R v Beattie, Julie Elizabeth Applicant

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

[2024] QCA 77

COURT OF APPEAL

MULLINS P
BOND JA
CALLAGHAN J

CA No 163 of 2023
SC No 291 of 2023

R

v

BEATTIE, Julie Elizabeth  Applicant

BRISBANE

WEDNESDAY, 8 MAY 2024

JUDGMENT

  1. MULLINS P:  The applicant pleaded guilty on the day her trial was due to commence on 25 July 2022 to four counts of supplying the dangerous drug methylamphetamine (respectively on 23, 24, 25 and 26 November 2020) (counts 1-4), possessing a dangerous drug methylamphetamine in excess of two grams on 2 December 2020 (count 5) and possessing a thing (a mobile phone) used in connection with supplying a dangerous drug on 2 December 2020 (count 6).  The applicant failed to appear on the date she was due to be sentenced on 30 September 2022, when she was in hospital for a panic attack, a warrant was issued for her arrest and she was arrested on 6 March 2023 and then granted bail.

  2. The applicant was sentenced on 19 July 2023 to 18 months’ imprisonment for each of counts 1–4, imprisonment of three years and six months for count 5 and imprisonment for three months for count 6.  All sentences were concurrent.  A pre-sentence custody declaration was made in respect of one day spent in pre-sentence custody between 2 and 3 December 2020.  A parole eligibility date was fixed at 18 December 2024 after serving 17 months in custody.

  3. The only ground in the application for leave to appeal against sentence is that the sentence is manifestly excessive.  The applicant advanced additional grounds in her outline of submissions and the respondent did not oppose leave being given to the applicant to amend the grounds of appeal to include:

    (a)miscarriage of justice due to failure of her legal representatives to tender at the sentencing hearing the five character references and a letter from Moonyah Recovery Centre dated 18 July 2023 which she provided to them;

    (b)the sentencing judge erred in considering parity;

    (c)the sentencing judge erred in not finding she was a drug dependent person;

    (d)failure to take into account that the offence occurred during the COVID pandemic;

    (e)matters relevant to immigration that were considered speculative at the time of the sentence had since crystallised.

  4. The applicant has filed an application for leave to adduce evidence, namely the character references and the Moonyah letter.  The application is supported by the applicant’s affidavit sworn on 11 April 2024.  The respondent opposes leave being given to adduce that evidence.

    Circumstances of the offences

  5. There was an agreed statement of facts.  The police were investigating the trafficking of methylamphetamine by a syndicate headed by one Beech.  His telecommunications were intercepted.  He was in contact with an associate of the applicant (the associate).  In October and November 2020 the associate contacted Beech negotiating the purchase of methylamphetamine and on 23 November 2020 agreed on three ounces for $10,000 each.  The associate rented a vehicle from the Brisbane airport which was used to collect the packages from Beech in a round trip of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Beattie, Julie Elizabeth Applicant and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QCA 77
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of the Commonwealth of Australia versus Julie Elizabeth Beattie, the Court of Appeal was called upon to determine the applicant's applications for leave to adduce new evidence and to appeal against her sentence. The applicant, who had been convicted of various criminal offences, sought to introduce new evidence to the Court which had not been presented at her original sentencing hearing. This included character references, a letter concerning a previous associate, and information regarding her possible deportation. Additionally, the applicant contested the severity of her sentence, arguing that it was manifestly excessive and did not properly consider certain factors such as the COVID-19 pandemic and the possibility of deportation.

The legal issues before the Court were whether the new evidence could be considered in the context of an appeal against sentence, and if the sentence imposed was manifestly excessive. In addressing these issues, the Court considered the relevance and admissibility of the new evidence, the appropriateness of the sentence given the circumstances, and the principle of finality in sentencing matters. The Court was required to balance the interests of justice with the need to maintain the integrity of the sentencing process.

The Court found that the new evidence, particularly the character references and the letter concerning the previous associate, did not warrant a departure from the original sentencing decision. The Court determined that the new evidence did not provide any substantial grounds to reconsider the sentence. Regarding the sentence itself, the Court held that the sentence imposed by the original sentencing judge was within the appropriate range and took into account the relevant aggravating and mitigating factors. The Court was satisfied that the sentencing judge had appropriately considered the late guilty plea and the COVID-19 pandemic, and concluded that the sentence was not manifestly excessive.

Accordingly, the Court refused the application for leave to adduce new evidence and the application for leave to appeal against the sentence. The Court's orders were that the application for leave to adduce evidence be refused, and that the application for leave to appeal against sentence be refused.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

There was no error in the sentencing judge proceeding on the basis that the maximum penalty for count 5 was 25 years’ imprisonment.Application for leave to adduce evidence For the reason that the Moonyah letter would not have assisted the applicant at the sentencing hearing, leave to adduce that letter should be refused. The character reference from the applicant’s daughter which is dated 8 April 2024 makes unsworn factual assertions against the associate and deals with matters that are subsequent to the sentence and therefore should not be received. The factual information in the four character references dated July 2023 was largely incorporated into the applicant’s counsel’s written submissions that were before the sentencing judge. That was a matter for the applicant’s counsel. It is not in the interests of justice for those letters to be received now in connection with the application for leave to appeal.Parity, COVID and possible deportation The sentencing judge dealt with the issue of parity on the basis of the sentencing submissions in relation to the associate, the associate’s criminal history and circumstances and the sentence imposed on the associate. The applicant’s sentencing submissions seek to adduce additional factual matters that undermine the basis on which parity was considered by the sentencing judge. Those matters were not sworn to by the applicant and there has been no attempt by the applicant to show why those factual matters which were always known to the applicant should be adduced now on the sentence leave application. The applicant does not seek to adduce any further evidence in relation to her possible deportation. She did inform the Court, without objection, that she has now been advised of the mandatory cancellation of her visa. The sentencing judge’s conclusion that it was a matter for speculation as to whether she would be able to have the mandatory cancellation of her visa successfully reviewed is not controverted by that development. The applicant had one day in pre-sentence custody during the COVID pandemic, so that her assertion that there was a failure to take into account that the offence occurred during the COVID pandemic is irrelevant.Was the sentence manifestly excessive? The head sentence imposed by the sentencing judge for count 5 fell within the range that was the subject of submissions of both the prosecutor and the applicant’s counsel. It was supported by many comparable authorities including R v Hawke [2021] QCA 179, R v Nicholson [2016] QCA 315 and R v Gerhardt (2019) 3 QR 48. The date for eligibility for parole was fixed after the applicant will have served approximately 40 per cent of the head sentence and reflects the sentencing judge’s conclusion that the late guilty plea did not justify fixing the parole eligibility date as early as one-third of the head sentence. That is not sufficient reason to justify a conclusion that the overall sentence was manifestly excessive.Orders The orders which should be made are:1.Application for leave to adduce evidence refused.2.Application for leave to appeal against sentence refused.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.