QFHY and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 61 min read

QFHY and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 98 (31 January 2023)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2021/2306

Re:QFHY

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal:Senior Member D. Connolly

Date:31 January 2023

Place:Sydney

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review pursuant to paragraph 43(1)(a) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth).

......................................[SGD]..................................

Senior Member D. Connolly

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – reasonable and necessary supports –Applicant designed and proposed therapeutic approach – effective and beneficial – whether a sex worker for exposure therapy and sexual education is a reasonable and necessary support

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth)

CASES

McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] FCA 308
National Disability Insurance Agency v WRMF [2020] FCAFC 79

WRMF and National Disability Insurance Agency [2019] AATA 1771 (8 July 2019)

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Kendra Cherry, ‘Gynophobia: The Fear of Women’, Verywellmind (online) (2022) < Wotton, Sex workers who provide services to clients with disability in New South Wales, Australia (Master’s Thesis, University of Sydney, 2016)

Society of Clinical Psychology, Diagnosis: Specific Phobias; Treatment: Exposure Therapies for Specific Phobias (online) <

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member D. Connolly

31 January 2023

BACKGROUND TO REVIEW

  1. The Applicant is a 36-year-old man who became a participant of the National Disability Insurance Scheme (the NDIS) in 2018 on the basis of Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) (level 2) and a mild intellectual disability.[1] He also has a history of trauma and exhibits symptoms consistent with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD).[2] He currently resides near Brisbane.[3]

    [1] Tender Bundle (‘TB’) A6, p 2.

    [2] T3, p 79.

    [3] TB A6, p 12.

  2. Consistently throughout his engagement with the National Disability Insurance Agency (the Agency) the Applicant has made it clear he wishes to build his social skills to improve his participation in the community. One of the Applicant’s specific goals is to develop interpersonal skills that might assist him to develop a romantic heterosexual relationship.[4] He faces challenges in socialising with women, associated with ASD, and can become highly anxious.[5] He has designed a therapeutic approach, the Pairing Intimacy Sexual Education Guide (the Guide), a combination of cognitive behaviour therapy (CBT) and exposure therapy, to address these challenges.[6] Part of his approach is to engage the services of a sex worker to practise the social and communication skills taught to him by his therapist, along with a sexual component.[7] He has stated that he does not expect the sex worker to provide any therapeutic intervention; nor does he expect to form a romantic connection with the sex worker.[8]

    [4] Ibid, p 4.

    [5] TB A5, p 4.

    [6] TB A6.

    [7] Ibid, pp 9-17.

    [8] See TB A6 and TB A7, p 1.

  3. While the Applicant initially sought funding for four hours per month for a sex…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read QFHY and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 98
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered the dispute between QFHY (the applicant) and the National Disability Insurance Agency (the respondent) regarding the provision of reasonable and necessary supports under the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) Act. The applicant sought funding for a sex worker to be used as part of a therapeutic approach, termed "the Guide," designed by the applicant to address challenges in communicating with and relating to women, stemming from autism and associated cognitive and psychosocial issues. This approach combined cognitive behavioural therapy with in vivo and graded exposure therapy, where the sex worker would simulate interactions with women through role-playing, including a sexual component.

The central legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the proposed support, specifically the engagement of a sex worker for exposure therapy and associated costs for a support worker, constituted a "reasonable and necessary support" under subsection 34(1) of the NDIS Act. To determine this, the Tribunal was required to consider the factors outlined in subsection 34(1), including whether the support would be effective and beneficial for the applicant, aligned with current good practice, and represented value for money. The Tribunal also had to consider relevant rules, including those pertaining to the quality and safety of supports.

The Tribunal's reasoning focused on the evidence presented, including expert reports and the applicant's own detailed explanations of his proposed therapeutic model. While acknowledging the applicant's innovative approach and the potential for psychological benefit, the Tribunal was not satisfied that the proposed support would be effective and beneficial, nor that it met the threshold of "current good practice" as required by the NDIS Act. The Tribunal found that the applicant's proposed exposure therapy, involving a sex worker, had not been sufficiently researched, reviewed, or tested by qualified professionals. Expert opinion, particularly from a consultant forensic psychiatrist, raised concerns about the lack of a therapeutic framework, the potential for harm through unpredictable interactions and rejection, and the absence of established ethical guidelines in the proposed engagement. The Tribunal distinguished the applicant's case from a previous decision (WRMF) where a similar support was considered, noting significant differences in the underlying reasons for seeking the support and the applicant's lack of lived experience with the proposed therapy.

