R v Abraham No. Sccrm-97-19, Sccrm-97-128 Judgment No. S6654

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

R  v ABRAHAM

Court of Criminal Appeal
Coram: Matheson, Prior & Debelle JJ

Matheson J

The appellant was tried by a judge without a jury in the District Court on two counts of rape, particulars being that on 18 June 1995 at Northfield she had sexual intercourse with Nula Catherine Hayden, ("the complainant"), without her consent by inserting a finger into her vagina.  After a lengthy  hearing commencing on 3 December 1996 she was convicted of both counts on 24 December 1996.   (It will be apparent later that dates assume some importance). Michelle Lee Charlton and Amy Rebecca Dean-Johns were charged on the same information with being present and aiding and abetting the appellant to commit the said offences.  There were problems about the identification of Charlton and the learned trial judge acquitted her.   The case had been  originally heard by Olsson J for several days during which the complainant was cross-examined at length.  For reasons which are now irrelevant, Olsson J granted a mistrial on 6 June 1996, and admitted Dean-Johns to bail.  She absconded.  She was subsequently arrested on a bench warrant and pleaded guilty to indecent assault.  She was given a suspended sentence.  The complainant said there was a fourth woman involved, but she was unable to identify her.  There is a suggestion that it was a prisoner called Tina Chalker, but she was never charged.

The offences were alleged to have occurred in A Wing of Unit 2 of the Women’s Prison at Northfield.   The complainant was transferred there on 12 June 1995.  She had earlier been extradited from New South Wales on a charge of assault occasioning actual bodily harm.  All three of the women originally charged were inmates of the same unit.

Prior to being transferred to Unit 2, the complainant had been hospitalised for a drug overdose and was restricted to non-contact visits.  Following her transfer she alleged that the appellant and others asked her to bring drugs into the prison by involving her boyfriend Robinson or another man.  The appellant stated that the complainant had asked her to receive a visit from Robinson for the purpose of collecting drugs.   The complainant could not obtain the drugs herself because of the non-contact restriction on her visits.  She had a non-contact visit with Robinson on Saturday 17 June.  A visit planned for later that day between him and the appellant did not eventuate.

The complainant slept in her own cell that night.  She said that she went to the toilet about 3am on Sunday 18 June.  She said that she was dragged from the toilet onto the floor.  A blanket was put over her head and she was held down while her vagina was twice digitally penetrated by the appellant in the course of a search for drugs.  Immediately after the assault she returned to her cell.   She did not seek assistance or treatment.  Later that day she spent some time with another inmate Joanne Rule.  The complainant agreed that she made no complaint…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Abraham No. Sccrm-97-19, Sccrm-97-128 Judgment No. S6654 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] SASC 6654
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal concerns the conviction of Wendy Abraham for two counts of rape in a prison setting. The appellant was tried and convicted in the District Court and now appeals against both her conviction and sentence. The appeal against the conviction is based on four grounds, one of which was added later. The appellant also appeals against the penalty imposed on her. The appeal against conviction hinges on two issues: firstly, whether the learned trial judge erred in his finding that there was a case to answer and secondly, whether the verdicts were unsafe and unsatisfactory. The first issue turns on whether the appellant's conduct amounted to rape as defined in the Criminal Law Consolidation Act. The second issue is whether the trial judge erred in his direction as to the burden of proof, particularly in relation to the use he made of the Crown submission that the complainant was not shown to have had a motive to lie or to fabricate the account she gave. The appellant also sought leave to adduce fresh evidence from Joanne Elsa Rule, a fellow inmate of the complainant, but this application was refused. The court dismissed the appeal against conviction and sentence. In relation to the application to call fresh evidence, the court found that the evidence could have been obtained with reasonable diligence before the second trial. In relation to the submission that the trial judge gave improper weight to the prosecution's submission that the complainant was not shown to have had a motive to lie or to fabricate the account she gave, the court found that the trial judge was conscious of the limits of an enquiry on the issue of a motive to lie and that this issue was not at the forefront of his direction. It was certainly not the central theme of his reasoning. The court also found that the appellant's conduct did constitute rape as defined in the Criminal Law Consolidation Act. Finally, the court found that it was open to the learned trial judge to be satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the appellant was guilty of both counts.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established