R v Andrews No. Sccrm-00-25, Sccrm-00-26

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

R  v  ANDREWS
[2002] SASC 233

Court of Criminal Appeal:  Doyle CJ, Prior and Gray JJ

  1. DOYLE CJ:           Mr Andrews was convicted of murder on the verdict of a jury.  He appeals against that conviction.

  2. He was charged with murdering Christine Jenkins on 18 December 1994.  The verdict was returned on 11 April 1996.  It is not necessary to go into the circumstances that led to the Court extending the time for the institution of this appeal, which was not instituted until an application for leave to appeal was filed on 9 February 2000.  The delay since then has been largely attributable to the fact that for a considerable time Mr Andrews did not have legal representation.

    Facts

  3. Mr Andrews and Ms Jenkins had been in a relationship over some time.  The Judge described the relationship to the jury as “unstable”.  There were periods when they lived together, and periods when they lived apart.  There had been some acrimonious exchanges between them.  Apparently they had got back together on the Thursday before Ms Jenkins was killed.

  4. Ms Jenkins lived at Ferryden Park with her two young children.  Mr Andrews lived about four kilometres away at Pennington.

  5. On the evening of Saturday 17 December Ms Jenkins, her two children and Mr Andrews went to a party at a house near her home.  They left the party together between about 2.30am and 3.30am on Sunday 18 December.

  6. On Sunday 18 December about 6.15am Mr Andrews telephoned a mutual friend to say he could not wake Ms Jenkins up.  Shortly after that he went to a neighbour’s house, and said much the same thing to her.  She returned to Ms Jenkins’s house with Mr Andrews.  Ms Jenkins was lying on her back on her bed, semi-naked.  She was dead.

  7. The evidence indicated that she had been strangled manually in the early hours of the morning.  The time of death was estimated at about 4am, but could have been three hours either side of that time.  The evidence also suggested, without being definitive, that she had been penetrated vaginally and anally about the time of her death.  Bruising on the body suggested a struggle associated with the strangling.

  8. The prosecution case against Mr Andrews was circumstantial.

  9. Mr Andrews left the party with Ms Jenkins, and on all the evidence was the last person to see her alive, unless another person killed her.  There was no sign of forced entry to her house.  Mr Andrews was the only person other than Ms Jenkins who had a key to the house.  The state of the body, and the possible vaginal and anal penetration, suggested a sexual motive.  There was nothing to suggest theft or any other motive.  I have already referred to the relationship between them.  There was also evidence that Mr Andrews was jealous and possessive in relation to Ms Jenkins.  There was evidence that Ms Jenkins had recently told two different friends that Mr Andrews engaged in anal intercourse with her, and she did…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Andrews No. Sccrm-00-25, Sccrm-00-26 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] SASC 233
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of R v Andrews No. Sccrm-00-25, Sccrm-00-26, the appellant, Robert James Andrews, was convicted of the murder of Christine Jenkins. The crime took place on 18 December 1994, and the appellant was found guilty on 11 April 1996. The case was appealed, with the primary focus being on the adequacy of the trial judge's directions to the jury regarding the consideration of lies and inconsistencies in the appellant's evidence. Andrews was the last person to see Jenkins alive and was the only other person, aside from Jenkins, who had a key to her home. The prosecution's case was circumstantial, relying on evidence of the appellant's inconsistent accounts and his alleged interest in anal intercourse, which he denied.

The legal issues before the court included whether the trial judge's directions to the jury were adequate in guiding them on the consideration of lies and inconsistencies in the appellant's evidence. The court also had to determine whether these inadequacies in the directions led to a risk of a miscarriage of justice and whether a retrial was warranted. The defence argued that the appellant's conviction should be quashed due to the trial judge's inadequate direction on the consideration of lies and inconsistencies, while the prosecution maintained that the trial judge's directions were sufficient and that there was no risk of a miscarriage of justice.

The court found that while the trial judge's directions to the jury could have been more comprehensive, they provided sufficient guidance for the jury to consider the lies and inconsistencies in the appellant's evidence. The court held that the inadequacies in the directions did not lead to a risk of a miscarriage of justice and that there was no need for a retrial. The court concluded that the appellant's conviction should be upheld, as there was no substantial risk that the inadequacies in the directions had affected the outcome of the trial.

The final orders of the court were to dismiss the appeal against conviction, affirming the appellant's conviction for the murder of Christine Jenkins. The judges unanimously agreed that the appeal should be dismissed, with the majority considering the inadequacies in the trial judge's directions to be insufficient to warrant a retrial, while one judge believed that a retrial was necessary due to the risk of a miscarriage of justice.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

He was charged with murdering Christine Jenkins on 18 December 1994. The verdict was returned on 11 April 1996. It is not necessary to go into the circumstances that led to the Court extending the time for the institution of this appeal, which was not instituted until an application for leave to appeal was filed on 9 February 2000. The delay since then has been largely attributable to the fact that for a considerable time Mr Andrews did not have legal representation.Facts Mr Andrews and Ms Jenkins had been in a relationship over some time. The Judge described the relationship to the jury as “unstable”. There were periods when they lived together, and periods when they lived apart. There had been some acrimonious exchanges between them. Apparently they had got back together on the Thursday before Ms Jenkins was killed. Ms Jenkins lived at Ferryden Park with her two young children. Mr Andrews lived about four kilometres away at Pennington. On the evening of Saturday 17 December Ms Jenkins, her two children and Mr Andrews went to a party at a house near her home. They left the party together between about 2.30am and 3.30am on Sunday 18 December. On Sunday 18 December about 6.15am Mr Andrews telephoned a mutual friend to say he could not wake Ms Jenkins up. Shortly after that he went to a neighbour’s house, and said much the same thing to her. She returned to Ms Jenkins’s house with Mr Andrews. Ms Jenkins was lying on her back on her bed, semi-naked. She was dead. The evidence indicated that she had been strangled manually in the early hours of the morning. The time of death was estimated at about 4am, but could have been three hours either side of that time. The evidence also suggested, without being definitive, that she had been penetrated vaginally and anally about the time of her death. Bruising on the body suggested a struggle associated with the strangling. The prosecution case against Mr Andrews was circumstantial. Mr Andrews left the party with Ms Jenkins, and on all the evidence was the last person to see her alive, unless another person killed her. There was no sign of forced entry to her house. Mr Andrews was the only person other than Ms Jenkins who had a key to the house. The state of the body, and the possible vaginal and anal penetration, suggested a sexual motive. There was nothing to suggest theft or any other motive. I have already referred to the relationship between them. There was also evidence that Mr Andrews was jealous and possessive in relation to Ms Jenkins. There was evidence that Ms Jenkins had recently told two different friends that Mr Andrews engaged in anal intercourse with her, and she did not like this, and that he made greater sexual demands of her than she liked. A magazine questionnaire found by police in Mr Andrews’s home, that he had completed, suggested that he was interested in anal intercourse. Mr Andrews gave an account of his movements on the morning that was not convincing. He gave somewhat different accounts to different people. He told some people that he and Ms Jenkins had argued on the night of her death. The prosecution suggested that he lied in the course of giving inconsistent accounts about his movements, in denying an interest in anal intercourse, in the explanations that he gave for scratch marks and abrasions on his face and body, and in statements he made about the whereabouts of Ms Jenkins’s handbag. These were put to the jury as a basis for inferring guilt. The prosecutor also pointed to various inconsistencies in Mr Andrews’s evidence.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The defence case attempted to explain, answer and negative these points. Other points made was were that there was no evidence of violence in the relationship, and that there were other men in Ms Jenkins’s life who might have killed her. Mr Andrews said that he left her in the early hours of the morning. She was lying on her bed watching television. He walked home, later went back to her home and found her apparently dead, and then contacted the persons referred to earlier. Mr Andrews denied to the police any interest in anal intercourse. He denied that he ever had anal intercourse with Ms Jenkins.Evidence of statements by Ms Jenkins The Judge admitted evidence from Mr Doroschenko that shortly before her death Ms Jenkins told him that Mr Andrews made her submit to anal intercourse, that she did not like that, and that she thought he was “too sexually active”. He admitted evidence from Ms Allen that Ms Jenkins told her shortly before her death that she and Mr Andrews had split up because Ms Jenkins did not like anal sex. If the jury accepted that these statements were made and were truthful, they were capable of establishing that Ms Jenkins did not like anal intercourse, and would be reluctant to submit to it. This would provide a basis for an inference that this was the origin of a struggle between her and Mr Andrews in the course of which she was killed. Of course, that would depend upon the jury inferring that Mr Andrews was likely to try to make her submit to anal intercourse. I should add that the prosecution case was not tied to the establishment of this motive. It was put to the jury that quite apart from this there was adequate evidence from which guilt could be inferred. As to this evidence, the Judge said:“Relevant to that relationship also was the evidence of Doroschenko and Vicki Allen that the deceased spoke to them about her attitude to anal sex. That particular evidence was admitted only to show her attitude and that she was unlikely to consent to anal sex and for no other purpose. You certainly must not infer therefrom that the accused was of bad character or jump to any conclusions that he was the culprit.” The Judge did not warn the jury not to use these statements as evidence that Mr Andrews did like anal intercourse, and had caused Ms Jenkins to submit to it. The evidence was admissible. It was relevant for the prosecution to prove that Ms Jenkins would not readily submit to anal intercourse. This was relevant because of the post mortem findings suggesting anal intercourse, and because of the evidence suggesting Mr Andrews would seek anal intercourse despite his denial of interest in or engagement in anal intercourse. As I have already said, if the jury accepted the prosecution suggestion, and accepted that Mr Andrews might try to make Ms Jenkins submit to anal intercourse, that would provide a likely explanation for a struggle in which she was killed. When the state of mind or attitude of a person is relevant in proceedings, authority establishes that witnesses may give evidence of statements made by the person in question if those statements might establish the person’s state of mind or attitude. If this were not permissible, there would be many situations in which a person’s state of mind or attitude would be relevant, but it would not be possible to establish what the state of mind or attitude was.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I consider that the directions gave the jury sufficient guidance, even though more could usefully have been given. Even if the summing up were defective, I regard this as a case in which it would be appropriate to apply the proviso. I do not consider that there is any risk of a miscarriage of justice from the deficiency in the directions.Conclusion For those reasons, I would dismiss the appeal against conviction. PRIOR J: I agree with the reasons given by the Chief Justice. The appeal should be dismissed.GRAY J: Introduction Robert James Andrews the appellant was charged with the murder of Christine Jenkins. He was convicted on the verdict of a jury on 11 April 1996. Ms Jenkins was murdered at her home at Ferryden Park in the early hours of Sunday 18 December 1994. She was found semi-naked on her bed. She had been strangled. There was bruising to her body. There appeared to have been a struggle. The time of death was likely to have been between 3.15 am and 6.00 am. The Crown case was circumstantial. It was said that the attacker was known to the deceased and the motive sexual. The evidence suggested there had been vaginal and anal penetration. The appellant and the deceased had been in an unstable relationship for some time. The relationship had at times been acrimonious but they had recently reconciled. The appellant was the only person apart from the deceased who had a key to the home. He lived nearby. There were no signs of forced entry. There was evidence that suggested that the appellant and the deceased had engaged in anal intercourse to the dislike of the deceased. A completed magazine questionnaire found at his home suggested that he was interested in anal intercourse. Other evidence suggested that the appellant demanded more from the deceased sexually than was appreciated. However this was denied by the appellant. The appellant and the deceased had been at a party the previous evening. They appeared happy. They returned to her home between about 2.30 am and 3.30 am on the Sunday morning. It was not disputed that the appellant went with the deceased to her home after the party. The appellant did not give evidence. In summary, his case was that he helped put her children to bed and then “hopped up” onto her bed and talked to her for about 15 minutes. He then left her home and walked back to his own home a distance of about four kilometres. He went to the toilet, had a cup of coffee and then walked back to the deceased’s home. He found her dead, attempted to resuscitate her, had a second cup of coffee. He then raised the alarm at some time between 6.00 am and 7.00 am. He rang the police and an ambulance. The Crown case was that the appellant had provided a number of inconsistent accounts as to his movements on the night of the deceased’s death and on other significant matters. I have had the benefit of reading the reasons of Doyle CJ. I agree that the lies direction was inadequate. However I disagree with the consequence that flows from that inadequacy. In my view the inadequacies were of such a nature that they have led to the risk of a miscarriage of justice in this case and that there should be a retrial. As a result it is unnecessary to consider the other grounds of appeal in detail. Generally I agree that they are without substance.The Lies DirectionThe Crown Address

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.