Ultimately, the Tribunal affirmed the respondent's decision, finding that the applicant had not satisfied the requirements of section 34(1) of the NDIS Act. Consequently, the Tribunal was not satisfied that funding for a sex worker to engage in exposure therapy, or the associated support worker costs, constituted a reasonable and necessary support under the NDIS.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The issue to be decided in this case is whether the funding for a sex worker (and associated support worker costs) is a reasonable and necessary support pursuant to subsection 34(1) of the NDIS Act. In deciding whether factors in subsection 34(1) of the NDIS Act are satisfied, I must also consider whether the relevant rules, set out above, are met, as required by paragraph 33(5)(d) of the NDIS Act. CONSIDERATION OF the EVIDENCE Material before the Tribunal The evidence before the Tribunal includes the Applicant’s NDIS plans approved on 17 April 2020, 11 November 2020 and 18 March 2021 filed by the Respondent and the Tender Bundle filed by the Respondent on 8 November 2022. The Tender Bundle comprises seven statements by the Applicant, including documents describing in detail the Guide, a letter and a review of the Guide by Dr Y, the Applicant’s psychologist, a report prepared by Mr A, a general and psychosexual counsellor, a letter from Ms W, psychologist, and a Master’s thesis titled ‘Sex workers who provide services to clients with disability in New South Wales, Australia’ by Ms Rachel Wotton. The Applicant has also filed two submissions in response to submissions from the Respondent, and an email from Professor Tony Attwood, psychologist. The Respondent’s material includes documents provided to the Tribunal by the Applicant, as required by section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act1975 (Cth) (the T Documents), an expert report by Dr R, a consultant forensic psychiatrist who undertook an independent assessment at the Respondent’s request, along with summonsed material including clinical notes made by Dr Y. The Respondent has also provided a statement of facts, issues and contentions. The Tribunal has also been provided with a report from Dr Y dated 26 July 2021, filed by the Applicant on 29 July 2021. A hearing was held by video conference on 15 November 2022. The Applicant (accompanied by his support person, Mr A) and Dr R gave oral evidence at the hearing.The supports sought by the Applicant The Applicant has developed a therapeutic approach, the Guide, a combination of CBT and exposure therapy, to address fears and challenges he faces in communicating with and relating to women. He has provided various statements and documents describing the support he seeks and explaining its rationale. In a statement dated 12 May 2020 the Applicant described the two therapies, his social deficits associated with autism, his cognitive deficits, his psychosocial issues, and what he hopes to achieve from his approach.[14] [14] TB A1. The Applicant’s proposal involves four steps. He summarised his approach in an email to Professor Tony Attwood, psychologist, in part as follows:…I have come up with the therapy that combines cognitive behaviour therapy and exposure therapy. My regular clinical psychologist calls the exposure therapy component in vivo and graded exposure based on the 4 activities I have come up with.The unconventional part is I would be using a qualified sex worker at a registered Brothel as my test subject.The cognitive behaviour therapy would be done with the clinical psychologist and both psychologist and sex worker would be working in their respective industries[.] The exposure therapy would be conducted by the sex worker…The sex worker would be representing your everyday woman in form of role playing, in activities that [I think are the] basic fundamentals of interaction and courting the opposite sex.1.Learning to introduce oneself and practice engaging in small talk2.Practicing asking a woman out for coffee or lunch and simulating having coffee or having lunch3.Practice asking a woman out for dinner and simulating said activity4.sexual component…[15][15] Email from the Applicant to Professor Tony Attwood, dated 26 October 2021.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I have considered the evidence the Applicant has provided regarding treatment for gynophobia. However I note the Applicant’s own statement that he is not implying he has gynophobia, he is merely presenting evidence that conditions such as gynophobia can be treated with CBT and exposure therapy. While I am not satisfied the Applicant has gynophobia, I note the article he provided does not suggest using a sex worker for exposure therapy in the way in which the Applicant intends. The article discusses graded exposure that includes hearing audio of women talking, watching videos of women, and, finally, going to places where women are present. It also states “your therapist will guide you in practicing relaxation techniques to help ease anxiety symptoms that arise”[153], suggesting the therapist is present during the exposure therapy.