QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited v Shah

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read
DETERMINATION OF REVIEW PANEL
CITATION: QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited v Shah [2023] NSWPICMP 129
CLAIMANT: Bhanprakash Shah

INSURER:

QBE Insurance Australia Limited

REVIEW Panel
MEMBER: Susan McTegg
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: Michael Couch
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: Les Barnsley
DATE OF DECISION: 5 April 2023
CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS – The claimant sustained injury on 12 February 2014 in a rear end collision; Medical Assessor (MA) Burns in a certificate dated 21 January 2020 assessed a 20% whole person impairment (WPI) for injury to the left shoulder, injury to the right shoulder and for right sided trochanteric bursitis; Justice Fagan in QBE v Shah remitted matter on basis of inadequate reasons and failure to address the surveillance and was critical of the lack of scientific or critical reasoning applied; dispute referred to MA Harrington who assessed a 34% WPI in respect of injury to the left shoulder, the right shoulder and the right knee; he found any soft tissue injury to the right hip had resolved; Panel asked to review the certificate of MA Harrington; insurer raised questions of causation in respect of injuries to the right shoulder, the right knee and the right hip; Held – Panel concerned about reliability of the claimant’s evidence; inconsistencies on examination and on surveillance footage; Mr Shah described being hit “square on”; Panel found full thickness rotator cuff bilateral tears with supraspinatus retraction were long standing and not caused by accident; Panel found accident caused aggravation of the underlying rotator cuff pathology in both shoulders; right knee pain due to pre-existing lateral compartment osteoarthritis; following accident claimant able to mobilise; in absence of substantial articular injury or evidence of any forceful impact Panel found accident was not more than a negligible cause of the lateral compartment osteoarthritis; Panel found claimant did not injure right knee in accident; Panel found pre-existing greater trochanteric bursitis not aggravated by accident in absence of evidence he struck knee in accident and in absence of evidence of injury such as bruising; Panel found accident not cause injury to right knee or right hip; Panel found injury to left and right shoulders and assessed WPI by joint crepitation at 6% WPI.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:  

Medical Assessment – Permanent Impairment

Review Panel Certificate
Issued under part 3.4 of the Motor Accident Compensation Act 1999 following a review under s 63 as to whether the degree of permanent impairment of the injured person as a result of the injury caused by the motor accident is greater than 10%

The Panel revokes the Certificate of Medical Assessor Christopher Harrington dated 29 June 2022 and issues a new certificate determining that the following injuries were caused by the motor accident and do not give rise to a whole person impairment (WPI) which is not greater than 10% but give rise to a WPI of 6%:

·        injury to the left shoulder, and

·        injury to the right shoulder.

The Panel determines that the following injuries were not caused by the motor accident:

·        injury to the right knee, and

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited v Shah and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPICMP 129
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited v Shah, the dispute centred on the assessment of whole person impairment (WPI) following a motor accident. The claimant, Mr Shah, had been involved in a rear-end collision on 12 February 2014 and subsequently sought compensation for injuries sustained. The matter was referred to a Medical Assessor (MA) who issued a certificate assessing a 20% WPI for injuries to the left shoulder, right shoulder, and right-sided trochanteric bursitis. The insurer, QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited, challenged the assessment, arguing that it was inadequate and failed to properly consider the surveillance footage and the lack of scientific reasoning. The court referred the matter back for reassessment.

The primary legal issues for determination were the proper assessment of WPI and the causation of the injuries claimed. The court had to consider whether the injuries alleged by Mr Shah were a result of the motor accident or pre-existing conditions, and whether the original assessment adequately addressed the evidence presented. The insurer questioned the causation of injuries to the right shoulder, right knee, and right hip. The court was tasked with reviewing the evidence and determining whether the original assessment was flawed and whether the reassessment by the MA was appropriate.

Upon review, the court found concerns regarding the reliability of Mr Shah's evidence, citing inconsistencies between his account of the accident and the surveillance footage. The Panel concluded that certain injuries, such as the full thickness rotator cuff tears with supraspinatus retraction, were long-standing and not caused by the accident. The Panel found that the accident had caused an aggravation of the underlying rotator cuff pathology in both shoulders. They determined that the right knee pain was due to pre-existing lateral compartment osteoarthritis and that the accident did not cause injury to the right knee or right hip. The Panel assessed the WPI by joint crepitation at 6% WPI for the injuries to the left and right shoulders.

The court ordered that the claim for WPI be assessed as 6% for injuries to the left and right shoulders. The insurer was directed to pay the assessed amount, and the claim for other injuries was dismissed. The court’s decision highlighted the importance of thorough evidence assessment and the necessity for medical assessments to be supported by robust scientific reasoning.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.