Queensland Building and Construction Commission v Russell

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read
CITATION: Queensland Building and Construction Commission v Russell [2015] QCATA 57
PARTIES: Queensland Building and Construction Commission
(Applicant/Appellant)
v
Cedric Ernest Russell
(Respondent)
APPLICATION NUMBER: APL182-14
MATTER TYPE: Appeals
HEARING DATE: On the papers
HEARD AT: Brisbane
DECISION OF: Senior Member O’Callaghan
Member Paratz
DELIVERED ON: 1 May 2015
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
ORDERS MADE: 1.    The application for leave to appeal and appeal is dismissed.
CATCHWORDS:

BUILDING DISPUTE – DIRECTIONS TO RECTIFY – where the Tribunal accepted the evidence of the builder over that of expert witnesses – when the Appeal Tribunal will interfere with findings of fact by the Tribunal – whether it is reasonable to order rectification by a builder – where a home-owner had not completed landscaping works, or conducted reasonable ongoing maintenance – when the Appeal Tribunal will interfere with an exercise of discretion

Queensland Building Services Authority Act 1991 (Qld), s 72
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 142

House v R (1936) 55 CLR 499
Cachia v Grech [2009] NSWCA 232
Chambers v Jobling (1986) 7 NSWLR 1
Dearman v Dearman (1908) 7 CLR 549
Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118
Glenwood Properties Pty Ltd v Delmoss Pty Ltd [1986] 2 Qd R 388
JM Kelly (Project Builders) Pty Ltd v Queensland Building Services Authority [2013] QCAT 502
McIver Bulk Liquid Haulage Pty Ltd v Fruehauf Australia Pty Ltd [1989] 2 Qd R 577
QUYD Pty Ltd v Marvass Pty Ltd [2009] 1 Qd R 41

APPEARANCES:

This matter was heard and determined on the papers pursuant to s 32 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) (QCAT Act).

REPRESENTATIVES:

APPLICANT: Queensland Building and Construction Commission represented by Mr G.I. Thomson of Counsel
RESPONDENT: Cedric Ernest Russell represented by Shand Taylor Lawyers

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. Cedric Russell built a house in 2006 for a couple who subsequently separated. A complaint was made many years later to the QBCC by Sharon Taylor, the owner who remained in the house. The QBCC issued a Direction to Rectify defective building work, on 6 July 2011, to Mr Russell (‘the First Decision’).

  2. Mr Russell filed an application seeking a review of the decision. An agreement was reached at a compulsory conference that Mr Russell would perform work at the house (‘the Compromise Agreement’). Mr Russell subsequently performed rectification works.

  3. The QBCC considered that the rectification works were unsatisfactory. It gave Mr Russell notice to that effect dated 6 December 2012 (‘the Second Decision’). Mr Russell then filed a further application seeking a Review of that decision.

  4. Both applications were heard together.

  5. The evidence at the hearing at first instance revealed that there were difficult site issues, and responsibility issues involved in the construction of the house. The site is on the side of a hill. Extensive excavations were conducted to cut a house pad level at the front with the road. This resulted in the site being bounded on three sides by high earth faces. The owners intended to do much…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Queensland Building and Construction Commission v Russell and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] QCATA 57
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Queensland Building and Construction Commission (QBCC) appealed against decisions of the Building Adjudication Tribunal (Tribunal) regarding rectification of a retaining wall and the interpretation of a compromise agreement. The Tribunal had found that the left-hand side (LHS) retaining wall of a garage was defective but declined to direct the builder to rectify it, whereas the right-hand side (RHS) retaining wall was not defective. The QBCC contended that the Tribunal should have directed rectification of the LHS retaining wall and that it had erred in its consideration of the compromise agreement.

The legal issues before the court included whether the Tribunal erred in not directing rectification of the LHS retaining wall, whether it erred in finding certain works were not defective, and whether it erred in the exercise of its discretion to refuse to order rectification of the works found defective. Additionally, the court considered whether the learned Tribunal Member erred in his consideration of the compromise agreement and whether the Tribunal erred in setting aside the QBCC’s decision that the rectification works were not satisfactory.

The court found that the learned Member was not in error in not directing rectification of the RHS retaining wall because there was no evidence to suggest that the reference to RHS in the direction was erroneous. Furthermore, even if it were to assume that the reference to RHS was mistaken, the Tribunal was not required to substitute its own decision to direct rectification. The court held that the learned Member was entitled to make his own findings of fact and exercise his own discretion in relation to the direction to rectify. Regarding the compromise agreement, the court found that the learned Member did not err in his consideration of it. Consequently, the court dismissed the appeal and affirmed the decisions of the Tribunal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for leave to appeal and appeal is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The issues in this Appeal are:· The First Decisiona) Did the Tribunal err in not directing rectification of the LHS retaining wall?b) Did the Tribunal err in finding certain works were not defective?c) Did the Tribunal err in the exercise its discretion to refuse to order rectification of the works it found defective?· The Second Decisiond) Did the learned Tribunal Member err in his consideration of the Compromise Agreement?e) Did the Tribunal err in setting aside the QBCC’s decision that the rectification works undertaken at the direction of the QBCC were not satisfactory? A Direction to Rectify dated 9 June 2011 was issued referring to the structural failure of the block retaining wall located on the LHS of the lower garage. This Direction was withdrawn and substituted with a further Direction dated 6 July 2011 specifying that the RHS retaining wall of the garage had failed. It was found by the learned Member that the LHS retaining wall had failed and that RHS retaining wall was not defective. The learned Member found that even though Mr Russell had carried out defective building work in not obtaining engineering design and approval for the construction of the LHS retaining wall, he would not confirm the decision to direct rectification of the retaining wall because the direction referred to the RHS wall and that side of the wall was not defective. The QBCC say that the learned Member erred and should have directed rectification of the LHS wall on two bases:a) The learned Member should have concluded that the reference to RHS was erroneous and was in fact a reference to the LHS wall. It says the evidence was against the finding of the learned Member that the change to RHS was purposive. It submits he should have found that the reference to RHS in the direction was erroneous and conclude that in those circumstances the direction to rectify should be confirmed. We accept that it is the LHS retaining wall which has failed. We do not consider however that the learned Member made an error in finding that he could not confirm a direction to rectify which referred to the rectification of the RHS retaining wall which all parties accepted was not defective. It is not clear why the change was made from LHS to the RHS. In circumstances however where there was a repeated reference to the RHS in the QBCC statement of reasons and no submission was made to the Tribunal that it should find that the reference to the RHS was simply a mistake, there is no error in the learned Member’s finding that he could not confirm that aspect of the direction to rectify.b) The QBCC say that even if it was not open to the learned Member to substitute RHS for LHS, he erred in not considering whether he should substitute his own decision to direct rectification of the LHS. The QBCC points out that the issue of the defects in the LHS wall had been brought to the attention of the decision-maker prior to the decision to issue the direction to rectify. It says therefore the Tribunal standing in the shoes of the decision-maker on a fresh hearing on the merits, and on finding that the LHS wall was in fact defective, should have substituted a decision that rectification be directed of the LHS retaining wall.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.