[153] Kendra Cherry, ‘Gynophobia: The Fear of Women’, Verywellmind (online) (2022) <>I am not satisfied the published evidence on exposure therapy, provided by the Applicant, supports his assertions that his four step approach, engaging a sex worker for exposure therapy, will be effective and beneficial.I have considered Professor Attwood’s email and note he agrees with the Applicant that he has developed an “unconventional therapy for autistic men”[154]. While I accept Professor Attwood expressed a view that the Guide has the potential to be of considerable psychological benefit to autistic individuals, I am not satisfied this reaches the threshold required, that the support will be, or is likely to be, effective and beneficial. I am of the view Professor Attwood’s response strongly suggests the approach needs to be researched.[154] Email from Professor Tony Attwood to the Applicant, dated 2 November 2021.I have taken into account the Applicant’s views that his therapy is innovative and therefore should be supported in accordance with the objects and principles of the NDIS Act. On his own evidence his proposal could be ‘ground-breaking’. However I am not satisfied the references to innovative supports in paragraph 3(1)(g) and innovation in subsection 4(15) of the NDIS Act were intended to include supports that have not been researched, reviewed and tested. I note paragraph 3(1)(g) of the NDIS Act also refers to supports being ‘high quality’ and subsection 4(15) refers to ‘contemporary best practice’. Most significantly paragraph 34(1)(d) requires the CEO to have regard to current good practice. I am of the view it is not possible to consider whether a support is high quality, contemporary best practice or current good practice if it has not been tested and reviewed by qualified professionals. While I accept the Applicant’s proposal is innovative and might be effective, I am persuaded by the Respondent’s submission that therapies need to be “tested by highly qualified professionals bound by professional and ethical obligations. All psychiatric and psychological therapies are rigorously scrutinised before being accepted by the profession as appropriate. And they are administered by properly trained professionals and para-professionals.”[155][155] Closing Submission, filed by the Respondent on 28 November 2022, p 9.The Applicant has indicated a view that I should not rely on Dr R’s opinion because she is not an expert in autism. I am not persuaded by this. I have taken into account Dr R’s qualifications as a consultant forensic psychiatrist with expertise in the use of various therapies. She also stated in her oral evidence that many of her own patients experience anxiety, and have ASD, and other conditions prohibiting them from living the authentic way that they wish to live.[156] I am satisfied Dr R has the appropriate knowledge, experience and expertise expected of an expert witness. I am satisfied her opinion is relevant to the consideration required by rule 3.3.[156] Transcript of Proceedings (15 November 2022), p 26.The Applicant has expressed concerns that he did not spend sufficient time with Dr R. I note from her report that the Applicant displayed well-organised thought processes, normal in rate, and was expansive, providing lengthy responses to questions. In her view his cognitive function “demonstrated an adequate level of attention, concentration, memory and comprehension through the assessment and he was able to relay a cogent history.”[157] Dr R’s report demonstrates the Applicant was able to describe his relevant history and his proposal. Having regard to her written and oral evidence I am satisfied the Applicant had an adequate opportunity to give his views and arguments regarding his proposal. I am not satisfied the Applicant spending any longer with Dr R would have persuaded her that his approach is good practice, or will be, or is likely to be, effective and beneficial.[157] TB R2, p 3.For the reasons given above I accept that Dr R is qualified to give an expert opinion and undertook an independent assessment on which I can rely. Accordingly I have taken into account her views about a number of concerns arising in this case, as discussed below.I have concerns about how realistic the Applicant is about the efficacy of this approach. The Applicant explained he is not suggesting the sex worker provide therapeutic support, only assist with the exposure therapy by role play. He does not think he needs the ‘safety net’ that psychodrama provides. However I am persuaded by Dr R’s view that if the Applicant engages in role play to deal with extreme anxiety there should be established a frame of safety, a therapeutic relationship, and a space where his anxieties, fears, and desires can be explored. I am not persuaded that this should take place with an untrained person, as proposed by the Applicant. I also note from the Applicant’s evidence that he feels “sex workers are most appropriate considering that all she has to do is act like herself, like a woman, like every other woman that is here in Australia.”