Queensland Law Soc Inc & Anor v PA Sande

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF QUEENSLAND
  No. 713 of 1995
[Queensland Law Soc Inc & Anor v. P.A. Sande]

BETWEEN:
  THE QUEENSLAND LAW SOCIETY INCORPORATED and
              THE COUNCIL OF THE QUEENSLAND LAW SOCIETY INCORPORATED

Applicant/Prosecutors
AND:
  PAUL ALEXANDER SANDE
  Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - THOMAS J

Delivered:1 April 1997

CATCHWORDS:     CONTEMPT, ATTACHMENT AND SEQUESTRATION - contempt of court - breach of injunction - acting or practising as a solicitor or conveyancer - directly or indirectly - drawing or preparing an instrument relating to real estate for reward without certificate.

SOLICITORS - acts amounting to practice as a solicitor - acts amounting to practice as conveyancer - whether delegation to agents or subcontractors - whether engagement of third persons alters nature of act of principal who undertakes for reward provision of overall conveyancing service - acts in Queensland by uncertificated person allegedly as agent for SA land-broker acting as "principal" on behalf of Queensland clients - acts of "agent" in Queensland still prohibited - Law Society NSW v. Ramalca (1988) 12 NSWLR 34 discussed - stamping - lodgment - searches - requisitions on title - settlement statements - giving of legal advice - whether documents relating to real estate drawn or prepared in Queensland.

INJUNCTION - restraint against individual from acting or practising in Queensland as solicitor or conveyancer - conveyancing practice conducted by company of which individual was major shareholder, director and manager, who personally devised system and caused and procured acts of company - whether injunction breached.

STATUTES - interpretation - whether definition in rules governs meaning of words in Act.

Queensland Law Society Act 1952 ss. 5, 38, 39, 46;  Legal Practitioners Act 1995 s. 19.

Counsel:Mr R. Perry for the Plaintiffs

Mr S. English for the Defendant

Solicitors:McCullough Robertson for the Plaintiffs

Mr Richard Keller for the Defendant

Hearing date:               10-17 March 1997

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF QUEENSLAND  No. 713 of 1995

[Queensland Law Soc Inc & Anor v. P.A. Sande]

BETWEEN:

THE QUEENSLAND LAW SOCIETY INCORPORATED and
              THE COUNCIL OF THE QUEENSLAND LAW SOCIETY INCORPORATED

Applicant/Prosecutors
AND:
  PAUL ALEXANDER SANDE
  Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - THOMAS J
  Judgment delivered 1 April 1997

I n d e x

Facts.............................................................................................................................................   2

Engagement of Duncan Sande & Associates.......................................................................   6

Services offered and provided by RCS...............................................................................   9

The standard retainer (post injunction)................................................................................ 11

Absence of certification...................................................................................................... 13

A typical conveyancing transaction..................................................................................... 14

Further activity of RCS...................................................................................................... 20

Advice and negotiation........................................................................................... 20

Other parts of the service (requisitions, searches, stamping, lodging, settlement statements)         21

General................................................................................................................. 23

Issues and Findings.................................................................................................................... 24

Knowledge of order.......................................................................................................... 24

Standard of proof.............................................................................................................. 24

"Practising as a conveyancer"............................................................................................. 24

Activity of RCS................................................................................................................. 28

Conveyancing practice........................................................................................... 28

Attempted delegation of drafting............................................................................. 29

Stamping, lodging, etc. - whether done as agent for Duncan Sande & Associates.... 33

Personal acts of Mr Sande................................................................................................. 36

Practising as a solicitor or conveyancer................................................................... 36

Drawing or preparing instruments in Queensland..................................................... 40

Conclusions................................................................................................................................. 46

This is a motion to commit Mr Sande to prison for contempt…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Queensland Law Soc Inc & Anor v PA Sande and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1997] QSC 57
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This is a motion to commit Mr Sande to prison for contempt by reason of his breach of an order of the court made on 5 June 1995. The order restrained Mr Sande from directly or indirectly acting or practising in Queensland as a solicitor or conveyancer without a certificate and from directly or indirectly, for expectation of fee gain or reward, drawing or preparing a conveyance or other deed or instrument in writing relating to real estate, in the State of Queensland. The notice of motion cites fourteen particular instances of breaches of each part of the order, referring to certain services and activity performed for fourteen named persons. Mr Sande is not qualified as a solicitor and has never held a certificate authorising him to practise in Queensland either as a solicitor or a conveyancer. Property Pack has no relevant certificate, and indeed a corporation cannot be issued with a certificate in Queensland. Apart from Mr Sande, no person employed by or associated with Property Pack or Realty Conveyancing Services (RCS) has any relevant qualification or expertise to be able to operate personally as a conveyancer or as a solicitor. Mr Sande is the person who has conceived the scheme of operation and has caused the company to act in this way. He is also the manager and principal employee who decides when to act and when not to act and who gives advice to clients when it seems expedient or necessary to do so. On some occasions however Mr Sande has identified legal problems beyond the capacity of the limited services he considers it appropriate to render, and has on such occasions referred matters to solicitors to deal with. I am satisfied to the necessary standard that on the fourteen instances contained in subparagraphs (a) to (n) of the notice of motion Mr Sande did directly or indirectly act and practise both as a solicitor and a conveyancer without having at the time a certificate referred to in s.38 of the Queensland Law Society Act 1952. I am also satisfied to the necessary standard with respect to subparagraphs (q), (v), (w) and (aa) of the notice of motion that Mr Sande did directly or indirectly draw or prepare an instrument in writing relating to real estate in the State of Queensland on behalf of the various persons named in those particulars when he was not at the time lawfully issued with a certificate by the secretary of the Queensland Law Society Incorporated. There will be a finding that Mr Sande has been guilty of contempt of Court with respect to the particulars mentioned.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established