Quinn and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

Quinn and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) [2024] AATA 3004 (23 August 2024)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2022/5030

2023/7789

Re:Mr Stephen Quinn

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Ms A E Burke AO, Member

Date:23 August 2024

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal sets aside the decision of 20 April 2022 and decides that Australia Post continues to be liable to pay compensation for Mr Quinn injuries, in accordance with section 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (SRC Act). The Tribunal remits the matter to Australia Post to assess Mr Quinn’s compensation in accordance with sections 16 and 19 of the SRC Act, in respect of reasonable medical expenses and incapacity for work.

The Tribunal affirms the decision of 18 August 2023.

...............................[sgd].........................................

Ms A E Burke AO, Member

Catchwords

WORKER’S COMPENSATION – mail sorter - Australia Post – no present liability – whether injury was work related – conflicting medical evidence – whether pre-existing condition – whether degeneration – whether acute physiological change occurred – whether injury occurred whilst undergoing treatment – 2 separate determinations – first decision set aside; second decision affirmed

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth)

Cases

Australian Postal Corporation v Burch (1998) 85 FCR 264
Bis Industries Limited v Dale [2017] FCA 789

Canute v Comcare (2006) 226 CLR 535
Szabo v Comcare [2012] FCFCA 1829
Telstra Corporation Ltd v Hannaford (2006) 90 ALD 263

Secondary Materials
Michele C Battié et al, ‘The Twin Spine Study: Contributions to a changing view of disc degeneration’ (2009) 9(1) The Spine Journal 47
Rahman Shiri et al, ‘The Association Between Obesity and Low Back Pain: A Meta-Analysis’ (2009) 171(2) American Journal of Epidemiology 135
Vini G Khurana, ‘Adverse impact of smoking on the spine and spinal Surgery’ (2021) 12 Surgical Neurology International 118

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms A E Burke AO, Member

First Application 2022/5030

  1. Mr Stephen Quinn (the Applicant), applied for review of a decision by Australia Postal Corporation (Australia Post) (the Respondent) dated 7 June 2022, which found no present liability for compensation under sections 16 and 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the SRC Act) in respect of Mr Quinn’s accepted claim for “Mechanical Lower Back Strain” sustained on 4 January 2021. The decision was based on the 25 February 2022 report of consultant neurosurgeon, Dr Ashish Jonathan, which concluded that Mr Quinn’s current condition related to the pre-existing degenerative changes in his lumbar spine rather than his employment or the incident on 4 January 2021.

  2. On 7 June 2022, Mr Quinn sought review of that decision by the General Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal), stating that he disagreed with the decision as: The Respondent has given inadequate consideration to the Applicant’s medical evidence.

    Second Application 2023/7789

  3. Mr Quinn applied for review of a decision by Australia Post dated 9 October 2023 which denied liability under section 14 of the Act in respect of Mr…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Quinn and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 3004
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for review by Mr Quinn against a decision by Australia Post regarding his claim for compensation under the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (Cth) (SRC Act). Mr Quinn, a mail sorter, alleged he sustained a lower back injury on 4 January 2021 while lifting a box of dog food at the Dandenong South Parcel Delivery Centre. Australia Post initially accepted liability for a "Mechanical Lower Back Strain" on 22 January 2021. Mr Quinn sought review of a subsequent decision by Australia Post, arguing that his medical evidence had not been adequately considered.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether Mr Quinn had suffered an injury, and if so, whether his employment with Australia Post contributed to that condition or the aggravation of a pre-existing condition to a significant degree. Specifically, the Tribunal had to consider whether the injury arose out of, or in the course of, his employment, and if Australia Post was liable to pay compensation. The court also had to consider conflicting medical evidence regarding the nature of Mr Quinn's condition, including whether it was a disease or an injury simpliciter, and the extent to which pre-existing degenerative conditions, smoking, and obesity might have contributed to his back pain.

The Tribunal applied the principles established in *Canute v Comcare* (2006) 226 CLR 535 regarding the definition of "injury" under the SRC Act, distinguishing between an "injury simpliciter" and a "disease." An injury simpliciter requires the injury to arise out of, or in the course of, employment, whereas a disease requires employment to have contributed to the condition to a significant degree. The Tribunal found that the Safety Event/Investigation – Output Form provided by Mr Quinn's supervisor constituted evidence of a precipitating incident that arose out of the course of his employment. This form detailed the event of Mr Quinn feeling a "pop" in his lower back while lifting a box, followed by immediate stiffness and removal from lifting duties. The Tribunal considered the medical reports and submissions from counsel, including those suggesting degenerative changes were genetic and related to lifestyle factors, but ultimately focused on whether the incident itself constituted an injury under the Act.

The Tribunal affirmed the second decision, finding that Mr Quinn had suffered an injury simpliciter arising out of, or in the course of, his employment with Australia Post. The court determined that the initial acceptance of liability under section 14 of the SRC Act for a mechanical lower back strain was appropriate, notwithstanding arguments about pre-existing degenerative conditions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 22 October 2022, Mr Quinn sought review of that decision by the General Division of the Tribunal, stating that he disagreed with the decision as: The Respondent has given inadequate consideration to the Applicant's medical evidence.BACKGROUND Mr Quinn was employed by Australia Post from 16 December 2019 as a Postal Delivery Officer at Bentleigh East; he was redeployed on 15 October 2020 to the Dandenong South Parcel Delivery Centre (PDC) as a mail sorter and terminated on 14 February 2022 on the grounds of serious and wilful misconduct. Mr Quinn is currently 52 years old and at the time of his injury was working as a Parcel Officer at the Dandenong South PDC. Mr Quinn commenced and completed a plumbing apprenticeship upon leaving school, has since worked as a plumber, truck driver, self-employed courier and in an administrative role in a plumbing supply business. Mr Quinn has been an active and keen sportsman, playing competitive football and cricket until his thirties. After Mr Quinn left Australia Post he undertook casual warehouse work, coached football in schools through an AFL program, and is currently employed as a part time sports coach/supervisor at Mentone Grammar. On 11 January 2021, Mr Quinn’s supervisor Mr Andrew Friend submitted a Safety Event/Investigation – Output Form which recorded the following details in respect of Mr Quinn:Title Hurt back while lifting dog foodEvent Date 04.01.2021 Event Time 03:30Description While sorting the non machinable cages I went to lift a box of dog food and when I tried to come back up I felt a pop in my lower back. The box was not marked as heavy. Sorter recalls bending his knees when attempting to lift the box. Immediate Actions Sorter went to tea break after this event and sorters back started to stiffen right up during the break. Sorter was taken off any lifting duties and asked just to scan any parcels. Doctors appointment was offered but sorter would prefers to go to their own doctor. This will be around 9am today.Event Classification Incident - Something happened which Severity Minor-No hospitalisation / <5Potential Severity Minor-No hospitalisation / <5 days lost Event TypeEvent Location Dandenong South PDC 147-153 Greens Road Dandenong South VIC 3175Australia On 12 January 2021, Mr Quinn submitted a claim for compensation under the SRC Act, as he had injured his lower back whilst on duty. Mr Quinn claimed he had lower back strain sustained while sorting parcels, with the injury occurring on 4 January 2021 and reported on 5 January 2021. On 22 January 2021, Australia Post accepted liability for Mr Quinn’s "Mechanical Lower Back Strain" pursuant to section 14 of the SRC Act with the date of injury determined as 4 January 2021. On 14 February 2022, Australia Post terminated Mr Quinn on the grounds of serious and wilful misconduct in relation to an incident which occurred on 23 November 2021. Mr Quinn was observed on a forklift truck carrying two fully laden unit load devices, this resulted in a near miss incident with a pedestrian working in the same area which he reported to management. Australia Post described the incident as Mr Quinn driving a forklift travelling in a forward motion, however, he should have been travelling in reverse to have vision of any personnel on foot in his direction of travel.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The key issues for determination are:(a)Has Mr Quinn suffered an injury (disease) and, if so, has his employment at Australia Post contributed to that condition(s) or the aggravation of that condition(s) to a significant degree?(b)Has Mr Quinn suffered an injury (other than a disease) and, if so, did it arise out of, or in the course of, his employment with Australia Post?(c)If the answer is yes to either of the above, is Australia Post liable to pay compensation?EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIBUNALMedical On 3 April 2014, Practitioner JN at the Parkdale Chiropractic Clinic recorded that Mr Quinn had presented with a complaint of “spinal subluxation joint complex with associated HTT MM” and recorded:Subjective Response: Muscle feel tight & acheClinical ImpressionGeneral Spinal Check UpPurpose of consult to maintain health with a focus on spinal mobilityEncouraged to increase stretching and mobility as employment requires long periods of sittingLX and THX CAV moderateMTT degree of CAV On 10 July 2014, Practitioner JN recorded that Mr Quinn had presented with a complaint of “spinal subluxation joint complex with associated HTT MM” and recorded:Subjective Response: Muscle feel tight & acheClinical ImpressionSpinal tightness improving less restrictedTends to spasm around THX on spinal STTGroin pulling BIGoal to improve spinal mobilityFocus on maintaining function and strength Australia Post’s pre-employment medical assessment report completed on 2 December 2019 assessed Mr Quinn’s back function as normal and that Mr Quinn demonstrated a normal range of motion for his age. On 26 November 2019, Practitioner JN recorded that Mr Quinn had presented with a complaint of left lower lumbar strain sprain and recorded:Subjective Response: Muscle feel tight & acheClinical ImpressionL leg hip painBig toe numbnessSLR – VE BINo specific incidentNo red flagsSleeping okStress ok On 25 June 2020, Practitioner JN recorded that Mr Quinn had presented with a complaint of “spinal subluxation joint complex with associated HTT MM” and recorded:Subjective Response: Muscle feel tight & acheClinical ImpressionL leg hip painBig toe numbnessNo neuro radiculopathyHeel and toe walking normal L4/5 L5/S1Ballet standing exercise normal On 27 October 2020, Practitioner JN recorded that Mr Quinn had presented with a complaint of “acute lower lumbar strain sprain work injury” and recorded:Clinical ImpressionChanged jobsFell off post bike landed on R forearm and leg 3 weeks agoTender LAT area of backPulling in R armL glut tender seized upShoulder scan required if no improvementReported to work as injury On 11 November 2020, Practitioner JN recorded that Mr Quinn had presented with a complaint of “acute lower lumbar strain sprain work injury” and recorded:Clinical ImpressionL glut into hami nerve pain lockingA couple days deterioratingGot off forkliftLX mild tightnessSP mobilisation and fascial release light TX AS high degree of P and MM spasm On 16 November 2020, Practitioner JN recorded that Mr Quinn had presented with a complaint of “acute lower lumbar strain sprain work injury” and recorded:Clinical ImpressionL glut into hami nerve pain lockingA couple days deterioratingGot off forkliftLX mild tightnessTHX tightnessFeels ok at the moment but getting up causes LBPSP mobilisation and fascial release light TX

Decision

Reasons for decision

Counsel contended that liability should never have been accepted under section 14 of the SRC Act for the accepted back injury, relying upon the opinion of Dr Jonathan contained in his reports dated 30 August 2022, 26 April 2023 and 28 November 2023. In support of their contention, Counsel took the Tribunal to several medical journals which they submitted corroborated their claim and Dr Jonathan’s findings that degenerative changes in Mr Quinn’s spine were genetic and related to smoking and obesity:The Twin Spine Study: Contributions to a changing view of disc degenerationCONCLUSIONS: The once commonly held view that disc degeneration is primarily a result of aging and ‘‘wear and tear’’ from mechanical insults and injuries was not supported by this series of studies. Instead, disc degeneration appears to be determined in great part by genetic influences. Although environmental factors also play a role, it is not primarily through routine physical loading exposures (eg, heavy vs. light physical demands) as once suspected.The Association Between Obesity and Low Back Pain: A Meta-AnalysisThis meta-analysis assessed the association between overweight/obesity and low back pain.…In summary, this meta-analysis shows that overweight and obesity are associated with an increased risk of low back pain. The association is strongest for seeking care for low back pain and chronic low back pain. Our study suggests that obesity is a potentially modifiable risk factor for low back pain. However, well-conducted prospective studies, including intervention studies, are needed to confirm our findings.Adverse impact of smoking on the spine and spinal surgeryThe nutritional supply of intervertebral discs, which are nonvascular tissues, depends on diffusion from adjacent vertebral bodies. That supply is compromised by smoking-induced vascular atherosclerosis in both local arteries and arterioles, thus promoting generalized tissue ischemia. Smoking also induces a hypoxic and low pH state in intervertebral discs, leading to a reduction in normal cellular activity that impairs collagen and proteoglycan production, while enhancing enzymatic proteolysis. Smoking’s disruption of cells, extracellular matrix, and the ordered histological architecture in spinal discs contributes to fissures/tears and fibrotic macroscopic hardening of the nucleus pulposus. Together, these adverse factors advance the loss of disc height/hydration (desiccation) and promote the onset of earlier and more severe symptomatic lumbar spondylosis. In studies of identical twins where one smoked and the other did not, the smoker was found to have higher disc degeneration and lower bone mineral density (BMD) scores.…Through a multitude of pathophysiological mechanisms, smoking negatively impacts the structure of the spine and the results of spinal surgery. Patients anticipating undergoing spinal procedures should therefore quit smoking immediately and permanently. Counsel contended that the Tribunal did not have jurisdiction in the context of Mr Quinn’s first claim to consider or treat the initial accepted injury on the alternative basis that it was a “disease”.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Counsel submitted that evidence indicated that Mr Quinn had no current compensable injury, was undertaking no treatment and had been found fit for pre-injury duties. CONSIDERATION The Tribunal notes (like numerous Tribunal Members before) the following observations of the High Court in Canute v Comcare (2006) 226 CLR 535 at 540 about the concept of an “injury”:…First, the Act does not oblige Comcare to pay compensation in respect of an employee's impairment; it is liable to pay compensation in respect of 'the injury'. Secondly, the term 'injury' is not used in the Act in the sense of 'workplace accident'. The definition of 'injury' is expressed in terms of the resultant effect of an incident or ailment upon the employee's body. Thirdly, the term 'injury' is not used in a global sense to describe the general condition of the employee following an incident. The Act refers disjunctively to 'disease' or 'physical or mental' injuries and, at least to that extent, it assumes that an employee may sustain more than one 'injury'. The use in s 24(1) of the indefinite article in the expression 'an injury' reinforces that conclusion. The distinction between sections 5A(1)(a) and 5A(1)(b) of the SRC Act is an important one, given that the classification of a condition as either a disease or an injury (other than a disease) will determine the applicable test for determining the contribution of work to an injury. Specifically, for there to be an injury (other than a disease) (often referred to as an “injury simpliciter”), the injury must arise out of, or in the course of employment (section 5A(1)(b) of the SRC Act). An injury simpliciter (within the meaning of section 5A(1)(b) of the SRC Act) can be contrasted with a “disease” which, according to section 5B(1), must be contributed to, to a significant degree, by the employee’s employment. Thus, a “disease” requires a stronger causal connection between the employment and the ailment (Burch at 268) than that required for an injury simpliciter. The Tribunal found that there was evidence that Mr Quinn had suffered a precipitating incident which arose out of the course of his employment. The Tribunal relied upon the Safety Event/Investigation – Output Form completed by Mr Quinn’s supervisor, which clearly outlines immediate action was taken by Australia Post following the incident on 4 January 2021.Description While sorting the non machinable cages I went to lift a box of dog food and when I tried to come back up I felt a pop in my lower back. The box was not marked as heavy. Sorter recalls bending his knees when attempting to lift the box. Immediate Actions Sorter went to tea break after this event and sorters back started to stiffen right up during the break. Sorter was taken off any lifting duties and asked just to scan any parcels. Doctors appointment was offered but sorter would prefers to go to their own doctor. This will be around 9am today. The Tribunal then must determine if the evidence before it demonstrated a causal connection between Mr Quinn’s claimed condition of mechanical lower back strain and the precipitating incident to satisfy the statutory definition of injuries in accordance with the SRC Act.