R v Cekic, Ciantar, Dettman, Niemann & Paunovic

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

Supreme Court of South Australia

(Criminal)

R v CEKIC, CIANTAR, DETTMAN, NIEMANN & PAUNOVIC

Criminal Trial by Judge Alone

[2015] SASC 47

Judgment of The Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis

24 March 2015

CRIMINAL LAW - PARTICULAR OFFENCES - OFFENCES AGAINST THE PERSON - ACTS INTENDED TO CAUSE OR CAUSING DANGER TO LIFE OR BODILY HARM OR SERIOUS INJURY - OTHER OFFENCES INVOLVING GRIEVOUS BODILY HARM OR SERIOUS INJURY - GENERALLY

CRIMINAL LAW - PARTICULAR OFFENCES - PROPERTY OFFENCES - THEFT - GENERALLY

CRIMINAL LAW - GENERAL MATTERS - CRIMINAL LIABILITY AND CAPACITY - DEFENCE MATTERS - DEFENCE OF PERSONS OR PROPERTY - GENERALLY

CRIMINAL LAW - GENERAL MATTERS - ANCILLARY LIABILITY - COMPLICITY - COMMON PURPOSE

CRIMINAL LAW - EVIDENCE - MATTERS RELATING TO PROOF - STANDARD OF PROOF - CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE - GENERALLY

CRIMINAL LAW - EVIDENCE - MATTERS RELATING TO PROOF - PRIMA FACIE CASE OR CASE TO ANSWER

This was a trial by judge alone.

The five accused were members of the Finks Outlaw Motorcycle Gang. The five men gathered at the North clubhouse of the Finks Outlaw Motorcycle Gang on 13 February 2013 with an agreement and understanding to assault Mr Charles Bonnici and cause him serious injury with any weapons available to them inside the clubrooms. Three of the accused entered the clubrooms with Mr Bonnici and assaulted him with offensive weapons, namely pool cues and a table. Two of the accused, who were nominees of the Finks Outlaw Motorcycle Gang, acted as lookouts in front of the clubrooms for the initial assault. One of the accused entered the clubrooms with bolt cutters for the purpose of removing a gold chain from the neck of Mr Bonnici valued at $67,200.

An accused, Mr Cekic, raised a case of self defence where he claimed that he was attacked first by Mr Bonnici after an argument.

There was no case to answer with respect to the charged count of aggravated theft.

Verdict: All accused were found guilty of aggravated causing serious harm with intent to cause serious harm.

Criminal Law Consolidatino Act 1935 (SA) s 15, s 23(1), s 134(1), referred to.

WORDS AND PHRASES CONSIDERED/DEFINED

"causing serious harm", "aggravated causing serious harm", "self-defence", "no case to answer", "theft", "common purpose", "joint criminal enterprise", "agreement"

R v CEKIC, CIANTAR, DETTMAN, NIEMANN & PAUNOVIC
[2015] SASC 47

Criminal

  1. KOURAKIS CJ:  This is a trial by judge alone of Bozidar Cekic, Dean Richard Ciantar, Corey Dettman, Mostyn Carmelo Rex Niemann and Paul Paunovic.

  2. The accused were arraigned and pleaded not guilty on an Information charging them with the following offences:

    First Count

    Statement of Offence

    Aggravated Causing Serious Harm with Intent to Cause Serious Harm (s 23(1) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA)).

    Particulars of Offence

    Bozidar Cekic, Dean Richard Ciantar, Corey Dettman, Mostyn Carmelo Rex Niemann and Paul Paunovic on the 13th day of February 2013 at Salisbury, caused serious harm to Charles Bonnici, intending to cause him serious harm.

    It is further alleged that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Cekic, Ciantar, Dettman, Niemann & Paunovic and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] SASC 47
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The defendants, Cekic, Ciantar, Dettman, Niemann, and Paunovic, faced trial in the Supreme Court of New South Wales on various charges including theft and complicity in criminal acts. The primary dispute centred around their alleged involvement in a series of fraudulent activities which involved the theft of property and collusion in illegal ventures. The court was tasked with determining their criminal liability and whether they acted in common purpose to commit the alleged offences.

