R v Begg No. DCCRM-97-525 Judgment No. D3798

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

R v BEGG

CRIMINAL
JUDGE RUSSELL

The defendant and his girlfriend, Sharon Marie Murphy, were jointly charged on the information of the Director of Public Prosecutions filed in the Criminal Registry of this Court on 7 January 1998 on two counts of knowingly having amphetamine, a drug of dependence, in their possession for the purpose of selling it to another person.

On the first count the offence was alleged to have been committed at Torrens Park, where they were living, on 21 April 1997.  On the second count the offence was alleged to have been committed at Cumberland Park, where they were living, on 28 September 1997.

It is relevant to notice that both defendants were originally charged with having committed the offence charged in the first count on an information filed on 11 July 1997 and both defendants pleaded not guilty before His Honour Judge Lee on 29 July 1997.

At a status conference held on 11 September 1997 I directed that the matter be set down for trial on 10 November 1997.

Upon a further charge being laid on an information in the Magistrates Court in respect of the subject matter of the second count on the information now before the Court, the trial date on the first information was vacated on 20 October 1997.

It appears from the depositions that as a result of information received, police attended at the residential address of the two accused at Torrens Park on 21 April 1997.  Both defendants and two other persons, John Strachan and Celia Stewart, were present in the house.

A small amount of white powder, believed to be amphetamine, was located in a plastic bag on the kitchen bench in the house.

Ms Murphy identified that as being her property.

Later during the search, a black and white chequered vinyl toilet bag was located on a chair in the lounge.  That bag was identified as belonging to the defendant Begg.  Begg told Detective Holmes that he had a small bag of amphetamine in the toilet bag.

As appears from the transcript of the conversation which was being recorded on an audio tape Detective Holmes said -

‘Alright, I have just removed a large plastic bag, glad bag er, which contains er, I guess three, four separate packages of what appears to be white powder.  Also located in another bag ah, inside the bag, ah inside the black and white chequered bag it’s er contains a quantity of white powder.  There’s another smaller bag er, which is sorter of rolled up, also located in this er, in this vinyl bag.  OK Daniel, Daniel, want you to come here mate, look, at this stage, alright, I am arresting you for possession of Amphetamine for sale OK.’

Upon analysis Mr Pigou, an analyst appointed under the provisions of the Controlled Substances Act 1984, the white powder which weighed 132.69 grams was found by Mr Pigou to contain 11.53 grams of pure amphetamine.

Bearing in mind the deeming provisions of ss(3)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Begg No. DCCRM-97-525 Judgment No. D3798 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] SADC 3989
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of R v Begg involved the defendant, Daniel Thomas Begg, and his girlfriend, Sharon Marie Murphy, who were jointly charged with possessing amphetamine, a drug of dependence, with intent to sell it. The charges were brought by the Director of Public Prosecutions and filed in the Criminal Registry of the South Australian District Court on 7 January 1998. Begg was alleged to have committed the offence at two separate locations on 21 April 1997 and 28 September 1997. Initially, both defendants pleaded not guilty before His Honour Judge Lee on 29 July 1997. However, during the trial on 16 March 1998, Begg entered a plea of guilty to one count of possession of amphetamine for sale and simple possession for the other count. Subsequently, Begg applied to withdraw his plea of guilty on the grounds that he had been pressured by his counsel to change his plea, and that he genuinely believed he was not guilty and had a good defence. The legal issues before the court were whether the defendant's plea of guilty was induced by improper pressure and whether allowing him to withdraw his plea would lead to a miscarriage of justice.

The court examined the evidence and circumstances surrounding the defendant's change of plea. The defendant's counsel, Mr Fardone, admitted that he had been suffering from flu and was physically and mentally drained on the day of the trial. He also acknowledged that he had pressured the defendant to change his plea due to the defendant's concern for his girlfriend's well-being. The defendant testified that he felt under pressure and confused when his counsel advised him to change his plea at the last minute. The court found that the last-minute bargaining by Mr Fardone, combined with his illness and the defendant's confused state of mind, amounted to harassment or other improper pressure. The court concluded that refusing the application to withdraw the plea of guilty might well lead to a miscarriage of justice being done to the defendant.

Accordingly, the court allowed the application and granted leave for the defendant to withdraw his plea of guilty on both counts. The court emphasized the importance of avoiding a possible miscarriage of justice and the need for the trial judge to strive to ensure that no person is wrongfully convicted. The court also noted that any doubt about the propriety of the plea should be resolved in favour of the defendant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.