COURT OF APPEAL
THOMAS JA
SHEPHERDSON J
JONES J
No 264 of 1998
THE QUEEN
v.
TIMOTHY JAMES BEATTIE Appellant
BRISBANE
..DATE 07/10/98
JUDGMENT
SHEPHERDSON J: The applicant has sought leave to appeal against sentences imposed on him on 4 August 1998. The circumstances leading to these sentences are as follows:
On 6 May 1997 the applicant appeared before a learned District Court Judge in Brisbane where he pleaded guilty to two charges of housebreaking, two charges of stealing and one charge of false pretences.
These offences were committed between 2 November 1996 and on or about 11 November 1996. His Honour did not record convictions and ordered that the applicant be released on probation, a probation order being made for two years.
According to the transcript His Honour also ordered the applicant to pay within 12 months compensation (in two sums) totalling $997.50. However other documents show the compensation totalled $1,062.50. This is the amount mentioned in the probation order and appears to be incorrect.
The applicant contravened, without reasonable excuse, a requirement of the probation order namely that he must report to and receive visits from an authorised officer as directed by the officer in that he failed to report to the Redcliffe Community Corrections office on 14th day of May 1998 as directed by an authorised officer.
On the complaint of an authorised Commission officer the applicant appeared on 4 August 1998 before the same learned District Court Judge to be dealt with for that breach.
After a hearing on that day His Honour vacated the probation order and on each of the two housebreaking charges he sentenced the applicant to 12 months imprisonment and on each stealing charge and on the false pretence charge he sentenced him to nine months imprisonment, all sentences to be served concurrently.
The applicant claims the sentences are manifestly excessive. Before I turn to the applicant's antecedents I note that the learned sentencing Judge had before him a Court report from a Community Corrections officer which said (inter alia):
"Mr Beattie last reported to the Redcliffe Community Corrections office on February 18, 1998. Correspondence sent on March 30, 1998 directing him to report on April 15, 1998 was ignored. An additional letter sent on May 7, 1998 directing him to report on May 14, 1998 was also ignored. The telephone call was made to his residence on May 19, 1998 when the offender was directed to report that day. Mr Beattie again ignored the direction and failed to report to Redcliffe Community Corrections office.
As Mr Beattie has been uncooperative towards his supervision and very tardy in payments of compensation it is respectfully recommended that he be dealt with under section 126(4) of The Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 namely re-sentence him for the original offence.
It is further respectfully recommended that a separate order be made for the payment of the balance of compensation."
The applicant was born on 16 April 1979. He was 17 years old…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Beattie and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1998] QCA 357
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
In its reasoning, the Court highlighted that while Beattie had breached the probation order, the sentencing judge had not adequately considered the applicant’s age and the nature of his first-time offences. The Court found that the sentencing judge had failed to sufficiently weigh these mitigating factors and thus erred in imposing the sentences. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, set aside the sentences, and imposed alternative sentences of four months imprisonment, suspended after 64 days, for each offence, with a one-year operational period during which Beattie must not commit another imprisonable offence.
The Court of Appeal noted the undertaking of Beattie’s counsel to inform him of the consequences of reoffending during the operational period of the suspended sentences. The final order of the Court was that the sentences imposed on 4 August 1998 be set aside and replaced with the suspended sentences, with convictions recorded for each offence.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case came before the Court of Appeal as an application for leave to appeal against the sentences imposed by the District Court on 4 August 1998. The applicant argued that the sentences were excessive and sought to have them set aside. The Court of Appeal considered the matter and determined to allow the appeal, setting aside the sentences and substituting them with suspended sentences.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the sentences imposed by the District Court were manifestly excessive.
2. Whether the applicant should be admitted to further probation with a compensation order.
3. Whether the applicant has not returned to serious criminal conduct since being placed on probation, to the extent that the object of the probation order has been achieved.
4. Whether the District Court Judge was entitled to consider further offences committed by the applicant since the probation order was made.
Held
1. The Court concluded that the sentences imposed by the District Court were manifestly excessive and set them aside.
2. The Court granted leave to appeal and, in lieu of the original sentences, ordered the applicant be sentenced to four months imprisonment, suspended after serving 64 days, for each offence, with convictions recorded.
3. The Court rejected the submission that the object of the probation order had been achieved, noting the applicant's further offending during the probation period.
4. The Court held that the District Court Judge was entitled to consider further offences committed by the applicant since the probation order was made.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal considered the applicant's appeal against the sentences imposed by the District Court, focusing on the nature and circumstances of the original offences and the applicant's conduct during the probation period. The primary legal issue was whether the District Court erred in imposing the sentences, particularly considering the applicant's youth and first-time offender status. The Court noted that the District Court had before it a recommendation to re-sentence the applicant due to his non-compliance with the probation order, which included failing to report as directed and tardiness in paying compensation. Despite the applicant's counsel arguing that the original offences warranted a non-custodial penalty due to the applicant's age and history, the Court found that the District Court was entitled to consider the applicant's conduct during probation, including further offences committed. The Court cited The Queen v. Gill [1986] 1 Queensland Reports 459 to support the proposition that the sentencing judge could consider all relevant circumstances up to the time of sentencing. The Court held that while the District Court was correct to consider the applicant's non-compliance and further offending, it erred by failing to adequately consider the applicant's status as a youthful first offender. Consequently, the Court set aside the original sentences and substituted suspended sentences with a requirement that the applicant serve 64 days, and mandated that he must not commit another imprisonable offence within one year to avoid activation of the suspended sentences. The Court also noted that it was general practice to advise the applicant of the consequences of re-offending during the operational period.