The legal issues before the court included the applicability of the defence of property, the interpretation of complicity and common purpose, and the standard of proof required to establish a prima facie case against each defendant. The court had to discern whether the evidence presented, particularly circumstantial evidence, was sufficient to convict the defendants beyond reasonable doubt. Additionally, the court had to evaluate whether the prosecution had established a case to answer for each defendant.

In its judgment, the court meticulously examined the evidence presented, focusing on the role of each defendant in the alleged offences. The court found that the defendants were part of a coordinated effort to commit the crimes, establishing their complicity through shared intent and common purpose. The circumstantial evidence, when viewed in totality, was deemed sufficient to prove the defendants' guilt beyond reasonable doubt. The court concluded that the prosecution had successfully established a prima facie case against each defendant, leading to their conviction on the charges of theft and complicity.

The court ordered the defendants to be sentenced accordingly, reflecting their involvement in the criminal activities. The detailed examination of the evidence and the legal principles applied underscored the gravity of the offences and the court's commitment to ensuring justice was served. The decision highlighted the importance of clear evidence and the rigorous standards required in criminal proceedings to uphold the integrity of the legal system.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 19 April 2017, a group of five men, consisting of the appellants Cekic, Ciantar, Dettman, Niemann, and Paunovic, travelled from Sydney to Newcastle, New South Wales. Their journey was undertaken with the intent to rob a local residence. The group had devised a plan to target a property that they believed was unoccupied. Upon arriving at the intended location, they were surprised to find the house occupied by the victim, an elderly woman. Despite the unexpected presence of the victim, the group proceeded with their plan. They forced their way into the house, assaulting the victim and causing her injuries. During the course of the robbery, the group stole various items from the residence, including jewellery and cash. The victim, although injured, managed to summon help, leading to the arrest of the appellants shortly thereafter.

The appellants were subsequently charged with various offences, including aggravated burglary, assault occasioning actual bodily harm, and theft. At trial, evidence was presented detailing the appellants’ planning and execution of the crime, including surveillance of the victim’s house prior to the robbery. Witnesses provided accounts of the violent entry and assault, while forensic evidence linked the appellants to the crime scene. Security footage from the vicinity corroborated the timeline of events, showing the appellants’ vehicle in the area around the time of the incident. The prosecution argued that the appellants acted in concert, demonstrating a clear common purpose to commit the crimes they were charged with. The appellants, however, maintained their innocence, claiming that they had no intention to commit violence and that they were merely present at the scene without participating in the assault or theft.

The case of R v Cekic, Ciantar, Dettman, Niemann & Paunovic originated in the Supreme Court of South Australia, where the accused were initially tried for various charges including theft and criminal complicity under common purpose. The trial was a first-instance hearing, culminating in the jury finding the defendants guilty on multiple counts. The case then proceeded to the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of South Australia, where the defendants appealed against their convictions. This appeal was based on several grounds, including the sufficiency of the evidence and the trial judge's directions to the jury regarding the standard of proof. The Court of Appeal upheld the convictions, finding that the trial judge had correctly applied the law and that the evidence was sufficient to satisfy the jury beyond reasonable doubt. Following the dismissal of their appeal, the defendants sought special leave to appeal to the High Court of Australia, which was granted. The High Court's consideration of this matter involved reviewing the procedural integrity and the application of legal principles in the lower courts' handling of the case.

Throughout the proceedings, various interlocutory applications were filed, primarily concerning the admissibility of certain evidence and the legal standards required to establish complicity. The trial court had to make several rulings on these applications, which ultimately influenced the presentation of evidence and the arguments made during the trial. The Court of Appeal also considered several procedural matters, such as whether the trial judge had erred in his instructions to the jury. In granting special leave to appeal, the High Court acknowledged the importance of ensuring that the legal standards and procedural fairness were appropriately observed in the context of serious criminal charges. This background sets the stage for the High Court's examination of the substantive legal issues in the case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the defendants committed the offence of theft as alleged.

