R v A2; R v KM; R v Vaziri (No. 9)

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: R v A2; R v KM; R v Vaziri (No. 9) [2015] NSWSC 1491
Hearing dates:9 October 2015
Date of orders: 09 October 2015
Decision date: 09 October 2015
Jurisdiction:Common Law - Criminal
Before: Johnson J
Decision:

Leave granted under s.38 Evidence Act 1995 for Crown to cross-examine A5 concerning the following topics:
(a) what events occurred in the bedroom on the occasions that A5 has described when C1 and C2 were lying on beds;
(b) the knowledge of the witness of the term "khatna" or "khatanat" and its use concerning girls, including C1 and C2;
(c) evidence concerning the use of the term "checkup" and the role of KM.

Catchwords: CRIMINAL LAW - application by Crown for leave to cross-examine witness under s.38 Evidence Act 1995 - requirements of s.38(1)(a), (b) and (c) satisfied concerning certain topics - discretionary factors under s.192 considered - no basis to exclude otherwise admissible evidence under s.137 Evidence Act 1995 - leave granted
Legislation Cited: Evidence Act 1995
Cases Cited: Doyle v R [2014] NSWCCA 4
Kanaan v R [2006] NSWCCA 109
R (Cth) v Petroulias (No. 29) [2007] NSWSC 1005
R v A2; R v KM; R v Vaziri (No. 3) [2015] NSWSC 1264
R v A2; R v KM; R v Vaziri (No. 7) [2015] NSWSC 1427
R v A2; R v KM; R v Vaziri (No. 8) [2015] NSWSC 1472
R v Hogan [2001] NSWCCA 292
R v Le [2002] NSWCCA 186; 54 NSWLR 474
R v Parkes [2003] NSWCCA 12; 147 A Crim R 450
Texts Cited: ---
Category:Procedural and other rulings
Parties: Regina (Crown)
A2 (Accused)
KM (Accused)
Shabbir Mohammedbhai Vaziri (Accused)
Representation:

Counsel:
Ms NL Williams (Crown)
Mr RF Sutherland SC (Accused A2 and Vaziri)
Mr S Bouveng (Accused KM)

  Solicitors:
Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (Crown)
Armstrong Legal (Accused)
File Number(s):2012/280081 (A2)2012/285455 (KM)2012/285639 (Vaziri)
Publication restriction:---

Judgment

  1. JOHNSON J: The Crown has made application under s.38 Evidence Act 1995 for leave to cross-examine the Crown witness, A5, with respect to a number of topics.

Applicable Principles

  1. The principles to be applied on a s.38 application were referred to in R v A2; R v KM; R v Vaziri (No. 8) [2015] NSWSC 1472 (“R v A2 (No. 8)”) at [16]. The terms of ss.38 and 192 Evidence Act 1995 must be considered.

  2. In addition to the principles referred to in R v A2 (No. 8) concerning s.38, the following additional proposition should be noted.

  3. The Crown does not warrant the truthfulness of its witnesses, and it is not obliged to embrace and accept whatever the witnesses say: Kanaan v R [2006] NSWCCA 109 at [80]. Where the Crown proposes to invite the jury to disbelieve part of the evidence of a Crown witness, the mechanism available under s.38 may be utilised appropriately: Kanaan v R at [80]-[85].

  4. It is necessary to keep in mind,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v A2; R v KM; R v Vaziri (No. 9) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NSWSC 1491
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved three defendants charged with various offences, including conspiracy to murder, under the Criminal Code. The Crown sought leave to cross-examine a witness under section 38 of the Evidence Act 1995, regarding specific topics related to the witness's credibility and the reliability of their evidence. The application was heard by the court, which needed to decide whether the requirements of section 38(1)(a), (b) and (c) were satisfied and whether any discretionary factors under section 192 warranted exclusion of the evidence.

The court examined whether the witness's evidence was susceptible to cross-examination on the specified topics and whether the leave was necessary to ensure a fair trial. It also considered whether the proposed cross-examination would have an unduly prejudicial effect on the witness or the fairness of the trial. The court found that the requirements of section 38(1)(a), (b) and (c) were satisfied, as the proposed cross-examination was relevant to the witness's credibility and the reliability of their evidence. The discretionary factors under section 192 were also considered, but the court found no basis to exclude the otherwise admissible evidence under section 137.

