Queensland College of Teachers v Smith

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read

CITATION:

Queensland College of Teachers v Smith [2015] QCAT 426

PARTIES: Queensland College of Teachers
(Applicant)
v
John Smith
(Respondent)
APPLICATION NUMBER: OCR212 -14
MATTER TYPE: Occupational regulation matters
HEARING DATE: 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 25 May and 28 September 2015
HEARD AT: Brisbane
DECISION OF: Senior Member Stilgoe OAM
Member Rogers
Member MacDonald
DELIVERED ON: 30 October 2015
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
ORDERS MADE:

1.    The referral by Queensland College of Teachers is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

OCCUPTATIONAL REGULATION – TEACHERS – where teacher took students on private excursions – where teacher bought food and favours for students – where teacher organised sleepover at his home for students without another adult present – whether teacher unsuitable to teach

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) ss 28, 66(2)(e), 99
Education (College of Teachers) Act 2005 (Qld) ss 49, 92(1)(h)

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336
Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298
Shahinper v Psychology Board of Australia [2013] QCAT 593
Psychology Board of Australia v Germain [2014] QCAT 202

APPEARANCES:

APPLICANT: A J Kimmins of Counsel instructed by McInnes Wilson
RESPONDENT: M Spry of Counsel instructed by Cooper Grace Ward

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. Earlier this decade, John Smith[1] was the principal of a rural primary school. Many of the students at the school came from disadvantaged families. Mr Smith developed a practice of giving students extra-curricular attention, in the form of shopping trips, fast food treats, opportunities for volunteer and paid work and the like.

    [1]Not his real name.

  2. Some teachers at the school formed the view that a core group of about six boys benefited most from Mr Smith’s activities. They were concerned that Mr Smith’s activities were inappropriate so they made a complaint to the Department of Education and Training. After investigation, the Queensland College of Teachers referred him to the tribunal for disciplinary action.

The grounds for disciplinary action

  1. The tribunal may discipline a teacher if it considers the teacher is not suitable to teach under s 92(1)(h) of the Education (Queensland College of Teachers) Act 2005 (Qld).

  2. The College grounds for disciplinary action are framed this way. Firstly, the College submits that pursuant to s 92(1)(h) of the Act, Mr Smith is not suitable to teach in that his registration is liable to be suspended under s 49. As a subparagraph of that submission, the College submits that between two dates, Mr Smith was performing his duties but that contrary to his duties he:

    a)    Failed to maintain appropriate professional boundaries with students under his care and control who were all in Year 7; and/or

    b)    Failed to maintain objective and impartial levels of disciplinary standards for students under his care  and control who were all in Year 7; and/or

    c)    Failed to address appropriately concerns within his knowledge in respect of alleged boundary violations with the students under his care and control who were all in Year 7.

  3. The College then set out 35 particulars of behaviour under the heading “PARTICULARS OF…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Queensland College of Teachers v Smith and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] QCAT 426
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Queensland College of Teachers v Smith, the College sought to have the teacher's registration suspended on the basis that his conduct made him unsuitable to teach. The dispute was heard by the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal, which was required to determine whether the teacher's actions warranted suspension of his registration under the relevant legislation. The teacher, Mr Smith, had been accused of failing to maintain appropriate professional boundaries with students, including taking them on private excursions, buying them food and treats, and organising a sleepover at his home where no other adults were present.

The legal issues the court needed to decide included whether Mr Smith's conduct constituted a breach of the professional standards required of teachers, and whether such breaches rendered him unsuitable to teach. The court found that Mr Smith had indeed failed to maintain appropriate professional boundaries, but noted that the particulars of the case did not address his relationship with his staff. The evidence did, however, establish that teachers did not feel comfortable raising concerns about Mr Smith's treatment of students, suggesting that he had failed to create an atmosphere of trust and mutual respect. The court also found that while Mr Smith's behaviour exhibited some indicators of grooming, there was insufficient evidence to substantiate a finding of grooming, and no evidence of any sexualised conduct.

The tribunal ultimately decided that the College's referral should be dismissed. Although Mr Smith's conduct was inappropriate, the findings and decision were constrained by the grounds for disciplinary action outlined in the application for referral. The tribunal found that, while Mr Smith's conduct rendered him unsuitable to teach, the evidence did not support a finding that his conduct amounted to a breach of the professional standards required of teachers. The tribunal's decision was therefore to dismiss the referral by the Queensland College of Teachers.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The referral by Queensland College of Teachers is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Although the particulars do not address Mr Smith’s relationship with his staff, we wish to make some comment. The evidence establishes that Mr Smith created an atmosphere in which teachers did not feel comfortable raising their concerns about Mr Smith’s treatment of the boys. They felt intimidated and, in every case, thought that Mr Smith held the key to their continued advancement through the profession and would use that key to stifle complaints. Whether or not their fears were justified is not the point. A Principal, though his actions, sets the standard and the tone for the way a school operates. Mr Smith evidently failed to create the necessary atmosphere of trust and mutual respect.Is Mr Smith unsuitable to teach in that his registration to teach is liable to be suspended under s 49 of the Act? We have found that Mr Smith failed to maintain appropriate professional boundaries with students. We have found that he failed to maintain objective and impartial levels of disciplinary standards for students. We have found that he failed to appropriately address concerns within his knowledge in respect of alleged boundary violations. We have found that he failed to recognise concerns in respect of alleged boundary violations in circumstances where a prudent Principal would have recognised concerns. We have found that, contrary to the Standard of Practice, Mr Smith friended students on Facebook through his personal Facebook address. We have found that some of Mr Smith’s activities render him unsuitable to teach. Unfortunately for the College, however, our findings, and our decision, are constrained by the grounds for disciplinary action annexed to the application for referral. It is implicit in the way the College framed its case that it suspected Mr Smith was grooming the boys. If the tribunal looks at the indicators of grooming[210], Mr Smith engaged in many of the behaviours. He allowed students to call him by his first name. Students were seen in close proximity with him. There was an unusual frequency of contact. He transported students in his car. He gave students special and differential treatment. He organised a sleepover for selected students. He was a Facebook friend. He bought students treats and rewards, including an expensive helicopter ride. [210]Exhibit 34, DAP-13 pages 172 – 173. The College has not, however, alleged grooming as conduct which made Mr Smith unsuitable to teach. Rather, grooming was a particular of one of three alleged breaches of Mr Smith’s failure as a teacher. When we struck out that particular, there was no remaining allegation of grooming. Even if there had been an allegation of grooming, the evidence could not substantiate a finding to that effect. As the Standard records, grooming is the act of deliberately establishing an emotional connection to lower a child’s inhibitions. Grooming requires intent and we have no evidence of intent. Although the boys acknowledged that they were Mr Smith’s favourites, the evidence tends to suggest that the boys were taking advantage of Mr Smith, rather than Mr Smith grooming them for some later, inappropriate purpose. Even though many opportunities were presented to him, there is no evidence Mr Smith ever touched the boys. They never even saw him without his shirt on, even though they shared rooms with him to and from the school camp[211]. There was no evidence of any sexualisation. Mr Smith was not secret about anything that he did. [211]Transcript page 2-73 at line 5.