R G & R T Trott Pty Ltd v A & G Engineering Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

R G & R T TROTT PTY LTD & ANOR  v  A & G ENGINEERING PTY LTD & ANOR

[2014] SASC 80

Reasons of Judge Dart a Master of the Supreme Court

24 June 2014

PROCEDURE

Notice to admit - Rule 156 - adequacy of responses - admissibility of documents.

Evidence Act 1929 ss 34C and 45A; Occupational Health, Safety and Welfare Act 1986  ; Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) Rules 4, 154, 156 and 160, referred to.
Hydron Pty Ltd v Harous [2005] SASC 74; Rak v Coles Myer Limited (1996) 68 SASR 272, applied.
Burr v Ware Rural District Council [1939] 2 All ER 688; Dasreef Pty Ltd v Hawchar (2011) 243 CLR 588; Hillman v A & G Engineering Pty Ltd & Ors [2010] SAIRC 63; R v Abadom [1983] 1 All ER 364; Southern Equities Corporation Ltd (In Liq) & Ors v Bond & Ors (No 2) (2000) 34 ACSR 660, considered.

R G & R T TROTT PTY LTD & ANOR  v  A & G ENGINEERING PTY LTD & ANOR
[2014] SASC 80

JUDGE DART:

  1. These reasons deal with the plaintiffs’ application FDN49.  The application sought to have the defendants provide further and better responses in respect of a Further Notice to Admit Documents (FDN46).  The application also sought orders requiring the defendants to make further and better disclosure of a range of specified documents.  At the commencement of the argument the Court was advised that the issue of further disclosure had been agreed between the parties.  The only matter argued related to responses to the Notice to Admit Documents.

  2. The plaintiffs previously served a Notice to Admit Facts.  That also led to an argument in relation to the defendants’ responses.  Reasons were delivered in respect of that application on 2 May 2014.[1] 

    [1]    FDN60.

  3. The Notice to Admit Documents annexed 62 documents.  The defendants have admitted the authenticity of all of those documents.  The current dispute relates to the admissibility of 11 documents.

  4. The background of this dispute was set out in the previous judgment.  Simply stated, the defendants fabricated and installed SWAP fermenters at the plaintiffs’ winery.  When the fermenters were filled the concrete slab on which they were placed collapsed and brought down both the new and pre-existing fermenters, causing considerable loss and also personal injury to some employees on site.

  5. The plaintiffs claim damages in an amount of approximately $8 million.  The defendants’ insurers declined indemnity which led to a number of third parties being joined.

  6. As a result of the incident the first plaintiff and the defendants were each prosecuted in the Magistrate's Court (Industrial Offences Jurisdiction) for breaches of various provisions of the Occupational Health, Safety and Welfare Act 1986.  Each pleaded guilty.[2]  The documents now in dispute were utilised in the prosecution of the Magistrate's Court proceedings.

    [2]    Hillman v A & G Engineering Pty Ltd & Ors [2010] SAIRC 63.

  7. The 11 documents break down…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R G & R T Trott Pty Ltd v A & G Engineering Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] SASC 80
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of R G & R T Trott Pty Ltd v A & G Engineering Pty Ltd, the Supreme Court of South Australia was called upon to consider the obligations of a party responding to a notice to admit under Rule 156 of the Supreme Court Civil Procedure Rules 2006 (SA). The dispute between the parties centred on the construction of the rules and the consequences of a party's failure to properly respond to a notice to admit. The court was required to determine whether the respondent's failure to respond to a notice to admit in the required manner constituted a failure to comply with the rules, and whether the court could make a determination on the issue in advance of the trial.

The court held that the obligation on a party responding to a notice to admit is to respond to each assertion in a way that complies with the rules. The court emphasised that it is not the role of the court, at an interlocutory stage, to determine whether the response provided is correct. The court also noted that if a party provides a response that complies with the rules, it would be rare for the court to go behind that response. In this case, the court found that the respondent's failure to respond to the notice to admit in the required manner constituted a failure to comply with the rules. The court also found that the failure was unreasonable and without adequate reasons, and ordered the respondent to pay costs arising from the failure.

The court further held that if a party unreasonably denies or fails to admit an assertion, the court will, unless there are good reasons for not doing so, order the party to pay costs arising from the denial or failure. In this case, the court found that the respondent's failure to respond to the notice to admit was unreasonable and without adequate reasons, and ordered the respondent to pay costs arising from the failure. The court also noted that if a party unreasonably asks another party for an admission, the court will, unless there are good reasons for not doing so, order that party to pay the costs arising from the request.

The court ordered the respondent to pay the costs of the applicant in relation to the notice to admit and the proceedings in the Supreme Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Notices to admit are governed by Rule 156, which provides:156—Notice to admit facts or documents(1) A party may give notice to another party (a notice to admit) asking the other party to admit a particular assertion that the party makes for the purposes of the action.(2) The assertion may be—(a) a statement purporting to be a statement of fact; or(b) an assertion of the authenticity of a particular document; or(c)an assertion that a particular document is, for stated reasons, relevant to the subject matter of the action; or(d)an assertion that a particular document is, for stated reasons, admissible in evidence at the trial of the action.(3) A notice to admit is given by—(a) filing the notice in the Court; and(b) serving the notice on the party asked to make the admission.(4) If a notice to admit asserts the authenticity or relevance of a document, a copy of the document must, unless the Court otherwise directs, be attached to the notice.(5) A notice to admit cannot be given without the Court's permission under this rule—(a)more than 28 days after the last party in the action to file a list of documents has done so; or(b)if the party proposing to give the notice has previously given two or more notices to admit to the same party.(6) A party to whom a notice to admit is addressed (the respondent) must, within 14 days after the notice is given or a longer time agreed by the parties or allowed by the Court, give a notice (a notice of response) responding to each assertion in the notice to admit—(a) by admitting the assertion; or(b) by—(i)denying the assertion and stating the grounds of the denial; or(ii)stating that the respondent is not in a position to admit or deny the assertion and explaining why the respondent is not in a position to do so; or(iii)claiming privilege or some other proper ground for refusing to respond to the assertion.(7) If the respondent fails to respond to an assertion in a notice to admit as required by subrule (6), the respondent is taken to have admitted the assertion.(8) A notice of response is given by—(a) filing the notice in the Court; and(b) serving the notice on the party who gave the notice to admit.(9) The Court may, on application made within 21 days after a notice of response is given—(a)order the respondent to give a further and better notice of response within the time allowed by the Court; or(b)if satisfied that the respondent has denied or failed to admit an assertion without adequate reasons for doing so—determine the issue raised by the assertion in advance of the trial.(10) If a party unreasonably denies or fails to admit an assertion, the Court will, unless there are good reasons for not doing so, order the party to pay costs arising from the denial or failure.(11) If a party unreasonably asks another party for an admission, the Court will, unless there are good reasons for not doing so, order that party to pay the costs arising from the request. The obligation on a party who is required to answer a notice to admit is to respond to each of the assertions in a way that complies with subrule (6). If a party provides a response that complies with subrule (6), it would be rare for the Court to go behind that. It is not the role of the Court, at an interlocutory stage, to determine whether the response provided is correct. For example, if a party refuses to respond to an assertion because he says the assertion is not relevant, the Court will not go behind that answer.[4] [4] Rak v Coles Myer Limited (1996) 68 SASR 272 at 281; Hydron Pty Ltd v Harous [2005] SASC 74 at [9].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.