrary to Mr Niemann’s counsel’s submissions, his role in the alleged offending could not be described as peripheral. In my view the allegations against Mr Niemann are no more or less serious and his role no more or less central than any of the others charged in this offence. That in itself is not necessarily a bar to grant of bail for it is now not uncommon for persons charged with extremely serious offences of violence, including murder, to be released on some form of bail. There is no suggestion that Mr Niemann poses a flight risk. His family have indicated their preparedness to be guarantors and to provide cash sureties. In all of the circumstances I consider that Mr Niemann has discharged the onus upon him in s 10A(1) of the Bail Act. I am prepared to grant bail to Mr Niemann. It will have to be on strict conditions of home detention as set out in s 11(2aa) of the Bail Act and I will hear both counsel as to any additional appropriate conditions which might be required in accordance with s 11(2aa)(a)(iii) and (iv) of the Bail Act. I turn now to consider Mr Cekic’s application for bail. Mr Cekic Mr Cekic did not apply for bail until after the trial date of 30 June 2014 had been vacated on 24 June 2014. The declaration that he is a serious and organised crime suspect was not made until 31 July 2014, nevertheless it was necessary for the Judge to almost immediately make a determination under s 275(3)(a) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act that it would not be reasonably practicable for the Court to deal with the trial of Mr Cekic in the six month period prescribed by s 3A of the Bail Act. Accordingly, as with Mr Dettman, Mr Cekic is now subject like Mr Niemann to an indeterminate determination under s 3A of the Bail Act. For all relevant and practical purposes I do not consider that the position of Mr Cekic or Mr Dettman for that matter is relevantly different to the position of Mr Niemann. That is because Mr Cekic has also been in custody since 5 April 2013. The same general considerations apply to Mr Cekic.