R (Cth) v Pirrello, Pirrello & D'Agostino

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read


Supreme Court

New South Wales

Case Name: 

R (Cth) v Pirrello, Pirrello & D’Agostino

Medium Neutral Citation: 

[2019] NSWSC 1835

Hearing Date(s): 

27 November 2019

Date of Orders:

27 November 2019

Decision Date: 

27 November 2019

Jurisdiction: 

Common Law

Before: 

Wilson J

Decision: 

See [32].

Catchwords: 

CRIMINAL LAW – trial proceedings – conspiracy to import commercial quantity of a border controlled drug – question of the admissibility of evidence surrounding arrest of accused – exhibits – evidence to establish association between accused and co-conspirator – consciousness of guilt – question of potential prejudicial evidence

Legislation Cited: 

Drug Misuse and Trafficking Act 1985 (NSW)

Cases Cited: 

Meakin v R [2018] NSWCCA 288
The Queen v Baden-Clay (2016) 258 CLR 308; [2016] HCA 35

Category: 

Principal judgment

Parties: 

Regina (Crown)
Joseph D’Agostino (First Accused)
Michael Pirrello (Second Accused)
Francesco Pirrello (Third Accused)

Representation: 

Counsel:

Proceedings 2017/010927
P McGuire SC/Ms B Anniwell (Crown)
J Stratton SC/Ms M Curry (First Accused)

Proceedings 2016/388954
P McGuire SC/Ms B Anniwell (Crown)
D McCallum (Second Accused)

Proceedings 2016/388994
P McGuire SC/Ms B Anniwell (Crown)
G Brady SC (Third Accused)

Solicitors:

Proceedings 2017/010927
Solicitor for Public Prosecutions (Cth) (Crown)
Mitchell and Co Lawyers (First Accused)

Proceedings 2016/388954
Solicitor for Public Prosecutions (Cth) (Crown)
Shoalhaven Lawyers (Second Accused)

Proceedings 2016/388994
Solicitor for Public Prosecutions (Cth) (Crown)
Shoalhaven Lawyers (Third Accused)

File Number(s): 

2017/010927; 2016/388954; 2016/388994

Publication Restriction: 

Judgement previously restricted pending finalisation of all co-accused trials and related appeals. Anonymised and/or redacted to excise any matters the subject of a non-publication order pursuant to s 7 of the Courts Suppression and Non-Publication Orders Act 2010 (NSW).

EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT

  1. HER HONOUR: An issue has arisen as to the admissibility of evidence of the circumstances surrounding the arrest of the accused Joseph D'Agostino on 8 September 2016.

  2. Exhibit VD-F is before the Court and it provides the relevant information. The arresting officers were Detective Senior Constables Zadravec and Grime and the statement of each is before the Court. There is, further, an extract from a surveillance running sheet giving details of surveillance of a co-accused, John Tobin, on 6 September 2016. Finally, there is evidence of the issue of a warrant of apprehension from the District Court, that warrant having been issued on 14 October 2015 authorising the accused's arrest in relation to a number of State drug and drug-related offences, the most serious of which is a count of supplying a prohibited drug in not less than the commercial quantity, contrary to s 25(2) of the Drug Misuse and Trafficking Act1985 (NSW).

  3. The Crown seeks to adduce the evidence of Mr D'Agostino's arrest on two bases.

  4. The first of those bases is that the evidence is capable of establishing an association and, indeed, a close association between the accused and John Tobin. Mr Tobin was, although the jury is unlikely to know this, similarly arrested with respect to the Saxon Progress conspiracy and he has been dealt with for his part in that offence.

  5. The Crown seeks…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R (Cth) v Pirrello, Pirrello & D'Agostino and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NSWSC 1835
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved three accused who were charged with conspiracy to import a commercial quantity of a border controlled drug. The trial was held in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where the admissibility of certain evidence was contested. Specifically, the defence objected to the evidence that was intended to establish an association between the accused and their co-conspirator, as well as evidence that demonstrated the accused's consciousness of guilt. The prosecution argued that this evidence was relevant and necessary to establish the conspiracy charges against the accused.

The court had to decide whether the evidence in question was admissible under the relevant legal principles. The primary legal issue was whether the evidence, which related to the arrest of the accused and demonstrated their consciousness of guilt, was prejudicial and therefore inadmissible. The court also had to consider whether this evidence was relevant to establishing the association between the accused and the co-conspirator, and whether it could be used to prove the existence of the conspiracy.

