Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: R v Abdaly; R v Hosseinishoja (No 1) [2022] NSWSC 1482 Hearing dates: 28 October 2022 Date of orders: 28 October 2022 Decision date: 28 October 2022 Jurisdiction: Common Law - Criminal Before: Hamill J Decision: Notice of motion dismissed. Refuse the application to set aside the subpoena directed to the Department of Home Affairs.
Catchwords: CRIMINAL LAW – subpoena issued by Prosecutor – attempt to obtain extraction of telephone records of accused – application to set aside subpoena – whether accused has standing – he obviously does – legitimate forensic purpose – “fishing” – caution in application of language employed in earlier cases – where issue between parties as to associations between accused and criminal group – not speculative that telephone may contain relevant evidence – legitimate forensic purpose established
Legislation Cited: SupremeCourtAct1970 (NSW), Sch 3
Supreme Court Rules 1970 (NSW), Pt 75, r 3(g)
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), r 33.1(a), Pt 33
Cases Cited: Attorney-General(NSW)vChidgey (2008) 182 A Crim R 536; [2008] NSWCCA 65
CommissionerofPolice(NSW)vFantakis [2022] NSWCCA 94
MannvCommissionerofPolice [2020] NSWSC 369
PrincipalRegistraroftheSupremeCourtvTastan (1994) 75 A Crim R 498
RvJenkin(No2) [2018] NSWSC 697
SecretaryoftheDepartmentofPlanning,IndustryandEnvironmentvBlacktownCityCouncil [2021] NSWCA 145
WatersvSecretaryoftheAttorney-General’sDepartment(Cth) [2021] NSWCCA 193
Category: Procedural rulings Parties: Rex (Plaintiff)
Sayed Anoush Abdaly (Defendant)
Seyed Amirmohammad Hosseinishoja (Defendant)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
D Patch (Rex)
M Cunneen SC (Abdaly)
G Brady SC with P Lange and M Ayache (Hosseinishoja)
Solicitor for Public Prosecutions (NSW) (Rex)
Tohi Lawyers (Abdaly)
OneGroup Legal (Hosseinishoja)
File Number(s): 2020/306132; 2020/306616 Publication restriction: Unique personal identifiers have been anonymised.
Except for publication on legal websites, there is an interim non-publication order over the names of the two accused and Abuzar Sultani.
Judgment
-
By notice of motion filed 12 October 2022, the accused Seyed Hosseinishoja sought an order that a subpoena issued at the request of the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP or the Director) and directed to the Department of Home Affairs be set aside. The issue was debated on Friday, 28 October 2022 at the end of the fourth day of a chaotic pre-trial hearing in a trial of three men charged with murder. [1] On the second day of the pre-trial hearing, one of those men (Mr Abuzar Sultani) pleaded guilty to murder and his case was adjourned until 21 November 2022 for mention or sentencing hearing, depending on the state of the trial proceedings. At the conclusion of the oral arguments, I dismissed the notice of motion and refused to set aside the subpoena. The matter was adjourned until today (Monday, 31 October 2022) for argument over whether access will be granted to the material produced.
1. The circumstances of the chaos will be described in a subsequent judgment…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Abdaly; R v Hosseinishoja (No 1) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] NSWSC 1482
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered whether the subpoena was issued for a legitimate forensic purpose, particularly in light of the defendants' argument that it amounted to fishing. The court noted that the language used in previous cases cautioned against the use of such terms without careful consideration. The court found that the issue between the parties involved the defendants' associations with a criminal group, and it was not speculative that their telephone records might contain relevant evidence. Consequently, the court determined that the subpoena served a legitimate forensic purpose.
As a result of the court's reasoning, the defendants' application to set aside the subpoena was dismissed. The court held that the subpoena was valid and that the defendants had standing to challenge it. The court further found that the subpoena did not amount to fishing but instead served a legitimate forensic purpose. The defendants were therefore required to comply with the subpoena to provide their telephone records.
No further orders were made by the court beyond dismissing the application to set aside the subpoena.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the court following an application by the accused to set aside the subpoena issued by the Prosecutor. The application was heard by the court, which needed to determine the validity of the subpoena. The accused argued that the subpoena was not supported by a legitimate forensic purpose and lacked standing. The court examined the circumstances surrounding the subpoena and the nature of the evidence sought. The accused's application to set aside the subpoena was the primary procedural step in the case, and no prior decisions or appeals were directly relevant to the issue of the subpoena's validity in this specific context.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the accused have standing to challenge the subpoena issued by the Prosecutor?
2. Was the subpoena issued for a legitimate forensic purpose, or was it merely a "fishing" expedition?
3. Given the contested nature of the accused's associations with a criminal group, was it speculative or justified to assert that the telephone records may contain relevant evidence?
Held
1. The court concluded that the accused does have standing to challenge the subpoena issued by the Prosecutor.
2. The court held that the subpoena was issued for a legitimate forensic purpose, not merely a "fishing" expedition.
3. The court determined that it was justified, given the contested nature of the accused's associations with a criminal group, to assert that the telephone records may contain relevant evidence.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the first issue of whether the accused has standing to challenge the subpoena issued by the Prosecutor. The court acknowledged that the accused has a legitimate interest in the information sought by the subpoena, and therefore, has standing to challenge it. This was a straightforward conclusion, given the personal nature of the information sought and the impact a subpoena can have on an individual's privacy and rights.
The second issue addressed whether the subpoena was issued for a legitimate forensic purpose or merely for a "fishing" expedition. The court examined the language used in previous cases and applied a cautious approach in interpreting terms such as "fishing expedition". The court found that the Prosecutor's intention was to obtain evidence relevant to the case and not to conduct a general search for information. This was supported by the specific details provided in the subpoena and the Prosecutor's affidavit outlining the connection between the requested telephone records and the case at hand.
The third issue concerned the contested nature of the accused's associations with a criminal group. The court recognised that the association between the accused and the criminal group was a matter of contention between the parties. Nevertheless, the court found it justified to assert that the telephone records may contain relevant evidence, as the connection between the accused and the group was sufficiently strong to warrant a legitimate forensic investigation. The court emphasised the importance of balancing the rights of the accused with the need for effective law enforcement, and concluded that the subpoena served a legitimate forensic purpose in this case.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that where a subpoena is issued for a specific and legitimate forensic purpose, and the accused has a legitimate interest in the information sought, the accused has standing to challenge the subpoena. Additionally, when there is a contested association between the accused and a criminal group, it is not speculative to assert that the telephone records may contain relevant evidence if the connection is sufficiently strong.