Queensland College of Teachers v El-Sayed

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Queensland College of Teachers v El-Sayed [2018] QCAT 320

PARTIES:

QUEENSLAND COLLEGE OF TEACHERS
(applicant)

v

WAEL MOHAMED EL-SAYED

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

OCR074-16

MATTER TYPE:

Occupational regulation matters

DELIVERED ON:

18 September 2018

HEARING DATE:

28 March 2018

DATE OF FINAL SUBMISSION:

14 June 2018

DECISION OF:

Member Howe (Presiding Member)
Member Grigg
Member Olding

ORDERS:

1.   Wael Mohamed El-Sayed’s teacher registration is cancelled.

2.   Wael Mohamed El-Sayed is prohibited indefinitely from reapplying for registration as a teacher or for permission to teach.

CATCHWORDS:

EDUCATION – TRAINING AND REGISTRATION OF TEACHERS – where allegations against teacher acting as carer for intellectually impaired adult complainant – where criminal charges discontinued after complainant passed away – where video recording of interview of complainant in evidence – where allegations corroborated by DNA evidence – whether ground for disciplinary action established – sanction  

Acts Interpretation Act 1954 (Qld), s 20(2)(c)
Education and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2016, s 51(2)
Education (Queensland College of Teachers) Act 2005 (Qld), ss 3(1), 92(1)(h), 158(2), 160(2)(j)
 
D’Arro v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2018] 1 Qd R 204
Queensland College of Teachers v Mr Robert James Napier [2010] QCAT 626
Queensland College of Teachers v TSV [2015] QCAT 186

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

E.J. Houston, Acting Principal Legal Officer, Queensland College of Teachers

Respondent:

Self-represented

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. The Queensland College of Teachers (QCT) has referred to the Tribunal a disciplinary proceeding relating to Mr El-Sayed.

  2. It is alleged that, while engaged as a relief support worker for an intellectually impaired, female adult then 23 years of age (the complainant), Mr El-Sayed felt her breasts, kissed her face and chest, and licked her bottom.

  3. QCT submits that this conduct establishes a ground for disciplinary action under section 92(1)(h) of the Education (Queensland College of Teachers) Act 2005 (Qld) (the Act), namely that:

    (h) the person behaves in a way, whether connected with the teaching profession or otherwise, that does not satisfy the standard of behaviour generally expected of a teacher.

  4. QCT also submits that Mr El-Sayed’s conduct demonstrates that he is not fit to hold teacher registration and that the appropriate sanction is to cancel his registration and to prohibit him from reapplying for registration or permission to teach for an indefinite period.

  5. Mr El-Sayed denies that he engaged in the conduct.

  6. The Tribunal’s task is to determine whether the ground for disciplinary action is established and, if so, the appropriate sanction.

    Background

  7. The complainant resided in a locked facility where the conduct allegedly occurred during Mr El-Sayed’s shift as a relief care worker from 9-00 pm on 5 September 2013 to 7-00 am on 6 September 2013.

  8. Charges were laid against Mr El-Sayed in relation to the alleged conduct. However, the complainant’s evidence was accidentally omitted from material handed up at the committal proceeding and the complainant passed away before the matter could proceed. The criminal proceedings were therefore discontinued.

  9. A member of the Tribunal determined that statements by the complainant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Queensland College of Teachers v El-Sayed and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QCAT 320
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Queensland College of Teachers (QCT) sought to establish disciplinary action against Mr El-Sayed, a registered teacher accused of inappropriate conduct with an intellectually impaired adult resident in a locked facility. The alleged incidents occurred during Mr El-Sayed's shift as a relief care worker. Although criminal charges were laid against Mr El-Sayed, these were discontinued after the complainant passed away. The Tribunal, which had jurisdiction to hear the matter, was required to determine whether the ground for disciplinary action was established and, if so, what the appropriate sanction should be.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the allegations against Mr El-Sayed were substantiated, and whether the DNA evidence, as well as the complainant's recorded statement, were sufficient to establish the ground for disciplinary action. The Tribunal needed to assess the credibility and reliability of the evidence presented, including the complainant's recorded statement and the DNA evidence, while also considering Mr El-Sayed's alternative explanations for the presence of his DNA on the complainant's underpants.

The Tribunal found that the ground for disciplinary action was substantiated. The Tribunal was comfortably satisfied that Mr El-Sayed's DNA was found in the complainant's underpants, which corroborated the complainant's recorded statement. Although Mr El-Sayed offered an alternative explanation for the presence of his DNA, the Tribunal found this explanation to be implausible and not supported by the evidence. The Tribunal also considered the serious nature of the allegations and the consequences for Mr El-Sayed, and concluded that the ground for disciplinary action was established.

The Tribunal ordered that Mr El-Sayed's teacher registration be cancelled and that he be prohibited indefinitely from reapplying for registration as a teacher or for permission to teach.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Wael Mohamed El-Sayed’s teacher registration is cancelled.

