R v Age

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

99.64

COURT OF APPEAL

DAVIES JA THOMAS JA MUIR J

CA NO 437 of 1998
THE QUEEN
v.

CAIN MATTHEW AGE Applicant

BRISBANE
..DATE 15/03/99
150399 T14/RAG23 M/T COA47/99
DAVIES JA: The applicant pleaded guilty in the Supreme
Court on 28 October last that on 31 December 1997 at
Etna Creek Prison he unlawfully wounded Ian James
Naylor. He was sentenced to three years' imprisonment
cumulative upon sentences then being served. He seeks
leave to appeal against that sentence. No grounds of
appeal were furnished but I shall mention shortly the
main basis upon which he seeks, not as I understand it a
reduction of the sentence which was imposed, but a
recommendation for parole.

The offence occurred inside prison. The applicant assaulted the complainant with a disposable razor with the safety guard removed, thereby exposing the blade. There is some dispute as to how the assault came to take place but on neither view was it provoked by the complainant. According to the applicant's counsel on the sentence hearing, the complainant had agreed to supply amphetamines to the applicant but later said he could not. The applicant then said that he would take the television set which the complainant was watching in his cell.

He decided to go to the cell, he said, to threaten the
complainant, but he argued with him and he then attacked
him with a razor. It may be accepted for the purpose of
this appeal that that was a correct version of events.
Notwithstanding that the attack was vicious and
cowardly. It included a substantial slash to the left-
side of the complainant's throat, which wounded him
150399 T14/RAG23 M/T COA47/99
severely causing a laceration about seven and a half
centimetres in length, penetrating the skin and totally
dividing the left external jugular vein.
The attack was cowardly because even without the use of
a weapon the applicant could easily have overpowered the
complainant, being a much larger and stronger man.
There was a further element of seriousness in this
assault in that it was committed within a prison, and
consequently liable to make the task of prison
discipline even more difficult than it now is. The
applicant declined to speak to the police after the
assault and his version of it came out much later.

The applicant has a prior history of violent offending and lack of discipline. He was convicted in 1994 for rioting, in 1995 for unlawful assault and two assaults occasioning bodily harm, again in 1995 for an assault occasioning bodily harm whilst in company and stealing with actual violence whilst in compay, in 1996 for obstructing police and unlawful use of a motor vehicle, and in 1997 for robbery, two counts of wilful destruction of property, one in which bodily harm was caused, one of unlawful use of a motor vehicle, and one of receiving.

For the offences committed in 1997 the applicant
received a sentence of three years' imprisonment, the
longest which he had received before this sentence.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Age and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] QCA 64
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of the Queen versus Cain Matthew Age, the applicant appealed against his sentence imposed in the Supreme Court for unlawfully wounding Ian James Naylor at Etna Creek Prison. The applicant pleaded guilty and was sentenced to three years' imprisonment, cumulative upon the sentences then being served. The applicant sought leave to appeal against this sentence, but no grounds of appeal were provided. Instead, the applicant argued for a recommendation for parole after 18 months, which was not sought in the lower court.

The central legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the sentence imposed by the Supreme Court was appropriate and within the range suggested by both counsels. The Court also considered whether the applicant's plea of guilty and the time and cost it saved were adequately taken into account in the sentence imposed.

The Court of Appeal found that the sentence imposed by the Supreme Court was appropriate and within the range suggested by both counsels. The Court noted that the only factor in the applicant's favour was his plea of guilty, which was adequately taken into account in the sentence imposed. The Court also found that the sentence the applicant sought to substitute was only slightly different from that imposed, and therefore, the application was refused. The judges, Davies JA, Thomas JA, and Muir J, unanimously agreed on this decision.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, Cain Matthew Age, pleaded guilty in the Supreme Court to unlawfully wounding Ian James Naylor at Etna Creek Prison on 31 December 1997. Age assaulted Naylor with a disposable razor, resulting in a severe laceration to Naylor's throat, which penetrated the skin and totally divided the left external jugular vein. The attack was unprovoked by Naylor, and even without the use of a weapon, Age could have overpowered Naylor due to their size and strength disparity. The assault occurred within a prison setting, adding to the severity of the crime as it could make prison discipline more challenging. Age declined to speak to the police after the assault, and his version of events only came out much later during the sentence hearing. Age has a prior history of violent offending and lack of discipline, with multiple convictions from 1994 to 1997 for offences including rioting, assault occasioning bodily harm, robbery, and receiving.

Age pleaded guilty to the charge in the Supreme Court and was sentenced to three years' imprisonment, which was cumulative upon sentences then being served. He sought leave to appeal against his sentence, with the main basis for the appeal being a recommendation for parole after 18 months. This recommendation was not sought in the lower court. The Court of Appeal heard the application on 15 March 1999 and delivered its judgment the same day.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the sentence imposed by the Supreme Court was appropriate and within the range of an appropriate sentence.
2. Whether there should be a recommendation for parole after 18 months, as sought by Age.

Held
1. The Court of Appeal held that the sentence imposed by the Supreme Court was appropriate and within the range of an appropriate sentence.
2. The Court of Appeal held that there should not be a recommendation for parole after 18 months, as sought by the applicant.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal examined the appropriateness of the sentence imposed by the Supreme Court and whether there should be a recommendation for parole after 18 months. The Court noted that the applicant did not seek a reduction in his sentence but rather a recommendation for parole. The Court held that the sentence imposed by the Supreme Court was appropriate and within the range suggested by both parties. The Court also found that the applicant's concerns regarding the prison system and his eligibility for early parole were not matters for the Court of Appeal to consider. The Court emphasised that the only thing that could have been said in the applicant's favour was his plea of guilty and the time and cost which that saved, which was adequately taken into account in the sentence imposed. The Court concluded that the sentence imposed by the Supreme Court was appropriate and refused the application for leave to appeal against the sentence. The Court of Appeal held that there should not be a recommendation for parole after 18 months, as sought by the applicant. The Court found that the applicant's complaint was against the prison system rather than the sentence imposed below. The Court also noted that even if such a recommendation were made, it would not substantially affect the applicant's eligibility for parole. The Court held that the applicant's concerns regarding parole were not matters for the Court of Appeal to consider.