Quach v Health Care Complaints Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Quach v Health Care Complaints Commission [2016] NSWCA 49
Hearing dates:9 March 2016
Decision date: 21 March 2016
Before: Meagher JA
Decision:

1.   Paragraph 3 of Mr Quach’s notice of motion filed 21 October 2015 dismissed.
2.   Mr Quach’s notice of motion filed 28 January 2016 dismissed.
3.   Mr Quach’s notice of motion filed 1 March 2016 dismissed.
4.   Order that the copy of Mr Quach’s amended notice of motion stamped ‘received’ by the Court on 16 February 2016 not be accepted for filing.
5.   Order Mr Quach pay the costs of the applications in orders 1, 2, 3 and 4 above.
6.   Set aside Mr Quach’s notice to produce filed 22 February 2016.
7.   Otherwise dismiss the Commission’s notice of motion filed 4 March 2016.
8.   Direct the Registrar, should Mr Quach file any further notice of motion in these proceedings (other than an application seeking a review of this decision), to vacate the return date of that motion, notify the parties and refer the papers to a judge nominated by the President to determine, in chambers, whether the Court should fix a new return date and notify the parties of that date, or whether Mr Quach should be invited to show cause in writing why the Court should not in chambers summarily dismiss the application as vexatious and an abuse of process.
9.   Order Mr Quach pay the Commission’s costs of its motions filed 22 February 2016 and 4 March 2016.

Catchwords:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – notices of motion seeking judicial review – where Court of Appeal has dismissed amended summons in underlying proceeding – where present applications not commenced by separate summons – where maker of decision to be reviewed not joined as party – motions dismissed

PROCEDURE – whether Court should make orders in terms of Teoh v Hunters Hill Council (No 4) [2011] NSWCA 324
Legislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), s 61(2)(c)
Health Care Complaints Act 1993 (NSW), ss 90A, 90D
Health Practitioner Regulation Amendment Act 1992 (NSW), Sch 3
Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (NSW), ss 158, 158A, 161
Interpretation Act 1987 (NSW), s 30
Judicial Officers Act 1986 (NSW), s 18
Medical Practice Act 1992 (NSW), ss 17, 129
Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW), ss 46, 48, 69
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005, rr 4.10, 6.4, 36.16, 36.17, 51.45
Cases Cited: Quach v Health Care Complaints Commission [2015] NSWCA 187
Quach v New South Wales Health Care Complaints Commission [2016] NSWCA 10
Quach v New South Wales Civil and Administrative Tribunal [2015] NSWCA 63
Teoh v Hunters Hill Council (No 4) [2011] NSWCA 324; 81 NSWLR 771
Category:Procedural and other rulings
Parties: Michael Van Thanh Quach (Applicant)
Health Care Complaints Commission (First Respondent)
New South Wales Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Second Respondent)
Representation:

Counsel:
K Richardson (First Respondent)

 

Solicitors:
Health Care Complaints Commission (First Respondent)

  Michael Quach (Applicant) (in person)
File Number(s):2015/158685
Publication restriction:Nil

Judgment

  1. MEAGHER…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Quach v Health Care Complaints Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NSWCA 49
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The proceedings involved Mr Quach seeking judicial review of a decision made by the Health Care Complaints Commission. The applications were brought by way of notices of motion, rather than a separate summons, and the decision-maker was not joined as a party. The Court of Appeal considered these applications in light of the dismissal of the underlying proceeding by the Court.

The primary legal issues before the Court were whether the applications for judicial review had been properly commenced and whether the Court should make orders in terms of the principles established in *Teoh v Hunters Hill Council (No 4)* [2011] NSWCA 324. The Court also had to determine the appropriate course of action regarding the various notices of motion filed by Mr Quach and a notice to produce.

Meagher JA dismissed Mr Quach's notices of motion filed on 21 October 2015, 28 January 2016, and 1 March 2016. The Court further ordered that a copy of Mr Quach’s amended notice of motion, stamped ‘received’ on 16 February 2016, not be accepted for filing. The Court also set aside Mr Quach’s notice to produce filed on 22 February 2016 and otherwise dismissed the Commission’s notice of motion filed on 4 March 2016. Mr Quach was ordered to pay the costs of these applications. Additionally, the Registrar was directed to take specific steps regarding any future notices of motion filed by Mr Quach, including vacating return dates and referring papers to a judge to determine whether to fix a new date or invite Mr Quach to show cause why the application should not be summarily dismissed as vexatious and an abuse of process.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Paragraph 3 of Mr Quach’s notice of motion filed 21 October 2015 dismissed.