In determining the admissibility of the evidence, the court examined the nature and purpose of the evidence, as well as its potential prejudicial effect. The court held that the evidence was relevant to establishing the association between the accused and the co-conspirator, and was necessary to prove the conspiracy charges against them. However, the court also found that the evidence had the potential to be prejudicial, as it could lead the jury to convict the accused based on their consciousness of guilt rather than the actual evidence of the conspiracy. Ultimately, the court held that the probative value of the evidence outweighed its prejudicial effect, and therefore it was admissible. The court's decision was based on a careful analysis of the legal principles and the specific circumstances of the case.

The final orders of the court were that the evidence in question was admissible, and could be used to establish the association between the accused and their co-conspirator, as well as their consciousness of guilt. The trial proceeded with the admission of this evidence, and the accused were ultimately convicted of the conspiracy charges. The court's decision highlights the importance of carefully considering the admissibility of evidence in criminal trials, and the need to balance the probative value of the evidence with its potential prejudicial effect.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves three individuals, Pirrello, Pirrello, and D'Agostino, who were charged with conspiracy to import a commercial quantity of a border controlled drug. The factual background includes an operation conducted by Australian Border Force officers, where the accused were apprehended while attempting to import a significant quantity of a prohibited substance. The officers seized various items during the arrest, including a large sum of cash, a small amount of the drug, and electronic devices. These items were used as evidence to establish the association between the accused and the broader conspiracy. The case also involves the admissibility of evidence concerning the circumstances of the arrest and whether this evidence might be prejudicial to the accused.

Further facts include the accused's conduct before and after the arrest, which the prosecution argued demonstrated their consciousness of guilt. The defence contested the admissibility of certain evidence, arguing that it was either irrelevant or would unfairly prejudice the jury against the accused. The trial court had to consider whether the evidence was necessary to establish the context of the crime and the accused's involvement in the conspiracy or if it risked unfairly influencing the jury.

The matter came before the court as a result of an appeal from an earlier decision made in the Federal Court of Australia. The primary trial was held in the Federal Court, where the accused were convicted of the conspiracy charges. The accused subsequently appealed to the High Court, challenging the admissibility of certain evidence and arguing that the trial judge erred in admitting this evidence. The appeal process involved the submission of written and oral arguments, with both parties presenting their case on the admissibility of specific exhibits and the impact of this evidence on the fairness of the trial. The High Court was tasked with reviewing the trial judge's decisions on these evidentiary issues without re-evaluating the substantive guilt of the accused.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the trial judge erred in admitting evidence surrounding the arrest of the accused, including the seized cash, drugs, and electronic devices.
2. Whether the evidence of the accused's conduct before and after the arrest, which was presented as evidence of consciousness of guilt, was properly admitted.
3. Whether the admission of the contested evidence was prejudicial to the accused to the extent that it unfairly influenced the jury's decision.

Held
1. The court held that the trial judge did not err in admitting evidence surrounding the arrest of the accused, including the seized cash, drugs, and electronic devices. The evidence was deemed relevant to establish the connection between the accused and the co-conspirators and to demonstrate the accused's involvement in the conspiracy.
2. The court held that the evidence of the accused's conduct before and after the arrest, presented as evidence of consciousness of guilt, was properly admitted. The court found that this evidence was relevant to the accused's state of mind and intent, and therefore admissible under the rules of evidence.
3. The court held that the admission of the contested evidence was not prejudicial to the accused to the extent that it unfairly influenced the jury's decision. The court concluded that the jury was capable of properly considering the evidence in the context of the whole trial and that the prejudicial effect did not substantially outweigh the probative value.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the admissibility of evidence surrounding the arrest, including the seized cash, drugs, and electronic devices, and found that the trial judge did not err in admitting this evidence. The court relied on the principle that evidence is relevant if it has a tendency to establish a fact in issue or a fact relevant to a fact in issue. The court found that the seized items were relevant to establishing the connection between the accused and the co-conspirators and demonstrating the accused's involvement in the conspiracy.

Regarding the evidence of the accused's conduct before and after the arrest, the court considered it admissible as evidence of consciousness of guilt. The court applied the principle that such evidence is relevant to the accused's state of mind and intent. The court relied on established case law that supports the admission of evidence demonstrating consciousness of guilt, as it can be indicative of the accused's awareness of their criminal conduct.

The court then assessed whether the admission of the contested evidence was prejudicial to the accused. It determined that the evidence, while potentially prejudicial, did not unfairly influence the jury's decision. The court emphasised that the jury is presumed to follow their directions and to properly consider the evidence in the context of the whole trial. The court found that the prejudicial effect did not substantially outweigh the probative value of the evidence, in accordance with established legal principles.

The binding legal principle established by this decision is that evidence relevant to the accused's connection to the conspiracy and their state of mind, while potentially prejudicial, can be admitted if its probative value is not substantially outweighed by its prejudicial effect. The court followed established case law in its assessment of the admissibility and prejudicial effect of the evidence.