Quinn and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements)

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

Quinn and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements) [2017] AATA 2714 (20 December 2017)

Division:                  VETERANS' APPEALS DIVISION

File Number(s):      2016/4217

Re:Michael Joseph Quinn

APPLICANT

AndRepatriation Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member D. J. Morris

Date:20 December 2017

Place:Melbourne

The decision under review is affirmed.

[sgd]........................................................................

Senior Member

VETERANS’ ENTITLEMENTS – Application for disability pension – claim for dental caries – prisoner of war contention for service in Cambodia – whether collateral reason for review - decision affirmed

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, ss. 37, 42B
Geneva Conventions Act 1949

Statement of Principles concerning Dental Caries (Reasonable Hypothesis)(No. 122 of 2015), Determination by the Repatriation Medical Authority – 16 October 2015

Veterans’ Entitlement Act 1986, ss 5A-11B, Part VIB, s 115M, s119, s120, s 120A, , Sch 2.

Cases

Repatriation Commission v Deledio [1998] 29 ALD 193
East v Repatriation Commission [1987] 16 FCR 517

Forrester v Repatriation Commission [2013] FCA 898

Secondary Materials

Agreement on a Comprehensive Political Settlement of the Cambodia Conflict (signed at Paris on 23 October 1991)
Department of Veterans’ Affairs Fees Schedule of Dental Services for Dentists and Dental Specialists (Effective 1 June 2014)
The Official History of Australian Peacekeeping, Humanitarian and Post-Cold War Operations: Volume III: The Good International Citizen-Australian Peacekeeping in Asia, Africa and Europe 1991-1993; David Horner and John Connor; Cambridge University Press (2014)

Veterans’ Entitlements and Military Compensation Law (3rd Ed.); Robin Creyke and Peter Sutherland; Federation Press (2016)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member D. J. Morris

20 December 2017

  1. Mr Michael Quinn seeks review of a decision of the Repatriation Commission (‘the Commission’) dated 19 April 2016 as affirmed by the Veterans’ Review Board (‘the VRB’) on 26 July 2016.  The Commission refused a claim for disability pension dated 20 December 2015 in respect of dental caries, made under the Veterans’ Entitlement Act 1986 (‘the VEA’).

  2. Mr Quinn claims to have suffered dental caries connected with his operational service in Cambodia from 10 November 1991 to 17 May 1992.

    Veterans’ entitlements

  3. Robin Creyke and Peter Sutherland neatly encapsulated the VEA regime in Veterans’ Entitlements and Military Compensation Law (3rd edition) thus:

    The system of veterans’ entitlements in Australia has been set up to provide pensions, benefits and other allowances to members of the armed forces and Australian mariners who have served in wars and other hazardous or peacekeeping service, and to their dependants.

    There are two major pensions for veterans:  the disability pension which is compensation for service-related injury, disease or death; and the service pension which is a pension for veterans broadly equivalent to the social security age pension.

  4. The VEA is intended to be applied both fairly and beneficially to veterans who have served Australia and, as a consequence of that service, have suffered physical or emotional harm.  This philosophy is reflected in section 119(1)(f) and (g) of the VEA which provides that the Commission is not bound by technicalities in considering, hearing, determining and deciding claims.  As stated by Mortimer J in Forrester v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Quinn and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 2714
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr Quinn for a review of a decision by the Repatriation Commission concerning his claim for dental caries. The dispute centred on whether Mr Quinn's service in Cambodia between 17 November 1991 and 17 May 1992 constituted operational service for the purposes of the *Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986* (VEA), and whether his dental condition arose from that service. The decision was made by D. J. Morris SM.

The court was required to determine whether the material before it raised a hypothesis connecting Mr Quinn's dental condition with his service in Cambodia, and if so, whether a Statement of Principles was in force. It also needed to consider whether the hypothesis was reasonable, and finally, whether it was satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the dental caries did not arise from war-caused injury. The court adopted the four-step approach outlined in *Repatriation Commission v Deledio* (1998) 49 ALD 193 for assessing such claims.

The court found that while Mr Quinn and his colleagues were restricted in their movements and required to be accompanied by Khmer Rouge personnel when leaving their building in Pailin, this did not amount to being prisoners of war. This was because Mr Quinn had volunteered for the deployment, was aware of the nature of the posting through pre-deployment briefings, and had not fallen into the power of the enemy. The court noted that the applicant's representative had referred to the Official History of Australian Peacekeeping, Humanitarian and Post-Cold War Operations, which corroborated the restrictions on movement. However, the court concluded that the circumstances did not meet the mandatory requirement of falling into the power of the enemy for the purposes of the Third Geneva Convention.

The decision under review was affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

In Repatriation Commission v Deledio (1998) 49 ALD 193, the Full Court of the Federal Court set out four steps for determining claims relating to the application of Statements of Principles under section 120A and subsections (1) and (3) of section 120 of the VEA. I shall describe them in the reasons as the Deledio steps. Their Honours held, at [93] to [98]:1.The tribunal must consider all the material which is before it and determine whether that material points to a hypothesis connecting the injury, disease or death with the circumstances of the particular service rendered by the person. No question of fact finding arises at this stage. If no such hypothesis arises, the application must fail.2.If the material does raise such a hypothesis, the tribunal must then ascertain whether there is in force an SoP determined by the Authority under s 196B(2) or (11). If no such SoP is in force, the hypothesis will be taken not to be reasonable and, in consequence, the application must fail.3.If an SoP is in force, the tribunal must then form the opinion whether the hypothesis raised is a reasonable one. It will do so if the hypothesis fits, that is to say, is consistent with the “template” to be found in the SoP. The hypothesis raised before it must thus contain one or more of the factors which the authority has determined to be the minimum which must exist, and be related to the person’s service (as required by ss 196B(2)(d) and (e)). If the hypothesis does contain these factors, it could neither be said to be contrary to proved or known scientific facts, nor otherwise fanciful. If the hypothesis fails to fit within the template, it will be deemed not to be “reasonable” and the claim will fail.4.The tribunal must then proceed to consider under s 120(1) whether it is satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the death was not war-caused, or in the case of a claim for incapacity, that the incapacity did not arise from a war-caused injury. If not so satisfied, the claim must succeed. If the tribunal is so satisfied, the claim must fail. It is only at this stage of the process that the tribunal will be required to find facts from the material before it. In so doing, no question of onus of proof or the application of any presumption will be involved.The Tribunal therefore approaches this review, adopting the reasoning of the Court in terms of the application of the Deledio steps.BACKGROUND Mr Quinn served in the Australian Army from 1981 to 2002. He had operational service in Cambodia from 17 November 1991 to 17 May 1992. Item 12 of Schedule 2 to the VEA prescribes Cambodia as an operational area in the period 20 October 1991 to 7 October 1993. Mr Quinn’s operational service in Cambodia was as part of Australia’s support for United Nations (UN) missions to Cambodia which resulted from the Agreement on a Comprehensive Political Settlement of the Cambodia Conflict’ signed at Paris on 23 October 1991 (commonly called the Paris Peace Accords). Mr Quinn was initially posted to the United Nations Advance Mission in Cambodia (‘UNAMIC’). The Respondent submitted that the task of UNAMIC was to help create a neutral environment in which Cambodia’s warring factions could disarm and demobilise.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

If there is some other gap that the Applicant has identified in the cover that is available to him, as opposed to future hypothetical dental or health needs, that is not a matter for this review of his claim for dental caries as a consequence of his service.DECISION The decision under review is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Applicant’s representative referred the Tribunal to the Official History of Australian Peacekeeping, Humanitarian and Post-Cold War Operations The Good International Citizen – Australian Peacekeeping in Asia, Africa and Europe 1991-1993 by David Horner and John Connor. The Tribunal obtained a copy of the book and notes that at page 127 there is discussion of the Australian signallers posted to UNAMIC and says:The most difficult and most frustrating posting was at Team Echo at Pailin, which had been captured by the Khmer Rouge on 22 October 1989. Many of the town’s buildings were still battle-scarred. With its rich gemfields and its proximity to Thailand, Pailin had an exotic, almost legendary, reputation among Cambodians. Team Echo was provided with a newly repaired two-storey building adjacent to what the Khmer Rouge claimed was their military headquarters. However, the peacekeepers quickly realised that this was a sham and that the officers there were ‘clearly their second eleven’. (The real Khmer Rouge military headquarters was probably in the Thai border camp known as Site K.) The Khmer Rouge’s policy of non-cooperation with UNAMIC included limiting the team’s movements to a 500-metre radius of their accommodation and not allowing their resupply by helicopter to Phnom Penh, which necessitated sending food, fuel and other items via Thailand….Team Echo retained their spirit in the face of these limitations. The Australian signallers stretched the limits of the Khmer Rouge restrictions by establishing a running route that went beyond the 500-metre limit to the local Buddhist temple on a hill overlooking the town as part of their fitness regime. When the team leader, Commandant O’Meara of the Irish Army, was told he was to be transferred to UNAMIC Headquarters he told Loridon [the French general who was deputy head of UNAMIC] of the ‘very strong bond’ that had been formed by the Australians and other members of his team and requested permission to remain with the detachment in Pailin.Consideration There is no doubt to me from the evidence both given by Mr Quinn and corroborated in the official history, as set out above, that the Applicant and his colleagues were restricted in their movements when in Pailin. It is also clear that the movements of the Applicant and other UN personnel in this location were restricted and that they had to be accompanied by Khmer Rouge personnel whenever leaving the precincts of their building. However, it is objectively untenable to support the proposition that Mr Quinn and his UN colleagues at this time were prisoners of war. They had not fallen into the power of the enemy, a mandatory requirement to satisfy the relevant Article of the Third Geneva Convention, for two reasons: the Applicant had volunteered for this attachment and had travelled from Australia to Thailand and Cambodia knowing that this was the nature of the deployment. He gave evidence that this had been extensively explained to him in and his fellow Australian UNAMIC colleagues in briefings before they left Australia.