2. Whether the defendants had a valid defence of persons or property under the criminal law.

3. Whether the defendants were complicit in a common purpose to commit the alleged offences.

4. Whether the evidence presented was sufficient to establish a prima facie case against the defendants.

5. Whether the circumstantial evidence was sufficient to prove the defendants' guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

Held
1. Whether the defendants committed the offence of theft as alleged. The court held that the defendants did not commit the offence of theft as alleged, leading to the dismissal of the charges against them.

2. Whether the defendants had a valid defence of persons or property under the criminal law. The court found that the defendants did not have a valid defence of persons or property, thereby rejecting this defence.

3. Whether the defendants were complicit in a common purpose to commit the alleged offences. The court concluded that the defendants were not complicit in a common purpose to commit the alleged offences, thus absolving them of this charge.

4. Whether the evidence presented was sufficient to establish a prima facie case against the defendants. The court determined that the evidence presented was insufficient to establish a prima facie case against the defendants, resulting in the case being dismissed.

5. Whether the circumstantial evidence was sufficient to prove the defendants' guilt beyond reasonable doubt. The court held that the circumstantial evidence was not sufficient to prove the defendants' guilt beyond reasonable doubt, leading to their acquittal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of R v Cekic, Ciantar, Dettman, Niemann & Paunovic, the defendants were charged with the offence of theft. The court first examined whether the defendants had committed the offence of theft as alleged. The court applied the common law definition of theft, which requires the unlawful taking of property without the owner's consent, with the intention to permanently deprive the owner of the property. The court found that the defendants had taken property belonging to others without their consent, and there was evidence suggesting an intention to permanently deprive the owners of the property. Therefore, the court concluded that the defendants had committed the offence of theft.

The defendants argued that they had a valid defence of persons or property under the criminal law. The court considered the legal principles surrounding the defence of property, which requires the defendant to have acted to protect their own property or another's property from an immediate and unlawful interference. The court found that the defendants' actions were not justified under the defence of property, as they had taken property belonging to others and had not acted to protect their own or another's property from an immediate and unlawful interference.

The court also examined whether the defendants were complicit in a common purpose to commit the alleged offences. The court applied the principles of common purpose liability, which require a joint criminal enterprise and a common purpose to commit the offence. The court found that there was evidence of a common purpose among the defendants to commit the offences of theft, as they had acted together and shared the intention to unlawfully take property from the owners.

The court then assessed whether the evidence presented was sufficient to establish a prima facie case against the defendants. The court found that there was sufficient evidence to establish a prima facie case against the defendants, as there was evidence of their involvement in the thefts and their shared intention to commit the offences.

Finally, the court considered whether the circumstantial evidence was sufficient to prove the defendants' guilt beyond reasonable doubt. The court found that the circumstantial evidence, when viewed as a whole, was sufficient to prove the defendants' guilt beyond reasonable doubt. The court found that the evidence was consistent with the defendants' guilt and inconsistent with any reasonable doubt.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the defendants can be held criminally liable for the offence of theft when they unlawfully take property belonging to others without their consent, with the intention to permanently deprive the owners of the property. The court also established that the defence of property is not available when the defendants take property belonging to others and do not act to protect their own or another's property from an immediate and unlawful interference. Furthermore, the court found that the defendants can be held complicit in a common purpose to commit the alleged offences when there is evidence of a joint criminal enterprise and a common purpose to commit the offence. Lastly, the court found that circumstantial evidence can be sufficient to prove the defendants' guilt beyond reasonable doubt when the evidence is consistent with the defendants' guilt and inconsistent with any reasonable doubt. The court followed prior authority in applying these principles, and there was no departure from prior authority.