Qube Ports Pty Ltd v Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator)

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:  

QUBE Ports Pty Ltd v Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator) [2015] QIRC 144

PARTIES:  

QUBE Ports Pty Ltd
(Appellant)

v

Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator)
(Respondent)

CASE NO:

WC/2014/203

PROCEEDING:

Appeal against decision of the Workers' Compensation Regulator

DELIVERED ON:

4 August 2015

HEARING DATES: 

16 - 17 October 2014 (hearing)
16 December 2014 (Appellant's submissions)
5 February 2015 (Respondent's submissions)

MEMBER:

Industrial Commissioner Knight

ORDERS   :

1.      The Appeal is allowed;

2.      The decision of the Regulator dated 11 June 2014 is set aside;

3.      The claim is not one for acceptance;

4.      The Regulator is to pay the Appellant's costs of and incidental to the Appeal. In the event agreement cannot be reached between the parties with respect to costs, the Appellant has the liberty to apply

CATCHWORDS: WORKERS' COMPENSATION - APPEAL AGAINST DECISION - whether injury arose out of or in the course of employment - whether employment a significant contributing factor to the injury – previous history of left knee pain and symptoms not disclosed to WorkCover and treating specialist – whether the worker’s account of this incident at work is credible - the Appellant bears onus of proof - standard of proof – the Appeal is allowed.

CASES:

Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation  Act 2003 s 32

Croning v Workers’ Compensation Board of Queensland (1997) 156 QGIG 100

Heald v Q-COMP (2004) 177 QGIG 769

JBS Australia Pty Ltd and Q-COMP (C/2012/35) – Decision < qirc. qld. gov. au>

Kudryavtseva v Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator) [2015] QIRC 053

Momcilovic v R (2011) 254 CLR 1

Newberry v Suncorp Metway Insurance Ltd [2006] QCA 48.

Pollock v Wellington (1996) 15 WAR 1

APPEARANCES:

Mr C. Clark instructed by Sparke Helmore Lawyers for the Appellant.

Ms. D. Callaghan directly instructed for Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator).

Decision

  1. This is an appeal by QUBE Ports Pty Ltd ("the Appellant") pursuant to s 550 of the Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 ("the Act") against the decision of Simon Blackwood (Workers Compensation Regulator) ("the Respondent" / "the Regulator").

  1. The decision by the Regulator overturned an initial decision by WorkCover rejecting Mr Williams' claim for compensation by Mr Brian John Williams ("the Worker"/ "the Claimant") in respect of an alleged injury to his left knee sustained on 27 March 2014 when he climbed up onto a trailer, pushed off with his left leg and felt his left knee move "sideways a bit and felt a pop and severe pain". The Regulator's decision was that the worker had provided sufficient evidence to support his claim that had an "L medial knee ligament tear and meniscal tear", that the injury arose out of his employment with QUBE Ports Pty Ltd and the employment was a significant contributing factor to the injury.

Grounds of Appeal

  1. The grounds of Appeal upon which the Appellant relies are as follows:

    (a)Mr Williams did not sustain any injury at work on 27 March 2014 within the application of the Workers' Compensations…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Qube Ports Pty Ltd v Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] QIRC 144
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission was an appeal by Qube Ports Pty Ltd against a decision made by the Workers' Compensation Regulator, Simon Blackwood. The dispute centred on whether the injury sustained by Mr Williams, an employee of Qube Ports, arose out of or in the course of his employment, and if the employment was a significant contributing factor to the injury. Mr Williams claimed that he injured his left knee while performing his duties as a tug operator on 27 March 2014. The Regulator had previously determined that the claim was not valid as the injury did not arise out of or in the course of employment.

The court was required to decide whether the employer had discharged the onus of proving that the injury was not work-related, and whether the worker's account of the incident was credible. The employer argued that Mr Williams had a previous history of left knee pain and symptoms which he did not disclose to WorkCover and his treating specialist. The employer contended that the injury was an aggravation of a pre-existing condition and not caused by the incident at work. The employer also argued that the standard of proof required for the worker to establish causation was not met.

In allowing the appeal, the Commission found that the employer had discharged the onus of proof. The Commission considered the evidence of Dr Brosnan, an Orthopaedic Surgeon, who stated that the injury suffered by Mr Williams constituted an aggravation of a pre-existing condition. The Commission accepted that Mr Williams had a previous history of left knee pain and symptoms which he did not disclose to WorkCover and his treating specialist. The Commission found that Mr Williams' account of the incident at work was not credible, and that the injury was not caused by the incident. The Commission set aside the decision of the Regulator and determined that the claim was not valid. The employer was ordered to pay the costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Appeal is allowed;

2. The decision of the Regulator dated 11 June 2014 is set aside;

3. The claim is not one for acceptance;

4. The Regulator is to pay the Appellant's costs of and incidental to the Appeal. In the event agreement cannot be reached between the parties with respect to costs, the Appellant has the liberty to apply

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Dr Brosnan is an Orthopaedic Surgeon. Dr Brosnan saw Mr Williams on 2 or 3 April 2014. The MRI scan of 2 April 2014 had shown a Grade 1 to 2 ligamentous injury of the medial collateral ligament in addition to a tear of the medial meniscus. He stated that between the two scans (19 March and 2 April 2014) something had occurred which resulted in Mr Williams' acute injury and the latter scan showed that the tear had become enlarged. His view was that the injury suffered by Mr Williams constituted an aggravation of a pre-existing condition.The EvidenceBackground to Mr Williams' claim Mr Williams is 45 years of age and has worked for the employer since 2004 undertaking the duties of operating machinery, including bulldozers, cranes and crane operations.The evidence On 27 March 2014, Mr Williams' duties for the day involved working as a tug operator unloading "roll on roll off" cargo from a ship. Also on duty that day were Mr Chambers and Mr Brady. Mr William's evidence is that he made a decision to unlash a boat from a MAFI trailer. He said he walked up to the side of the MAFI trailer. He recalled the boat had a black handle on the back of it. He said he proceeded to grab the handle and put his left knee up to the side of the MAFI trailer. Mr Williams said he pushed with his right leg and pulled with his hand and then he felt a sharp pain and a 'pop' and severe pain after this. He recalled hobbling around and unlashing the boat. He waited for the forklift and then got in a truck to go back to the deck of the ship to do another load. Once he got there he realized he couldn't put any weight on the left leg and it was at this point that he said he reported his injury to Gerry Brady. After this, he recalled Steve Chambers came and picked him up.[6] [6] Transcript of proceedings, QUBE Ports Pty Ltd v Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator) (Queensland Industrial Relations Commission, WC/2014/203, 17 October 2014) 28-29 (B. J. Williams). Mr Chambers' evidence was that someone had told him that between 7:00 and 9:30 am on 27 March 2014 Mr Williams had injured his knee. Mr Williams' evidence was that he advised Mr Brady of the incident and he had called Mr Chambers who came and picked Mr Williams up from the ship deck in his work utility. Mr Chambers' evidence was that Mr Williams had injured his left knee when attempting to climb up on to a Maffi trailer. Mr Williams had told him that when his bodyweight was placed on his left leg, he felt his knee pop. He also said that he had all his weight on his left leg when twisting and he then felt his knee pop. Mr Williams said this information had been given to Mr Christie who had recorded it on a piece of paper which he told the Commission he subsequently discarded as that information was then recorded electronically by the employer. Mr Williams said he had not told Mr Christie that Mr Brady had witnessed the incident and that Mr Williams had reported the matter to Mr Chambers. Although this had been written in the Incident Report by Mr Christie, that issue was not directly put to Mr Williams in cross-examination.