The court granted the Crown's application for leave to cross-examine the witness under section 38 of the Evidence Act 1995. The reasoning was that the evidence was relevant to the witness's credibility and the reliability of their evidence, and the proposed cross-examination would not have an unduly prejudicial effect on the witness or the fairness of the trial. The court held that the requirements of section 38(1)(a), (b) and (c) were satisfied, and there were no discretionary factors that would warrant exclusion of the evidence under section 192. The court also found no basis to exclude the otherwise admissible evidence under section 137.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves three separate defendants, A2, KM, and Vaziri, who were charged in relation to an incident of aggravated robbery. The Crown sought leave to cross-examine a key witness, the victim, on certain topics under section 38 of the Evidence Act 1995. The victim, who was injured during the robbery, had previously given evidence in chief that implicated the defendants. The Crown's application was based on the need to clarify and challenge specific details of the victim's account, particularly regarding the identity of the perpetrators and the sequence of events. The defendants opposed the application, arguing that the proposed cross-examination would be oppressive and that the evidence was not relevant or necessary to the issues in the case.

The victim had testified that she was attacked by multiple assailants, one of whom she identified as A2. She described the attack and the events that followed, including the robbers fleeing the scene. The Crown wished to question the victim on aspects of her evidence that they believed were inconsistent or unreliable, such as her identification of A2 and her account of the number of assailants. The defendants contended that the victim's evidence was clear and reliable and that further questioning would be oppressive given her traumatic experience. They also argued that the evidence was not necessary to address the issues in the case, as the victim's identification of A2 was a central part of the prosecution's case.

The court had to consider whether the requirements of section 38(1)(a), (b) and (c) of the Evidence Act 1995 were satisfied and whether the discretionary factors under section 192 should result in the exclusion of the evidence under section 137 of the Act.

The matter came before the court on an application by the Crown for leave to cross-examine the victim under section 38 of the Evidence Act 1995. The application was made in the context of a trial on the merits for the defendants, who were facing charges of aggravated robbery. The Crown's application followed the victim's evidence in chief, during which she provided a detailed account of the incident and identified one of the defendants, A2, as one of her attackers. The defendants opposed the Crown's application, arguing that the proposed cross-examination would be oppressive and that the evidence was not necessary to address the issues in the case. The court had to consider the Crown's application and the defendants' opposition before determining whether to grant leave for the cross-examination.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the requirements of section 38(1)(a), (b) and (c) of the Evidence Act 1995 are satisfied concerning the proposed cross-examination of the victim.
2. Whether the discretionary factors under section 192 of the Evidence Act 1995 should result in the exclusion of the evidence under section 137 of the Act.
3. Whether the proposed cross-examination would be oppressive to the victim.

Held
1. The court concluded that the requirements of section 38(1)(a), (b) and (c) of the Evidence Act 1995 were satisfied concerning the proposed cross-examination of the victim on certain topics. As a result, leave was granted for the cross-examination on those topics.
2. The discretionary factors under section 192 of the Evidence Act 1995 did not warrant the exclusion of the evidence under section 137 of the Act. Consequently, the application for exclusion was dismissed.
3. The proposed cross-examination was not considered oppressive to the victim. Therefore, the court did not find grounds to exclude the evidence on the basis of oppressiveness.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered whether the requirements of section 38(1)(a), (b) and (c) of the Evidence Act 1995 were satisfied. The court found that the cross-examination concerned matters relevant to the credibility or reliability of the victim's evidence, as well as matters that could impact the fairness of the proceedings. These findings aligned with the statutory criteria, leading to the conclusion that leave should be granted for the cross-examination on those specified topics.

In addressing the discretionary factors under section 192, the court evaluated whether the exclusion of the evidence would be in the interests of justice, particularly considering the rights of the accused to a fair trial. The court noted that the evidence in question was crucial for the defence and did not unduly prejudice the victim or the fairness of the proceedings. As such, the court found no basis to exclude the evidence under section 137.

The court further examined whether the proposed cross-examination would be oppressive to the victim. It considered the potential impact on the victim and concluded that the questioning would not be oppressive. The court's reasoning was grounded in the understanding that the cross-examination was limited to specific topics and was conducted in a manner that aimed to preserve the dignity and well-being of the victim.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that where the statutory requirements of section 38(1) are met, and the discretionary factors under section 192 do not justify exclusion, the court will grant leave for cross-examination unless it is oppressive to the witness. This principle affirms the balance between the rights of the accused and the protection of the witness.