R v BUNTING & WAGNER (NO 6)
[2003] SASC 254Criminal: Reasons for Rulings
MARTIN J John Justin Bunting and Robert Joe Wagner are jointly charged with eleven counts of murder alleged to have been committed between December 1995 and May 1999. In addition, Bunting is charged with a further count of murder alleged to have been committed in 1992 with Mark Ray Haydon and Wagner is charged with Assisting Offenders in connection with that crime of murder. Haydon has been granted a separate trial with respect to that and other charges of murder.
The facts are set out in detail in R v Bunting and Others (No 3) [2003] SASC 251. The Crown intends to lead evidence from a number of witnesses purporting either to identify positively the accused as persons engaged in carrying out activities relevant to the Crown case or to identify the accused as persons bearing similarities to those engaged in such activities. In addition to specific objections related to individual witnesses, a general objection to such identification evidence was taken by the accused because the identifications were made from photographs attached to photoboards containing a number of photographs of the heads and shoulders of the accused and other persons. I ruled against the general objection and I now set out my reasons for that ruling.
The accused were arrested on 21 May 1999. On 2 July 1999 fresh information was laid charging the accused with additional counts of murder. On 16 September 1999 the Director of Public Prosecutions (“the Director”) wrote to solicitors acting for the accused inquiring whether the accused were prepared to participate in a formal identification parade. The letter was in the following terms:
“I am advised by the police officers who are investigating this matter that they intend to give potential witnesses in this matter the opportunity to identify your client.
I write to ask if your client is prepared to participate in a formal identification parade?
I request that you advise of your client’s attitude to participating in a formal identification parade before the next court appearance on 5 October 1999.
If your client declines to participate in a formal identification parade, or if I have received no response by that time, the investigating police officers will attempt to arrange identification by alternative means.
If you wish to discuss this matter further please contact Rebecca Gray (82071584) of this Office.”
No reply was ever received from solicitors acting for Wagner. There is no evidence that any further communication took place between the Director and solicitors for Wagner concerning this issue.
Counsel for Bunting responded by letter of 5 October 1999. The letter indicated that the instructing solicitor was absent on leave. The relevant parts of the response were as follows:
“Due to the current state of this case I am not in a position to advise my client adequately about the issue of an identification parade. Therefore, at this time, Mr Bunting neither agrees nor declines to take…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Bunting & Wagner (No 6) No. Sccrm-01-205 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] SASC 254
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issue before the court was whether the defendants were entitled to certain information about the witnesses' descriptions of the accused before participating in an identification parade. The defendants argued that they needed this information to make an informed decision about whether to participate in the parade. The court examined the established procedures for identification parades and the requirements for offering an accused the opportunity to participate in such a parade. It noted that while fairness was a key consideration, the prevailing view in South Australia was that fairness in an identification parade was best achieved by ensuring that the participants resembled the accused in build and appearance.
The court ruled against the defendants' general objection, stating that there was no requirement for the accused to be provided with witness descriptions before the identification process. The court found that the investigators had complied with their duty to offer the defendants the opportunity to participate in an identification parade. The failure of Bunting to respond to the final ultimatum was deemed a refusal to participate, and the court found it reasonable for the investigators to interpret Wagner's solicitor's silence as a refusal. The court concluded that the investigators followed accepted procedures and that the defendants had refused to participate, allowing the evidence to be admitted.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: