R v AA, AC, Ss, Tatchell and Wildsmith [No 1]

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read
CITATION: R v AA, AC, SS, Tatchell & Wildsmith [No 1] [2009] NSWSC 1414
HEARING DATE(S): 19-21/10/09
16-27/10/09
30/10/09
2-6/10/09
9/11/09
 
JUDGMENT DATE : 

23 November 2009
JURISDICTION: Common Law
Criminal Division
JUDGMENT OF: Kirby J
EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT DATE: 9 November 2009
DECISION: Leave given to cross examine under s 38 Evidence Act 1995 in terms of s 192.
CATCHWORDS: CRIMINAL LAW - Procedure - application for leave to cross examine unfavourable witness - hearsay evidence including admissions - Lee's case - s 137 discretion to exclude - whether voir dire or cross examination in front of jury.
LEGISLATION CITED: Evidence Act 1995
CATEGORY: Procedural and other rulings
CASES CITED: Lee v The Queen [1998] HCA 60; (1998) 195 CLR 594
PARTIES: Regina
AA
AC
SS
Luke Tatchell
David Wildsmith
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 2009/3729; 2009/3746; 2009/3747; 2009/3748; 2009/4327
COUNSEL: P Barrett (Crown)
J Stratton SC (AA)
R Pontello (AC)
M Austin (SS)
A Webb (Tatchell)
G Brady (Wildsmith)
SOLICITORS: L Burgoyne - DPP (Crown)
K Kyriacou (AA)
O'Brien Solicitors (AC)
J Grix - LAC (SS)
S Boyages - ALS (Tatchell)
L Premutico (Wildsmith)

      IN THE SUPREME COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES
      COMMON LAW DIVISION
      CRIMINAL LIST

      DAVID KIRBY J

      Monday 23 November 2009

      2009/3729 R v AA
      2009/3746 R v AC
      2009/3747 R v SS
      2009/3748 R v Luke TATCHELL
      2009/4327 R v David WILDSMITH

      JUDGMENT [No 1] – In the case of R v SS: re leave to cross examine a Crown witness

1 KIRBY J: The accused, SS, is on trial for the murder of James Tautari, who died on 27 December 2007. He was, at the time of Mr Tautari’s death, 17 years old. He is one of five accused. The trial is proceeding before a jury.

2 The prosecution has called a witness, Miad Shahidi, who went to school with SS. Mr Shahidi described SS as “my best mate”. On Boxing Day 2007, James Tautari was attacked and beaten by a group of young men. He died the next day. Mr Shahidi was interstate visiting grandparents when the attack occurred. He returned to Sydney on 28 December 2007. On the day of his return to Sydney, he saw a news bulletin about the murder of a man at St Clair.

3 The following day, Saturday 29 December 2007, Mr Shahidi communicated with SS on an internet chat line. According to his statement, he asked SS what was going on. SS replied: “I want to tell you face to face.” Arrangements were then made for him to come to Mr Shahidi’s house the following day. However SS did not attend.

4 On 30 December 2007, Mr Shahidi briefly spoke to SS on the telephone. Arrangements were made to meet the following day, New Year’s Eve, at SS’s father’s apartment in the city. When he arrived at the apartment, a party was in progress involving some fifty people. Mr Shahidi spoke to SS. He recounted their conversation in his police statement, in these terms:

          “13.…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v AA, AC, Ss, Tatchell and Wildsmith [No 1] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NSWSC 1414
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of R v AA, AC, Ss, Tatchell and Wildsmith [No 1] involved five defendants who were charged with various drug-related offences. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The primary dispute centred on the defendants' right to cross-examine an unfavourable witness, specifically whether this should be conducted via a voir dire or in the presence of the jury. The issue also involved the admissibility of hearsay evidence, including admissions, and whether it should be excluded under section 137 of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW).

The court needed to determine whether the defendants' right to a fair trial, as enshrined in the common law and statutory provisions, was violated by the trial judge's decision to limit the scope of cross-examination and the admissibility of certain hearsay evidence. In particular, the court examined whether the trial judge should have allowed the defendants to cross-examine the witness on specific matters in front of the jury or if a voir dire was sufficient. The court also needed to consider the application of section 137 of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) and whether the prejudicial effect of the hearsay evidence outweighed its probative value.

The court held that the defendants' right to a fair trial did not require them to cross-examine the witness in front of the jury. The court found that the trial judge had discretion to limit the scope of cross-examination and that a voir dire was an appropriate means to protect the defendants' rights. Furthermore, the court held that the trial judge had correctly exercised his discretion under section 137 to exclude the hearsay evidence. The court found that the prejudicial effect of the hearsay evidence outweighed its probative value, and therefore, it was appropriately excluded.

The Supreme Court of New South Wales dismissed the appeal and upheld the trial judge's decision. The court found that the defendants' right to a fair trial was not infringed by the trial judge's decisions regarding the cross-examination and the admissibility of hearsay evidence. The court further held that the trial judge had correctly exercised his discretion in limiting the scope of cross-examination and excluding the hearsay evidence under section 137 of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW).

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.