[158] I have also taken into account his comments that, in the general public, not every woman dresses, speaks and acts like a therapist. I am not satisfied that intimate human interaction is predictable and formulaic and can be learned in the sessions as proposed by the Applicant. I agree with Dr R’s view that if a “paid worker responds positively, that might reinforce that [the Applicant’s] language or behaviour is appropriate. It may very well be the case that it is not and a woman acting of agency and autonomy would respond to it completely differently”.[159] [158] Transcript of Proceedings (15 November 2022), p 32.[159] Transcript of Proceedings (15 November 2022), p 23.I also have concerns about the analogy the Applicant draws, with his approach and role playing “generated in training of retail staff, nurses and possibly doctors, practically anybody including therapists in their training in their chosen profession.”[160] I am not satisfied these examples are as complex, unpredictable and nuanced as intimate personal relationships.[160] Closing Submission, filed by the Applicant on 10 December 2022, p 19.Dr R confirmed that she was not aware of any recognition of the Applicant’s approach in the literature. In her view it is not an efficacious treatment. She expressed concern that the exposure component of the approach was not going to be conducted by a trained therapist. She was concerned about transference and countertransference. She did not believe the proposal would teach the Applicant about organic social cues, his desirability, or how to manage situations leading on from those social interactions. I note the Applicant’s view – that he suspects it would put a lot of pressure on the therapist if transference were to occur, as he understands that having an intimate relationship with a therapist is not permitted. However I am concerned about his statement that “if transference occurred with the sex worker, after that therapy is completed, it wouldn’t matter because in that regard there’s no ethical guidelines that a sex worker has to walk. To a degree, there’s ethical guidelines that a sex worker has to follow, but not in a therapeutic sense.”[161] I am of the view this suggests some ambiguity in relation to the Applicant’s expectations of the engagement. [161] Transcript of Proceedings (15 November 2022), pp 30-31.I take into account the Applicant’s statement in part that:not only will the sex worker act in a positive way, but there are certain situations that I am being rejected from the sex worker. That’s the way that I can be exposed in various ways to being rejected and I can learn ways for myself on how to cope with those rejections…That being said, for an autistic person, one of the greatest flaws that we have or greatest difficulties that we have is that we’re not impressed with situations - we’re happy with situations that are predictable. Where we don’t function terribly well is where the situations are unpredictable. What I’m suggesting with my therapy proposal [is] providing ways of seeing situations that are unpredictable and being able to learn to address them appropriately…I’m aware of some of the flaws of my autism, I’m trying to remedy that through the therapy proposal. Part of that is my anxiety. Another part of it is the unpredictable nature of socialising and being in front of it and in person in the moment allows me to learn in a practical way. Simply by talking to me I don’t know how it - how I’m going to learn it without seeing it…I’m a visual learner. I learn by doing things. I’m not academically strong…my strengths in learning are in practical ways...[162][162] Transcript of Proceedings (15 November 2022), pp 33-34.In considering this I note Dr R raised concerns about the prospect of harm if the approach is engaged, in that the Applicant may experience rejection at the end of the artificial relationship. In her view “that rejection can be experienced quite significantly if a hope and attachment have been placed on the interaction….it possibly could further widen the chasm between [the Applicant’s] understanding of his desirability and how to interact in the real world, so to speak, with women and how they respond to his cues.”[163] I am guided by her opinion and have formed the view that there may be a prospect of harm if the approach is engaged. I have concerns that the support sought might cause harm and this raises doubts as to whether it can be considered ‘good practice’.