2. Wael Mohamed El-Sayed is prohibited indefinitely from reapplying for registration as a teacher or for permission to teach.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Tribunal’s task is to determine whether the ground for disciplinary action is established and, if so, the appropriate sanction.Background The complainant resided in a locked facility where the conduct allegedly occurred during Mr El-Sayed’s shift as a relief care worker from 9-00 pm on 5 September 2013 to 7-00 am on 6 September 2013. Charges were laid against Mr El-Sayed in relation to the alleged conduct. However, the complainant’s evidence was accidentally omitted from material handed up at the committal proceeding and the complainant passed away before the matter could proceed. The criminal proceedings were therefore discontinued. A member of the Tribunal determined that statements by the complainant to the police before the charges were laid, in the form of video recordings and transcripts of police records of interview, were admissible as evidence in this proceeding, along with statements of Ms Joanne Drake and Ms Cindy Tyson, respectively a youth worker and primary carer for the complainant. The Tribunal in the current proceeding therefore had the benefit of viewing an audio-visual recording of the complainant’s statement to the police. Additionally, there is evidence of Mr El-Sayed’s DNA being found in underpants worn by the complainant during the evening the conduct is alleged to have occurred. Mr El-Sayed also offers an alternative explanation that the DNA came to be found on the underpants, suggesting that he must have sneezed or coughed when folding the complainant’s clothes.The complainant’s statement The complainant’s recorded statement included a number of allegations, which are recorded in this exchange with the interviewing police officer, Plain Clothes Senior Constable Krystal Martyn:[COMPLAINANT]: And uhm, at first he kept saying, ah you could be my girlfriend and I go, no, I’m too young for you. He goes, no there’s famous people have older boyfriends and all.KM: Mmmhmm[COMPLAINANT]: And yeah, he just keep harassing me and then uhm, I was showing him pictures on my camera and he saw a photo of my tattoo and it’s down my back and uhm, he said show me and I showed him but, UI, then he said, ah do you have any other tattoo’s (sic).KM: Mmmhmm[COMPLAINANT]: I go yes. Am I talking too fast?KM: No, that’s fine.[COMPLAINANT]: I said, yes and and I showed him where it was and he pulled my shirt down a bit but then he goes, ah take your shirt off.KM: Mmmhmm[COMPLAINANT]: I took it off, that was rude but then, I went to bed and uhm, I got up UI half an hour later and I had to go to the toilet. And I went back in, in the office to ask if he could tuck me back in bed. And he came in and laid right next to me.KM: MmmhmmAnd he started feeling my boobs. And uhm, then I don’t know if he got bit down, like he turned around or what everKM: Mmmhmm[COMPLAINANT]: He uhm, licked me inside my bumKM: Mmmhmm[COMPLAINANT]: And then, I said, don’t do that. And uhm, then he goes, oh will it be better if I lick you down below? I said no.KM: Mmmhmm and then what happened?[COMPLAINANT]: Well he went out because I said I want to go to sleep.KM: Mmmhmm. Then what happened after that?[COMPLAINANT]: Nothing. He didn’t come in.KM: Ok. What happened the next morning?[COMPLAINANT]: Well I uhm, my other career (sic) said, oh why are you so tired. And I said, well something happened. UI And she uhm, was wondering what UI happened cause I didn’t want to say what happened cause he said, don’t tell anybody. And yeah uhm, I was scared if he came back he would abuse me. So uhm, yeah, I didn’t tell her but then I went out outside and my UI, the boss that’s here, uhm she came to and I said. I just had to tell her.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

He emphasised that, having regard to previous violent outbursts, his whole strategy was to try to keep the complainant calm and avoid triggers that might lead to such behaviours.The DNA evidenceNature of the evidence The complainant’s pyjama pants and underpants were tested. Saliva, but no DNA, was found on the pyjama pants. The inside front and back surfaces of the underpants were screened for saliva. An area on the inside back of the underpants, measuring approximately 65mm by 60mm, tested positive. A sample prepared from this positive area was submitted for DNA analysis and Mr El-Sayad accepts, as do we, that his DNA was found to be present. QTC submits that this corroborates the complainant’s recorded statement.Mr El-Sayed’s alternative hypothesis Mr El-Sayed gave evidence that he was suffering from the flu and submitted that the DNA must have become present on the underpants due to him sneezing on the underpants when he was folding some clothes. He also suggests that the complainant must have changed her underwear during the night as she was capable of doing. The forensic scientist who provided the DNA report, Ms Patricia Anne Finch, was asked to provide a report regarding whether DNA contamination could have occurred by Mr El-Sayed sneezing near the underwear or by touching the underwear. Ms Finch’s report was to the effect that both propositions are possible, but she was unable to distinguish between these, and transfer via saliva, as the most likely cause of the transfer of the DNA to the underpants. We take this to mean that Ms Finch was unable to make this distinction based on the scientific analysis, as Ms Finch was obviously unable to assess the broader evidence of Mr El-Sayed, the complainant and other witnesses. Mr El-Sayed also sought to attack what he submitted to be inconsistent evidence regarding the washing of the complainant’s bed linen, which occurred before the police arrived. However, the evidence of Ms Drake, which we accept in the absence of any contrary evidence, was that the clothing the complainant was wearing was not washed. The scientific evidence establishes that it is scientifically possible that Mr El-Sayed’s hypothesis occurred. It provides no assistance in determining the probability that Mr El-Sayed’s DNA came to be present in the complainant’s underwear. Mr El-Sayed also submitted that, if the complaint were true, his DNA should have been found elsewhere. However, there was no testing of other clothing or bedding other than the pyjama pants on which saliva but not DNA was found.The ground is substantiated Although the standard of proof for criminal matters (beyond reasonable doubt) does not apply, having regard to the serious nature of the allegations and the consequences for Mr El-Sayed, we should not find the allegations substantiated unless comfortably satisfied on the basis of direct evidence to that effect.[2] For the reasons that follow, we are so satisfied.[2]Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established