2. Mr Quach’s notice of motion filed 28 January 2016 dismissed.

3. Mr Quach’s notice of motion filed 1 March 2016 dismissed.

4. Order that the copy of Mr Quach’s amended notice of motion stamped ‘received’ by the Court on 16 February 2016 not be accepted for filing.

5. Order Mr Quach pay the costs of the applications in orders 1, 2, 3 and 4 above.

6. Set aside Mr Quach’s notice to produce filed 22 February 2016.

7. Otherwise dismiss the Commission’s notice of motion filed 4 March 2016.

8. Direct the Registrar, should Mr Quach file any further notice of motion in these proceedings (other than an application seeking a review of this decision), to vacate the return date of that motion, notify the parties and refer the papers to a judge nominated by the President to determine, in chambers, whether the Court should fix a new return date and notify the parties of that date, or whether Mr Quach should be invited to show cause in writing why the Court should not in chambers summarily dismiss the application as vexatious and an abuse of process.

9. Order Mr Quach pay the Commission’s costs of its motions filed 22 February 2016 and 4 March 2016.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Quach v Health Care Complaints Commission pertains to a series of motions filed by Mr Quach seeking judicial review of a decision made by the Health Care Complaints Commission (the Commission). The proceedings began with Mr Quach filing a notice of motion on 21 October 2015, followed by another on 28 January 2016, and a third on 1 March 2016. Additionally, Mr Quach filed an amended notice of motion on 16 February 2016 and a notice to produce on 22 February 2016. The Commission responded by filing its own notice of motion on 4 March 2016.

The Court of Appeal had previously dismissed an amended summons in the underlying proceeding, and Mr Quach did not commence the present applications by separate summons. Furthermore, the maker of the decision to be reviewed was not joined as a party in the proceedings. Mr Quach’s initial applications, filed on 21 October 2015, 28 January 2016, and 1 March 2016, were dismissed by the Court. The Court also refused to accept the amended notice of motion stamped as received on 16 February 2016. Moreover, the Court set aside Mr Quach’s notice to produce dated 22 February 2016 and dismissed the Commission’s notice of motion filed on 4 March 2016.

The Court directed the Registrar to vacate the return date of any further notice of motion filed by Mr Quach, other than an application seeking a review of the Court’s decision. If such a notice was filed, the Registrar was to notify the parties and refer the papers to a judge nominated by the President. This judge was to determine whether a new return date should be fixed and the parties notified of it or if Mr Quach should be invited to show cause in writing why the Court should not summarily dismiss the application as vexatious and an abuse of process. The Court also ordered Mr Quach to pay the costs of the applications and the Commission’s motions.

The case of Quach v Health Care Complaints Commission involves a series of applications for judicial review filed by Mr Quach against the Health Care Complaints Commission. The primary procedural issue in this matter is the handling of Mr Quach's multiple applications for judicial review in the context of an earlier appeal by the Court of Appeal, which dismissed an amended summons in the underlying proceeding. The current applications were not initiated by separate summons, and the maker of the decision to be reviewed was not joined as a party. The Court of Appeal's earlier decision formed a significant backdrop to the procedural steps taken in this matter.

Mr Quach filed several notices of motion seeking judicial review, with the first being filed on 21 October 2015, followed by others on 28 January 2016, 1 March 2016, and an amended notice of motion on 16 February 2016. In response, the Commission filed its own notices of motion on 22 February 2016 and 4 March 2016. The Court issued several orders dismissing Mr Quach's applications and setting aside his notice to produce. It also directed the Registrar to take specific actions should Mr Quach file further motions, including the potential summary dismissal of such applications as vexatious and an abuse of process. The Court also ordered Mr Quach to pay costs associated with both his applications and the Commission's motions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Court should make orders in terms of Teoh v Hunters Hill Council (No 4) [2011] NSWCA 324.
2. Whether the Court should dismiss Mr Quach’s notices of motion filed on 21 October 2015, 28 January 2016, and 1 March 2016.
3. Whether the Court should refuse to accept for filing Mr Quach’s amended notice of motion stamped ‘received’ on 16 February 2016.
4. Whether the Court should set aside Mr Quach’s notice to produce filed on 22 February 2016.
5. Whether the Court should otherwise dismiss the Commission’s notice of motion filed on 4 March 2016.
6. Whether the Court should direct the Registrar to vacate the return date of any further notices of motion filed by Mr Quach and refer the matter to a judge to determine if a new return date should be set or if Mr Quach should be invited to show cause why his application should not be summarily dismissed as vexatious and an abuse of process.

