Court
DISTRICT COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
Reasons of His Honour Judge Lunn
Hearing
24/02/97.
Catchwords
CRIMINAL LAW Inspection of depositions from committal proceedings on District Court file - held to be "documentary material" within S52(2)(d) of District Court Act - criteria for exercise of administrative discretion for permission to inspect - procedure to be followed - permission granted to media - cases considered. CRIMINAL LAW Inspection of application for enforcement of a bond - held not within S54(2)(c) as material placed before Court on sentencing - held to be "process relating to proceedings" within S54(1)(aa) and so available for inspection as of right.
Representation
R:
Counsel: MS K SHEPHERD - Solicitors: DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS
Accused ADAM JAMES BERGER:
No Attendance
Participant ADVERTISER NEWSPAPERS:
Counsel: MR A SHORT - Solicitors: MINTER ELLISON
DCCRM-96-1294, DCCRM-97-143
Judgment No. D3569
11 March 1997
(Criminal)
R v ADAM JAMES BERGER
Criminal
Judge Lunn
REASONS FOR ORDERS UNDER SECTION 54 OF THE DISTRICT COURT ACT FOR INSPECTION OF THE COURT FILE
An Information was presented against the defendant in this Court charging him with supplying amphetamine (Ecstasy). The Director of Public Prosecution filed with this Court the material which had been before the Magistrates Court on the committal proceedings which consisted of two statements of witnesses and a record of interview between a detective and the defendant. (There are also other formal papers on the Court file but there is no issue in relation to them.) On 10 February 1997 the defendant pleaded guilty to the charge. At the request of all counsel the further steps in the sentencing process were adjourned to 3 March 1997 for the prosecution to institute proceedings for breach of a bond against the defendant and for his solicitors to obtain a psychological report. No allocutus was given.
Representatives from the media requested to inspect the depositions on the Court file. I informally indicated I would give the necessary permission under Section 54(2) of the District Court Act without holding any hearing if the defendant's solicitors consented. They did not consent. Solicitors for Karen Michelmore, a journalist employed by the Advertiser Newspaper, wrote to the Registrar on 14 February 1997 formally requesting inspection of the depositions. I held a hearing on 24 February to consider the request. Solicitors for the defendant were notified of it but did not attend or otherwise respond. The DPP took a neutral stance. At the conclusion of the hearing I gave permission for the depositions to be inspected by the Advertiser and anyone else who sought to do so. I indicated I would subsequently publish these reasons for my decision because there has been considerable uncertainty about the operation of S54 in respect of depositions and the appropriate procedures to be adopted.
Section 54 of the District Court Act at present provides as follows:
"54(1) Subject to this section, the Court must, on application by any member of the public, allow the applicant to inspect or obtain a copy of -
(aa) any process relating…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Berger No. DCCRM-96-1294, DCCRM-97-143 Judgment No. D356... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1997] SADC 3569
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court were whether the depositions were "documentary material" within Section 52(2)(d) of the District Court Act, and whether the criteria for exercising the administrative discretion to permit inspection were met. The court also had to determine the appropriate procedure for making an application for inspection under Section 54(2) of the District Court Act. Additionally, the court considered whether an application for enforcement of a bond was "material placed before the Court during sentencing proceedings" within Section 54(2)(c), or whether it was "process relating to proceedings" within Section 54(1)(aa) and therefore available for inspection as of right.
The court held that the depositions were "documentary material" within Section 52(2)(d) of the District Court Act and that permission was required to inspect them under Section 54(2). The court determined that the appropriate procedure for making an application for inspection was to send a letter to the Registrar requesting permission and briefly setting out the grounds on which it was sought. The court granted permission for the depositions to be inspected by the media. The court also ruled that the application for enforcement of a bond was "process relating to proceedings" within Section 54(1)(aa) and therefore available for inspection as of right.
The court ordered that the depositions from the committal proceedings could be inspected by the media and anyone else who sought to do so, subject to any conditions the court considered appropriate. The court also ordered that the application for enforcement of a bond was available for inspection as of right.