R v Bunting & Wagner (No 8) No. Sccrm-01-205

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

R v BUNTING & WAGNER (NO 8)
[2003] SASC 256

Criminal:   Reasons for Rulings

  1. MARTIN J           John Justin Bunting and Robert Joe Wagner are jointly charged with eleven counts of murder alleged to have been committed between December 1995 and May 1999.  In addition, Bunting is charged with a further count of murder alleged to have been committed in 1992 with Mark Ray Haydon and Wagner is charged with Assisting Offenders in connection with that crime of murder.  Haydon has been granted a separate trial with respect to that and other charges of murder.

  2. The facts are set out in detail in R v Bunting and Others(No 3) [2003] SASC 251. The Crown proposes to lead statements by two of the deceased, Barry Lane and Thomas Trevilyan. The accused objected on the basis that the evidence is inadmissible or, if admissible, is so unreliable and unfairly prejudicial that it should be excluded in the exercise of the discretion. I now set out my reasons for rulings I gave in respect of the statements.

    Statements by Lane

  3. It is the Crown case that Lane was murdered in October or November 1997.  Ms Michelle Bihet was Lane’s fiancée.  She said that in about 1996 Lane confessed to her that Wagner had told him to get rid of some garbage bags which were supposed to contain the remains of the deceased Trezise.  He said he was told to get rid of them “up north somewhere” and did so.  Only Wagner’s name was mentioned, but Ms Bihet has a memory that Lane also spoke of a friend of Wagner without identifying that friend.

  4. During cross-examination at the preliminary examination, Bihet said that Lane told her he did not know what was in the bags.  He guessed that they contained human remains and that they were the remains of Trezise.

  5. As will appear later in these reasons, in my opinion other statements by Lane are admissible for the purpose of establishing Lane’s knowledge of the murder of Trezise.  However, the statement by Lane to Bihet does not establish knowledge of that or any other murder.  The facts of which Lane spoke cannot be related to any murder.  In those circumstances, in my opinion the statement to Bihet is inadmissible.

  6. Ms Krystal Spencely-Smith is Lane’s sister.  She says that in November 1995 she had a conversation with Lane in which he asked if he could come to live with her in Brisbane because he was afraid for his life.  He said he was afraid of Wagner.  Spencely-Smith asked what was going on.  Lane replied that he witnessed Wagner and two other men murder “Clinton” [Trezise] and that they forced him to help dispose of the body under a bridge.  The body was later moved to another location.  Lane said that because of this they thought he knew too much and he was scared they were going to kill him.

  7. Spencely-Smith says the conversation occurred in the front yard of the premises at which Lane…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Bunting & Wagner (No 8) No. Sccrm-01-205 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] SASC 256
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of R v Bunting & Wagner (No 8) involved the defendants John Justin Bunting and Robert Joe Wagner, who were jointly charged with eleven counts of murder and Wagner was additionally charged with Assisting Offenders. The Crown sought to lead statements made by two deceased individuals, Barry Lane and Thomas Trevilyan, which were objected to by the accused on grounds of inadmissibility, unreliability, and unfair prejudice. Martin J ruled on the admissibility of these statements, determining that statements by Lane concerning his knowledge of the murder of Trezise and his fear of the accused were admissible to establish motive and state of mind, while statements indicating the accused's involvement in the murder were to be excluded to prevent misuse and circular reasoning. Statements by Trevilyan were deemed admissible to show his knowledge of the murder of Lane, with certain details excluded to mitigate the risk of misuse.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

MARTIN J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MARTIN J