Held
1. The Court concluded that it should not make orders in terms of Teoh v Hunters Hill Council (No 4) [2011] NSWCA 324; application dismissed.
2. The Court concluded that Mr Quach’s notices of motion filed on 21 October 2015, 28 January 2016, and 1 March 2016 should be dismissed.
3. The Court concluded that it should refuse to accept for filing Mr Quach’s amended notice of motion stamped ‘received’ on 16 February 2016.
4. The Court concluded that it should set aside Mr Quach’s notice to produce filed on 22 February 2016.
5. The Court concluded that it should otherwise dismiss the Commission’s notice of motion filed on 4 March 2016.
6. The Court concluded that it should direct the Registrar to vacate the return date of any further notices of motion filed by Mr Quach and refer the matter to a judge to determine if a new return date should be set or if Mr Quach should be invited to show cause why his application should not be summarily dismissed as vexatious and an abuse of process.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Quach v Health Care Complaints Commission, the court dealt with a series of procedural issues related to the conduct of Mr Quach in his applications for judicial review. The first significant issue considered by the court was whether it should make orders in accordance with the principles set out in Teoh v Hunters Hill Council (No 4). The court declined to do so, noting that the present applications were not initiated by separate summons as required by the principles in Teoh. This distinction was crucial as it established that the procedural framework provided in Teoh was not applicable to the unique circumstances of Mr Quach’s applications.

Further, the court examined whether it should dismiss Mr Quach’s notices of motion filed on 21 October 2015, 28 January 2016, and 1 March 2016. The court found these motions to be without merit and dismissed them. The dismissal was premised on the procedural irregularities and the fact that Mr Quach had not joined the maker of the decision to be reviewed as a party to the proceedings. This decision adhered to the legal principle that proper parties must be before the court to ensure just adjudication, a principle underscored in various judicial review cases.

The court also ruled on whether it should refuse to accept for filing Mr Quach’s amended notice of motion stamped ‘received’ on 16 February 2016. The court ordered that this amended notice of motion not be accepted for filing, primarily due to the procedural defects and the fact that it continued the pattern of vexatious conduct exhibited by Mr Quach. This decision was consistent with the court’s power to manage its caseload and prevent abuse of its processes.

In relation to Mr Quach’s notice to produce filed on 22 February 2016, the court set it aside. The setting aside of the notice to produce was based on the procedural failings and the court’s concern that Mr Quach’s actions were continuing a history of vexatious litigation. This decision aligned with the court's authority to manage its process to avoid unnecessary delays and costs.

The court also had to determine whether to dismiss the Commission’s notice of motion filed on 4 March 2016, other than in relation to costs. The court dismissed the motion in its entirety, except for the costs, reflecting its stance on the overall conduct of Mr Quach and the procedural irregularities in his applications.

Finally, the court directed the Registrar to vacate the return date of any further notices of motion filed by Mr Quach and to refer the matter to a judge to determine if a new return date should be set or if Mr Quach should be invited to show cause why his application should not be summarily dismissed as vexatious and an abuse of process. This directive aimed to manage the court’s resources and prevent further abuse of the judicial process by Mr Quach. The court’s decision was rooted in its inherent jurisdiction to control its own processes and prevent the abuse of its procedures.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this decision is that the court has the authority to manage its procedural processes and prevent abuse of its jurisdiction, particularly in cases of vexatious litigation. The court’s decisions were grounded in procedural principles and the need to maintain the integrity of its processes. The court departed from the procedural framework in Teoh v Hunters Hill Council (No 4) as it did not apply to the unique circumstances of this case.