CITATION: R v Brendan CUTMORE & R v Edward DAVIS [2009] NSWDC 261 HEARING DATE(S): 27 July 2009 - 29 July 2009
JUDGMENT DATE:
29 July 2009JURISDICTION: District Court Criminal JUDGMENT OF: Sweeney DCJ DECISION: Certificate granted CATCHWORDS: Criminal law - Judgment - Costs - Evidence excluded under s 137 Evidence Act 1995 - No further proceedings directed by Director of Public Prosecutions - Application for certificate pursuant to Costs in Criminal Cases Act 1967 LEGISLATION CITED: Evidence Act 1995
Costs in Criminal Cases Act 1967CASES CITED: Chahal v Director of Public Prosecutions [2008] NSWCA 152
KJF, unreported Supreme Court, 7 December 2007
R v Blick [2000] NSWCCA 61
R v Pavy (1997) 98 A Crim R 396PARTIES: The Crown
Brendan Cutmore
Edward DavisFILE NUMBER(S): DC 2009/11/0332; DC 2009/11/0333 COUNSEL: Mr C Everson (Crown)
Ms S Kluss (Mr Cutmore)
Ms L McSpedden (Mr Davis)SOLICITORS: NSWDPP
Sam Hegney Solicitors Armidale (Mr Cutmore)
Jarratt Webb & Graham Advocacy Pty Ltd (Mr Davis)
JUDGMENT
1 HER HONOUR: On Monday 27 July 2009 Brendan Cutmore and Edward Davis were arraigned for the purpose of some preliminary legal arguments on an indictment containing four joint counts being aggravated break and enter with intent to steal, aggravated break enter and steal, attempt aggravated break and enter with intent to steal and be carried in a conveyance without the owner’s consent. Mr Cutmore was also charged with an assault.
2 On Tuesday 28 July I excluded evidence of photographic identification of both accused pursuant to section 137 Evidence Act1995. The Director of Public Prosecutions thereafter directed that there be no further proceedings against both men.
3 Mr Cutmore and Mr Davis then made an application for a certificate under the Costs In Criminal Cases Act 1967. Each bears the onus of showing that the test in the Act has been met. The Crown opposes the granting of a certificate.
4 On the applications I have considered all of the material I considered in the voir dire on the identification evidence, which was essentially the Crown brief, plus the New South Wales Police Services Procedures on Identification Evidence which were tendered in this application.
5 Ms Kluss for Mr Cutmore also notionally tendered on this application the judgment I delivered in excluding the identification evidence. The Crown submitted that that judgment is not a “relevant fact” to be taken into account in considering the test in the Costs in Criminal Cases Act. I agree.
6 Section 2 of the Costs inCriminal Cases Act provides that a Court may, where after the commencement of a trial a direction is given by the Director of Public Prosecutions that no further proceedings be taken, grant to the accused a certificate specifying the matters referred to in section 3 of the Act relating to the proceedings. A trial includes preliminary proceedings such as a voir dire, as was held in this trial.
7 The test in section 3 of the Act, and as has…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Brendan Cutmore and R v Edward Davis and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] NSWDC 261
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court began by examining the statutory framework governing costs in criminal cases. It determined that a certificate could be granted if the defendant was acquitted or the Director of Public Prosecutions directed that no further proceedings be taken. The court noted that while the excluded evidence under section 137 of the Evidence Act 1995 was significant, it did not impact the Director's decision to halt further proceedings. The court concluded that the defendants were entitled to a certificate as they were effectively acquitted due to the prosecutorial decision. The exclusion of evidence, while prejudicial, did not negate the basis for the certificate under the Act.
Consequently, the court granted the defendants' application for a certificate, thereby ordering that they were entitled to a costs order. This decision recognised the unique circumstances where prosecutorial decisions effectively lead to an acquittal, ensuring the defendants could recover their costs despite the complexities of the case. The ruling underscores the importance of statutory interpretation in balancing the rights of defendants with the prosecutorial discretion afforded by the Evidence Act 1995.
Orders
Orders of the court
Certificate granted
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi