Queensland Police Service v Ntakarutimana

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Queensland Police Service v Ntakarutimana [2012] QDC 139

PARTIES:

QUEENSLAND POLICE SERVICE
(appellant)

v

INNOCENT NTAKARUTIMANA
(respondent)

FILE NOS:

33/2011 & 34/2011

DIVISION:

Criminal

PROCEEDING:

Appeal 

ORIGINATING COURT:

Beenleigh

DELIVERED ON:

22 June 2012

DELIVERED AT:

Beenleigh

HEARING DATE:

10 May 2012

JUDGE:

Dearden DCJ

ORDERS:

1.        Appeal granted.

2. Orders of “no case to answer” in respect of the offences of fail to provide a specimen of breath (TORUMA s. 80(5A)(b)) and fail to provide a specimen of breath for analysis (TORUMA s. 80(11)), set aside.

3. Verdicts of acquittal for the offences of obstruct police and driving under the influence of liquor (TORUMA s. 79(1)(A)) set aside.

4. Remit the offences of fail to provide specimen of breath (TORUMA s. 80(5A)(b)); fail to provide a specimen of breath for analysis (TORUMA s. 80(11)); obstruct police (PPRA s. 790(1)); and drive under the influence of liquor (TORUMA s. 79(1)(A)) to the Magistrates Court at Beenleigh for retrial before another magistrate.

CATCHWORDS:

Criminal law – appeal and new trial – where at trial, magistrate ordered “no case to answer” –  error of law – misdirection as to elements of the offence – whether the learned magistrate erred in accepting a “no case” submission

Criminal law – appeal and new trial – where at trial, magistrate made a finding of not guilty – error of law – misdirection as to elements of the offence – where defences not addressed by learned magistrate

Criminal law – appeal and new trial – where at trial, magistrate made a finding of not guilty – error of fact

LEGISLATION:

Transport Operations (Road Use Management) Act 1995 (Qld) ss. 79(1)(A), 80(5A)(b) and 80(11)

Police Powers and Responsibilities Act 2000 (Qld) s. 790(1)

Justices Act s. 225(1), (2)

CASES:

Stehbens v Queensland Police Service [2012] QDC 132

R v Gesa and Nona; ex-parte Attorney General [2001] 2 Qd R 72

Doney v R (1990) 171 CLR 207

Queensland Police Service v Tobane [2010] QDC 222

Walton v Gardiner (1993) 177 CLR 378

R v Ferguson; ex-parte Attorney General of Queensland [2008] QCA 227

R v Sutton [1986] 2 Qd R 72

COUNSEL:

J A Wooldridge for the appellant

L K Crowley for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Director of Public Prosecutions for the appellant

Legal Aid Queensland for the respondent

Introduction

  1. On 15, 16 and 23 March 2011, the respondent, Innocent Ntakarutimana, appeared for summary trial before the learned magistrate at Beenleigh in respect of the following charges:-

(1)       Fail to provide a specimen of breath (Transport Operations (Road Use Management) Act 1995) (“TORUMA”) s. 80(5A)(b);

(2) Fail to provide specimen of breath for analysis (TORUMA s. 80(11));

(3)       Obstruct police (Police Powers and Responsibilities Act 2000 (PPRA)) s. 790(1); and

(4) Drive under the influence of liquor (TORUMA s. 79(1)(A)).

  1. The learned magistrate, at the conclusion of the prosecution case, found that the respondent had no case to answer in respect of the offence of failing to provide a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Queensland Police Service v Ntakarutimana and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] QDC 139
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Queensland Police Service v Ntakarutimana, the appellant, the Queensland Police Service, sought to appeal a decision made by a magistrate in the Magistrates Court at Beenleigh. The respondent, Ntakarutimana, had been charged with various offences, including failing to provide a specimen of breath, failing to provide a specimen of breath for analysis, obstructing police, and driving under the influence of liquor. During the trial, the magistrate ordered a "no case to answer" on the charges of failing to provide a specimen of breath and failing to provide a specimen of breath for analysis, and subsequently found the respondent not guilty on the charges of obstructing police and driving under the influence of liquor.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the magistrate erred in law by accepting the "no case" submission and misdirecting themselves as to the elements of the offence, and whether the magistrate erred in law by not addressing the defences raised by the respondent. Additionally, the court had to determine if there was an error of fact that warranted the appeal.

The court held that the magistrate had indeed erred in law by misdirecting themselves on the elements of the offence and by not addressing the defences raised by the respondent. The court found that the magistrate had failed to properly consider the evidence and the applicable legal principles in reaching their decision. Consequently, the appeal was granted, the orders of "no case to answer" were set aside, and the verdicts of acquittal were also set aside. The court ordered that the charges be remitted to the Magistrates Court at Beenleigh for retrial before another magistrate.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal granted.

2. Orders of “no case to answer” in respect of the offences of fail to provide a specimen of breath (TORUMA s. 80(5A)(b)) and fail to provide a specimen of breath for analysis (TORUMA s. 80(11)), set aside.

3. Verdicts of acquittal for the offences of obstruct police and driving under the influence of liquor (TORUMA s. 79(1)(A)) set aside.

4. Remit the offences of fail to provide specimen of breath (TORUMA s. 80(5A)(b)); fail to provide a specimen of breath for analysis (TORUMA s. 80(11)); obstruct police (PPRA s. 790(1)); and drive under the influence of liquor (TORUMA s. 79(1)(A)) to the Magistrates Court at Beenleigh for retrial before another magistrate.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established