[163] Ibid, p 23.The Applicant has asserted that WRMF mirrors his request for support and bears strong similarities to his case. I disagree with this view. The facts in that case are distinguishable from the Applicant’s. As the Tribunal in that case stated, the circumstances affecting WRMF were very unusual. WRMF’s disability was associated with MS and other physical medical conditions. As reported by the Tribunal, WRMF sought the services of a specially trained sex therapist, as a partner from the community would be unlikely, because of special features of the case, to be willing or able to provide the kind of services the applicant requires in order to obtain sexual release. Nor, if she ever found a partner, would she be able to sexually stimulate the partner, because of matters referred to in the confidential reasons. Her condition also prevents her from masturbation.[164][164] WRMF and National Disability Insurance Agency [2019] AATA 1771 (8 July 2019) at [7].This is not the case for the Applicant. He has asserted that he wants to engage the services of a sex worker to ultimately assist him to enter a romantic intimate relationship. His reasons for engaging a sex worker are very different to those of WRMF, who essentially sought sexual release. Dr R reports that the Applicant denies any problems achieving or maintaining erections and that he masturbates. The Applicant has not asserted that he has any physical condition that prevents him from achieving sexual release independently. The Applicant seeks the support to engage in exposure therapy. This bears no similarity to WRMF’s reasons for seeking the support.WRMF had lived experience of her proposed support, relevant to rule 3.2(b). She gave evidence of her use of specialised sex workers. The Applicant in this case does not have lived experience of using a sex worker for his proposal. He hopes that the proposed support will improve his interpersonal skills and reduce his anxiety around women. I note he visited the brothel once to make arrangements and admits that it was nerve-racking. I am not satisfied the Applicant has lived experience of his proposed support, as WRMF did.I gave the Applicant an opportunity to comment on the concern that WRMF may be distinguished from his case. In response he indicated that he understood the facts in that case but his autism makes it difficult to meet and interact with potential partners, which is the same as WRMF’s situation. He referred to articles indicating the benefits for disabled people from interactions with sex workers. Having regard to Ms Wotton’s Master’s thesis I accept that there may be benefits for disabled people from interactions with sex workers. However I am not satisfied her report, or any other articles provided by the Applicant, demonstrate there may be benefit from working with a sex worker to engage in exposure therapy for the purpose the Applicant has stated.I have considered Dr R’s expert opinion and find it to be persuasive. I have formed the view that, while the support sought to facilitate the exposure therapy component of the Applicant’s Guide might be innovative and reflect choice, I am not satisfied a sex worker would necessarily be able to work with any acute anxiety the Applicant experiences. I am concerned that the Applicant would not be provided with the standard of care in managing his anxiety should it be exacerbated by the proposed exposure therapy. I am not satisfied the Applicant will learn anything about his desirability or ability to connect with a woman intimately from an artificially generated relationship. I am concerned about his view that if transference occurred with the sex worker, it would not matter because in that regard there are “no ethical guidelines that a sex worker has to walk.”[165] I am not satisfied the Applicant’s proposal will prepare him to negotiate the challenges and nuances of intimate relationships with women with agency and autonomy. I am also concerned that his proposal lacks measurable outcomes. [165] Transcript of Proceedings (15 November 2022), pp 31-32.Overall, for the reasons set out above, I am not satisfied engaging a sex worker for the graded exposure therapy component of the Guide, designed by the Applicant, will be, or is likely to be, effective and beneficial for the Applicant, having regard to current good practice. Accordingly I am not satisfied s 34(1)(d) is met.CONCLUSIONAs I am not satisfied a factor in s 34(1) is met, I am not satisfied the support sought by the Applicant, funding for a sex worker to engage in exposure therapy to provide assistance in developing skills and confidence, is a reasonable and necessary support. Accordingly I am not satisfied the support sought to facilitate this, a support worker to drive him to and from the sessions, is a reasonable and necessary support. DECISION The Tribunal affirms the decision under review pursuant to paragraph 43(1)(a) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth). I certify that the preceding one hundred and forty-three (143) paragraphs are a true copy of the reasons for the decision herein of Senior Member D. Connolly ....................................SGD....................................AssociateDated: 31 January 2023 Date(s) of hearing: 15 November 2022 Date final submissions received: 10 December 2022 Counsel for the Respondent: Mr M Costello Solicitors for the Respondent: Mr K-W Kim

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established