R v Bunting & Wagner (No 9) No. Sccrm-01-205

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

R v BUNTING & WAGNER (NO 9)
[2003] SASC 257

Criminal:  Reasons for Rulings

  1. MARTIN J            John Justin Bunting and Robert Joe Wagner are jointly charged with eleven counts of murder alleged to have been committed between December 1995 and May 1999.  In addition, Bunting is charged with a further count of murder alleged to have been committed in 1992 with Mark Ray Haydon and Wagner is charged with Assisting Offenders in connection with that crime of murder.  Haydon has been granted a separate trial with respect to that and to other charges of murder.  The facts are set out in detail in R v Bunting and Others(No 3) [2003] SASC 251.

  2. As the facts alleged by the Crown demonstrate, this matter is an exceptional case in a number of respects.  Some of the allegations are horrific.  It is likely that members of the jury will find some of the evidence distressing.  The case has been attended by an exceptionally large amount of publicity and the intensity and quantity of publicity is likely to continue throughout the trial.  The nature of the case and the publicity accompanying it have given rise to considerable speculation and rumour within the community.  It is estimated that the jury will be engaged in the trial for approximately six months.

  3. Against that background, the accused submitted that I should question all potential jurors either by written questionnaire or in person or by both means about a number of matters which the accused said were relevant to the ability and suitability of each potential juror to sit as a juror in the trial.  I refused the application and I now set out my reasons.

  4. The matters about which the accused contended each juror should be asked are conveniently set out in Bunting’s Rule 9 Notice filed for the purposes of the pre-trial applications.  The relevant paragraphs of the notice are as follows:

    “2. That the questionnaire or questioning include enquiries of each potential juror about:

    (a)Whether he/she has a family member or friend who is or has been a member of the police force;

    (b)Whether he/she, his/her spouse or member of his/her family has ever been the victim of violent assault;

    (c)Whether he/she, his/her spouse or member of his/her family has ever been the victim of a sexual assault;

    (d)Whether he/she has in the past or does now suffer from any psychological or psychiatric condition;

    (e)Whether he/she holds strong views that are either favourable or unfavourable towards homosexuals;

    (f)Whether he/she holds strong views that are either favourable or unfavourable about the punishment of paedophiles or people convicted of sexual offences against minors.

    3.   That each potential juror be asked about his/her emotional state and his/her ability to endure a long trial (on the assumption that the potential jurors will be informed as to the best reasonable estimate for the trial that they will be undertaking).

    4.   That each potential juror be asked whether he/she has formed any opinion as to the guilt or innocence…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Bunting & Wagner (No 9) No. Sccrm-01-205 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] SASC 257
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of R v Bunting & Wagner (No 9) involves the accused, John Justin Bunting and Robert Joe Wagner, who are jointly charged with eleven counts of murder, with Bunting additionally charged with a count of murder in 1992 and Wagner charged with assisting an offender in connection with that crime. The accused sought to question potential jurors about various matters to determine their suitability for the trial, citing the exceptional nature of the case and the significant publicity it had attracted. The Crown opposed the accused's application, arguing that the trial should not be treated differently from others and that the circumstances did not warrant the proposed measures.

The legal issue before the court was whether the accused had the right to question potential jurors about personal matters as part of the jury selection process, given the exceptional nature of the case. The court considered the relevant statutory provisions under the South Australian Juries Act 1927, which do not specifically permit such questioning. However, the court recognised an inherent power in judges to exclude jurors from a particular trial in the interests of justice, which could include questioning jurors to ascertain relevant information.

The court held that while the power to question jurors existed, it should only be exercised in exceptional circumstances. The court noted that the nature of the case, including the horrific allegations and extensive publicity, did require careful direction to potential jurors. However, the court found that the circumstances did not warrant the level of questioning proposed by the accused. The court was concerned that such questioning might infringe on jurors' privacy rights and did not believe the exceptional nature of the case justified the proposed measures. Consequently, the application to question potential jurors was refused.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

MARTIN J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MARTIN J